Deo Gratias Developments Limited v Tower Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2015-404-002088 [2018] NZHC 767

BETWEEN DEO GRATIAS DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED
Plaintiff

AND

TOWER INSURANCE LIMITED

First Defendant

AND

EARTHQUAKE COMMISSION

Second Defendant

CIV-2016-409-000722

BETWEEN

K B THORPE & ANOR
Plaintiffs

AND

EARTHQUAKE COMMISSION

First Defendant

AND

AA INSURANCE LIMITED

Second Defendant

CIV-2016-404-000984

BETWEEN

J E FRAMPTON & ANOR
Plaintiffs

AND

TOWER INSURANCE LIMITED

First Defendant

AND

EARTHQUAKE COMMISSION

Second Defendant

DEO GRATIAS DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED v TOWER INSURANCE LIMITED [2018] NZHC 767 [23 April 2018]

CIV-2016-404-001786

BETWEEN

A S AULD & ANOR

Plaintiffs

AND

IAG NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

First Defendant

AND

EARTHQUAKE COMMISSION

Second Defendant

Hearing: 16 February 2018

Appearances:

GDR Shand for Plaintiffs

M Hayes and K S Rouch for EQC Counsel for other parties excused

Judgment:

23 April 2018


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE OSBORNE

[costs and disbursements]


Costs application

[1]                 Four sets of plaintiffs seek orders for the payment of costs and disbursements by the Earthquake Commission (EQC) as the second defendant (behind each plaintiffs’ private insurer).

Background

[2]                 The plaintiffs all suffered damage in the Canterbury Earthquake Sequence. EQC subsequently made some payments for repairs to each of the plaintiffs but below EQC’s statutory cap. EQC denied further liability. The plaintiffs issued these proceedings against their respective private insurers and EQC.

[3]                 EQC after each of the proceedings was commenced made increased payments acceptable to the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs then discontinued their proceedings against

EQC. All plaintiffs have either since reached acceptable settlements or repair arrangements with their private insurers or (in one case) are close to that point.

[4]The plaintiffs are:

·in CIV-2015-404-2088 – Deo Gratias Developments Ltd (Deo Gratias);

·in CIV-2016-409-722 – Kevin Thorpe and another (the Thorpes);

·in CIV-2016-404-984 – James Frampton and another (the Framptons); and

·in CIV-2016-404-1786 – Angela Auld and another (the Aulds).

The plaintiffs’ costs and disbursements claims

[5]                 Upon settlement by EQC, the Thorpes, Framptons and Aulds sought costs from EQC calculated at 75 per cent of a 2B1 award, while Deo Gratias sought 50 per cent of 2B costs. All plaintiffs also sought payment of their disbursements, including variously expert witnesses’ and management fees.

[6]                 EQC initially rejected liability for any costs and disbursements claimed by Deo Gratias, the Framptons and the Aulds on the basis that, in these three proceedings, it was a litigation funder who may have incurred the “plaintiffs” costs and disbursements. In response to the Thorpes’ claim, EQC asserted that an award of 50 per cent of 2B costs and disbursements would be appropriate.

EQC’s position on costs and disbursements

[7]EQC now accepts that:

·the plaintiffs are entitled to awards of costs and disbursements as parties who have succeeded (it being inappropriate to apply the default rule for costs on a discontinuance);2


1      High Court Rules, Category 2 under r 14.3(1) and band B under r 14.5(2).

2      High Court Rules, r 15.12.

·contrary to EQC’s position before these applications were filed, the plaintiffs’ litigation funding arrangements in these…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Deo Gratias Developments Limited v Tower Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZHC 767
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Deo Gratias Developments Limited, along with three other plaintiffs, sought to recover costs and disbursements from the Earthquake Commission (EQC) as the second defendant in separate proceedings following settlements with their respective private insurers. EQC had made payments to the plaintiffs following the Canterbury Earthquake Sequence, but these payments were below the statutory cap. The plaintiffs subsequently discontinued their proceedings against EQC once they reached settlements with their insurers. EQC accepted that the plaintiffs were entitled to costs and disbursements as parties who had succeeded, but disagreed on the amount and proportion of costs to be awarded to each plaintiff.

The court considered the legal principles governing costs in discontinued proceedings, particularly the presumption under r 15.23 High Court Rules that a plaintiff who discontinues a proceeding must pay costs to the defendant. However, the court also recognised its residual discretion to make a different order if it was just and equitable to do so. The court adopted principles from relevant precedents, including the need for the plaintiff to persuade the court to exercise its discretion and the avoidance of assessing the respective strengths of the parties’ cases.

The court examined the submissions from both sides regarding the appropriate proportion of costs to be awarded to each plaintiff. The plaintiffs argued for a higher proportion of costs to be awarded to EQC, while EQC maintained that a 50 per cent award was appropriate. The court found that while a different approach to costs may be justified in certain circumstances, there was insufficient evidence to determine that EQC bore differing responsibility for the continuation of the proceedings in these cases. Therefore, the court concluded that it would not be just to order the defendants to pay more than 50 per cent of the plaintiffs’ costs.

The court also considered the plaintiffs' claims for disbursements, specifically the costs of reports obtained and paid for by the plaintiffs. The court found that these disbursements were incurred for the purposes of the proceeding, were reasonably necessary for the conduct of the proceeding, and were specific to the conduct of the proceeding. Therefore, the court awarded the disputed disbursements to the plaintiffs.

The court ordered EQC to pay the plaintiffs the following sums for costs and disbursements: Deo Gratias Limited $7,582.00 for costs and $7,774.48 for disbursements; James Edward Frampton and Ann Charlotte Vanschevensteen $7,582.00 for costs and $8,290.99 for disbursements; Kevin Byron Thorpe and Yvonne Teresa Thorpe $7,136.00 for costs and $4,731.73 for disbursements; and Angela Stanton Auld and Andrew Robert Auld $12,042.00 for costs and $10,396.55 for disbursements. EQC was also ordered to pay each plaintiff's costs and a one-quarter share of the disbursements reasonably incurred by the plaintiffs' solicitors in relation to the costs applications and the hearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.