IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY
CRI-2014-485-87 [2015] NZHC 3269
IN THE MATTER OF an application to cancel and substitute
sentence under s 80F(1)(c) Sentencing Act
2002BETWEEN
THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS Applicant
AND
SEAN MCKAY Respondent
Hearing: 17 December 2015 Counsel:
A R Winsley for Applicant
P J Knowsley for RespondentResentencing:
17 December 2015
RESENTENCING NOTES OF WILLIAMS J
[1] Mr McKay you pleaded guilty on 29 July 2015 to one count of injuring with intent to injure. I considered that a sentence of home detention was appropriate in your case and I sentenced you to six months’ home detention accordingly.
[2] The Department of Corrections has applied to cancel your sentence and substitute it with a sentence of imprisonment. In addition, the charge of breach of home detention conditions has been transferred from the District Court to me to be dealt with here today, and you have pleaded guilty to that charge.
[3] The Department says you have failed more than once to comply with conditions of sentence: specifically the condition of attending drug and alcohol counselling as directed by a Probation Officer. Given that an important element in
your home detention sentence was your need for drug and alcohol rehabilitation,
THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS v MCKAY [2015] NZHC 3269 [17 December 2015]
indeed the most significant element in my thinking when I sentenced you to home detention, and I am bound to consider that these breaches are significant.
[4] I do know now that you accept the inevitability of a short period of imprisonment must follow but I am going to record how we got to this point for the record.
[5] It seems that yours has been a high maintenance sentence from the perspective of the Department. According to the affidavit of Ms Gaskin, the Department has serious concerns about whether your home detention sentence, the sentence itself, and the address continue to be suitable:
(a) There was an incident at your home detention address on
21 November 2015 in which you were said to have pushed your mother and kicked her car. Your mother of course said that the push was a tiny push and was being overblown. But I have come to know your mother over the last few months and am full of respect for her because I know how difficult it is to stand by you as you keep putting your toe across the touchline. But she has. My perspective on this is that she (understandably, as all mothers are), is guilty of minimising your faults for your own protection, and because she loves you so much. And I expect that her rendition of that incident is an example of that. Importantly in the record as I have it, the police reflect that you, during the course of this sentence, appear to be controlling of your mother and manipulative of her. There are concerns as to your mother’s ongoing safety and to some extent at least the stress…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Department of Corrections v McKay and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] NZHC 3269
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the original sentence of home detention should be cancelled and replaced with a term of imprisonment. The court had to consider the reasons for the original sentence, the nature of the breaches, and whether a term of imprisonment would be more appropriate given the circumstances.
Justice Williams, who presided over the case, noted that the original sentence was based on McKay's need for drug and alcohol rehabilitation. The breaches of the home detention conditions, especially the failure to attend counselling sessions, indicated that the home detention was not suitable. The court also considered the high maintenance nature of McKay's sentence, including incidents involving his mother and the presence of undesirable associates at his residence. Ultimately, the court concluded that home detention was no longer appropriate and resentenced McKay to six months' imprisonment, taking into account the time already served. The court emphasized that further punishment would not serve a purpose and that the decision to change his life was ultimately up to McKay.
In summary, the court resentenced McKay to six months' imprisonment on the original charge, with the sentence to commence immediately. On the charge of breach of home detention, McKay was convicted and discharged. The final sentence remains six months' imprisonment. Upon release, McKay will be required to attend any alcohol and drug counselling or other services directed by the Department of Corrections.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi