Daisy Limited v Wellington Distributors Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2013-485-10075 [2014] NZHC 497

BETWEEN  DAISY LIMITED Applicant

ANDWELLINGTON DISTRIBUTORS LIMITED

Respondent

Hearing:                   13 March 2014

Counsel:                  J C La Hatte for applicant

N H Whalley for respondent

Judgment:                18 March 2014

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF DOBSON J

[1]      This was an application brought in reliance on s 290 of the Companies Act

1993 (the Act) to set aside a statutory demand served by the respondent (WDL) on the applicant (Daisy).

[2]      The statutory demand  was  served  on  22 November 2013  for the sum of

$134,463.68.  The demand relates to costs incurred by WDL as lessor in reinstating premises previously leased to Daisy in central Wellington, together with legal costs incurred by WDL’s solicitors in relation to the lease.

[3]      The setting aside was sought on the basis that Daisy did not owe the amount demanded to WDL, that the amount claimed was excessive and beyond any liability for reinstatement under the lease.  In addition, Daisy claimed that it had a set-off or counterclaim  in  respect  of misleading and  deceptive conduct  on WDL’s  part  in

dealings between them for a new lease on varied terms.

DAISY LTD v WELLINGTON DISTRIBUTORS LTD [2014] NZHC 497 [18 March 2014]

Adequacy of service of application

[4]      WDL took a preliminary jurisdictional point that Daisy’s application to set aside the statutory demand had not been served in accordance with the requirements under the Act, thereby rendering the proceedings a nullity.

[5]      In terms of s 290(2) and (3) of the Act, the application had to be made and served on the creditor within 10 working days of the date of service of the demand. The section specifies that no extension of time may be given for filing or serving such an application, and it is accepted that if that time limit is not complied with,

then the company loses its opportunity to set aside the statutory demand.1    In this

case,  Daisy  served  WDL  with  a  copy  of  the  application  within  the  requisite

10 working day period.   As served, the copy was incomplete in that it was  not endorsed with the “CIV number” allocated to the proceedings by the Court Registry, or the date on which the application would be called in Court.   In a separate communication the same day, those details were provided.

[6]      The challenge to adequacy of the service was argued on the basis that service of the incomplete copy did not comply, and the technical point was taken that strict compliance is required.

[7]      For WDL, Mr Whalley invited analogy with the reasoning in Hyro Australia Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Inland Revenue.2     In that case, a service copy of the application was unendorsed (apparently lacking the same details that can only be added after filing as were absent in the present case).  Advice of those details was only provided when the applicant served a further copy, duly endorsed with those details, after the 10 working day period had elapsed.

[8]      It…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Daisy Limited v Wellington Distributors Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 497
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand was asked to decide an application to set aside a statutory demand served by Wellington Distributors Limited (WDL) on Daisy Limited. WDL served a statutory demand for $134,463.68, which related to costs incurred by WDL as a lessor in reinstating premises previously leased to Daisy. Daisy sought to set aside the statutory demand on the basis that it did not owe the amount claimed, that the amount was excessive, and that it had a set-off or counterclaim in respect of WDL's alleged misleading conduct in dealings between them for a new lease on varied terms. The court had to decide whether the statutory demand could be set aside on the grounds that there was a substantial dispute as to whether the debt was owing, and whether Daisy had a counterclaim or set-off.

The court first considered whether Daisy's application to set aside the statutory demand had been served in accordance with the statutory requirements. WDL argued that the application was not served properly because it was not endorsed with certain details. However, Daisy had provided those details in a separate communication on the same day as the incomplete copy of the application was served. The court found that the challenge to the adequacy of service could not be sustained because WDL was not prejudiced in any respect in responding to the application, and because both communications were received within the time limit.

The court then considered whether there was a substantial dispute as to whether the debt cited in the statutory demand was owing. WDL argued that the reinstatement costs were reasonable and that Daisy could not dispute that some reinstatement work was required. However, the court found that there was a substantial dispute as to the reasonableness of the reinstatement costs, and that the statutory demand procedure should not be used to pre-empt a lessee's opportunity to test the justification for amounts claimed to be incurred in reinstating premises.

Finally, the court considered whether Daisy had a counterclaim or set-off. Daisy claimed that WDL had misrepresented the arrangements it was prepared to enter into for work on the premises and the terms of a new lease. However, the court found that the prospect of such a claim was more in the nature of a pre-emptive strike to provide a bargaining tool in negotiations with WDL, rather than a tenably based claim for actionable misleading conduct.

The court granted Daisy's application to set aside the statutory demand, and ordered that WDL pay Daisy's costs on a 2B basis, together with disbursements as approved by the Registrar.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.