Crow v Ministry of Primary Industries

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NEW PLYMOUTH REGISTRY

CRI-2013-043-001488 [2015] NZHC 571

BETWEEN

BRIAN TERENCE CROW

Appellant

AND

MINISTRY OF PRIMARY INDUSTRIES Respondent

Hearing: 4 February 2015

Appearances:

S W Hughes QC for Appellant
S A H Bishop & K E Martley for Respondent

Judgment:

26 March 2015

JUDGMENT OF KEANE J

This judgment was delivered by me on 26 March 2015 at 12pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

Crown Solicitor, Wellington

CROW v MINISTRY OF PRIMARY INDUSTRIES [2015] NZHC 571 [26 March 2015]

[1]      On 16 October 2014, after a hearing in the District Court, New Plymouth, Brian Crow was convicted by Judge Sygrove of two offences: selling to Nilesh Kumar on 8 February 2013 and on 8 March 2013 ‘animal product’, slaughtered and dressed goats, which he knew had not been processed as Parts 2 – 5 of the Animal Products Act 1999 require.  He was found not guilty of a third such offence on 15

February 2013.  He was sentenced to 150 hours community work.  He appeals his convictions.

[2]      Before the hearing Mr Crow admitted that on the three dates, the subject of the charges, he had sold live goats to Mr Kumar, with whom he was originally jointly charged: 11 goats on 8 February 2013, eight goats on 15 February 2013, and five goats on 8 March 2013.  He denied that he had sold Mr Kumar slaughtered and dressed goats; and that, as counsel agreed in a memorandum to the Judge, was the critical issue.  If all he had done was to sell Mr Kumar live goats he had not sold him

‘animal product’.

[3]      The Judge held Mr Crow had sold Mr Kumar ‘animal product’ on the two dates, because that was the result of those two sales, and of several earlier sales to others admitted as evidence of propensity.  On those two dates, and in most if not all of the earlier sales, the goats were slaughtered and dressed on Mr Crow’s property by the purchasers, often with Mr Crow’s help, and occasionally by Mr Crow himself. The Judge acquitted Mr Crow on the third charge because, while he had slaughtered a goat that day, that could have been as food for his dogs.

[4]      In his primary ground of appeal Mr Crow contends that the Judge was wrong in law, and consequently in fact, to hold that it was immaterial whether he had been paid for the goats while they were alive, or after they had been slaughtered and dressed.  Though he did not give evidence, he had said when interviewed that he had been paid for live goats and that, while he had allowed them to be slaughtered and dressed on his property, and had sometimes helped, that was not part of the bargain. The Judge could not on the evidence, he contends, be satisfied that it was.

[5]      Mr Crow’s second ground of appeal is contingent on his first.  He contends…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Crow v Ministry of Primary Industries and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 571
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Brian Terence Crow appeals his convictions in the District Court, New Plymouth, for selling to Nilesh Kumar on 8 February 2013 and 8 March 2013 'animal product', slaughtered and dressed goats, which he knew had not been processed as Parts 2 – 5 of the Animal Products Act 1999 require. The critical issue is whether Mr Crow sold live goats or slaughtered and dressed goats. If he sold live goats, he had not sold 'animal product'. The District Court Judge held that Mr Crow had sold Mr Kumar 'animal product' on the two dates, as the result of those sales was that Mr Kumar left with slaughtered and dressed goats. The Judge acquitted Mr Crow on the third charge because, while he had slaughtered a goat on that day, that could have been as food for his dogs.

The High Court considered whether the District Court Judge was correct in his interpretation of the word 'sale' as widely and purposively as he did, which the Act makes an offence. The Judge held that the sale was one in which the ultimate outcome was the delivery of 'animal product', regardless of when money changed hands. The Court found that the Judge was entitled to interpret the word 'sale' widely, having regard to the relevant object of the Act, which is to prevent the sale of 'animal product' in a state unfit for consumption. The Court also found that the Judge was entitled to rely on other evidence, including admissions Mr Crow made before the hearing, video surveillance evidence, and text messages, which were consistent with the Judge's findings.

The High Court dismissed Mr Crow's appeal and upheld his conviction. The Court found that the Judge made no error of law or of fact carrying any possibility of a miscarriage of justice.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established