De Alwis v Chean HC Auckland CIV 2007-404-5357

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2007-404-005357

BETWEEN HERALD VICTOR DE ALWIS First Plaintiff

AND

MARGARET ELIZABETH DE ALWIS AND HERALD VICTOR DE ALWIS Second Plaintiffs

AND

JOHN WAH KUM Third Plaintiff

AND

CONNIE FAY LING KUM Fourth Plaintiff

AND

MARSHA ADRIENNE TAI PING TAN Fifth Plaintiff

AND

PETER WEE Sixth Plaintiff

AND

PAUL SENG POH KHOR Seventh Plaintiff

AND

AI NEE CHEAN Defendant

Hearing:

24 March 2010

Appearances: No appearances for the First to Fifth and Seventh Plantiffs

G A D Neil for the Sixth Plaintiff
E Orlov and D Lee for the Defendant

Judgment:      31 March 2010 at 4:30 pm

JUDGMENT OF WYLIE J

This judgment was delivered by Justice Wylie 31 March 2010 at 4:30pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date:

H V DE ALWIS AND ORS V A N CHEAN HC AK CIV 2007-404-005357  31 March 2010

[1]      There are a number of applications before the Court.   Mr Wee, the sixth plaintiff, seeks orders:

a)        varying an asset preservation order made by Cooper J on 30 August

2007;

b)making final an interim charging order issued and sealed by this Court on 9 March 2010; and

c)        for the delivery up of the charged moneys.

[2]      The defendant, Mrs Chean, seeks the stay of a judgment given by the Court of Appeal on 24 February 2010.

[3]      Both parties oppose the other’s applications.

Background

[4]      This proceeding, and the wider litigation associated with it, has had a long and tortuous history.  That history is reviewed in part in the very recent judgment of Courtney J — De Alwis v Luvit Foods International Ltd.[1]    I have drawn from her Honour’s analysis.

[1] HC Auckland CIV-2002-404-001944 24 March 2010 at [6]-[9].

[5]      Mrs Chean’s husband, Mr Chean, was a director of a company known as

Luvit  Foods  International  Limited  (“Luvit”).    In  late  2001,  Mr  Wee  invested

$150,000 in Luvit.  The investment was not successful and Mr Wee and the other plaintiffs, who had also invested in the company, sought to recover their funds. They commenced proceedings in October 2002.   They alleged that Mr Chean had induced them to invest in Luvit by making representations about the company’s performance which were misleading and deceptive under the Fair Trading Act 1976. They also alleged breach of the Securities Act 1978.   It was said that a registered prospectus was required.  It was asserted that s 37(6) of the Securities Act required the repayment of the subscriptions within two months of receipt by the company,

and that the directors were fixed with joint and several liability in the event that repayment was not made.

[6]      The hearing was due to commence on 30 April 2007.  However, Mr Chean adjudicated himself bankrupt on 27 April 2007.  Counsel had no instructions, and he was granted leave to withdraw.  The matter proceeded by way of formal proof on

15 May 2007, and judgment was entered for all plaintiffs, including Mr Wee, on

23 May 2007.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read De Alwis v Chean HC Auckland CIV 2007-404-5357 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 1004
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the High Court of New Zealand in Auckland involves multiple plaintiffs seeking relief against the defendant, Mrs Chean. The plaintiffs, including Mr Wee, are seeking variations to asset preservation orders, finalisation of interim charging orders, and the delivery of charged moneys. Mrs Chean, on the other hand, has applied for a stay of the Court of Appeal's judgment. The legal issues at hand revolve around the validity and enforcement of asset preservation orders, the finalisation of charging orders, and the potential stay of the Court of Appeal's judgment. The Court considered whether the asset preservation orders should be varied to exclude the charged moneys, whether the interim charging order should be made final, and whether to grant a stay of the Court of Appeal's judgment.

The Court found that circumstances had substantially changed since the asset preservation orders were varied by Winkelmann J. The plaintiffs had successfully obtained judgments against Mrs Chean, and it was no longer uncertain that they would be able to do so. The Court concluded that Mr Wee was entitled to enforce his judgment and that it would be unjust for him to stand by while Mrs Chean's day-to-day living expenses were met out of the charged moneys. Consequently, the Court varied the asset preservation order to exclude all moneys charged to the benefit of Mr Wee and rescinded the variation order made by Winkelmann J on 5 June 2009. The Court also granted Mr Wee's application to have his interim charging order made final. The Court found that there was no good reason to refuse the application and exercised its discretion in favour of making the charging order final. Lastly, the Court declined Mrs Chean's application for a stay of the Court of Appeal's judgment, finding that there would be no substantial miscarriage of justice if the judgment were enforced.

In conclusion, the Court varied the asset preservation orders to exclude the charged moneys, made the interim charging order final, and declined to stay the Court of Appeal's judgment. Mr Wee was awarded costs on a 2B basis, along with his reasonable disbursements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established