Creative Development Solutions Limited v Chorus New Zealand Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2018-485-509

[2019] NZHC 2959

BETWEEN CREATIVE DEVELOPMENT SOLUTIONS LIMITED
Plaintiff

AND

CHORUS NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 2-6 September; 9-13 September; 17 September 2019

Counsel:

C L Elliott QC, M B Wigley and A Lenard for plaintiff

J B M Smith QC, V L Heine, T D Smith and S E Quilliam-Mayne for defendant

Judgment:

13 November 2019


RESERVED JUDGMENT OF DOBSON J

[Public Version]


CREATIVE DEVELOPMENT SOLUTIONS LTD v CHORUS NEW ZEALAND LTD [2019] NZHC 2959
[13 November 2019]

Contents

Introduction  [1]

The telecommunications industry in New Zealand  [8]

Creative/MDC initiatives  [20]

The witnesses, evidential objections  [23]

Dealings between the parties  [35]

Chorus’s internal conduct in the relevant period  [67]

Extent of the information conveyed  [104]

Further factual disputes  [122]

Would MDC pay for new infrastructure?  [122]

Who recommenced Chorus-CIP dialogue?  [129]

First cause of action: breach of fiduciary duty  [133]

Second cause of action: breach of the NDA  [144]

Extent of use of confidential information by Chorus  [171]

Observed change in Chorus’s behaviour  [174]

Use of confidential information made out?  [180]

Analysis of EEU numbers  [185]

Focus on regional development co-operation with WISPs  [188]

Unauthorised disclosure to Aird Towers  [191]

Use of Creative’s confidential information in seeking PGF funding, re-entry into RBI2+        [193]

Re-purposing Chorus assets  [196]

Summary on Chorus use of Creative’s confidential information  [201]
Third cause of action: equitable duty of confidentiality  [204]

Fourth cause of action: estoppel  [209]

The representation  [215]

Representation adequately precise?  [220]

Scope for equitable constraint  [222]

Would the representation found an anti-competitive arrangement?  [224]

Detriment suffered?  [227]

Result  [236]

Costs  [237]

Glossary of Abbreviations

Introduction

[1]    The plaintiff (Creative) operates as an adviser and consultant on provision of telecommunications services. It has researched and developed proposals for providing of extended telecommunications services, including ultra-fast broadband (UFB), in more remote parts of the areas covered by the Marlborough District Council (MDC), including the Marlborough Sounds.

[2]    The product of Creative’s work is its “Smart Services Infrastructure” initiative (SSI), which it describes in its statement of claim as:

… an initiative that pivots around telecommunications broadband services to underserved rural and remote regions and end users, based on a broader

collaborative and partnership approach aimed at larger social and economic objectives.

[3]    Creative has developed its SSI in collaboration with the MDC. MDC has contributed to the cost of its development, as well as providing information about the location and extent of potential end users of broadband services. Creative and MDC treat themselves as joint owners of the intellectual property reflected in SSI.

[4]    The defendant (Chorus) is a telecommunications network operator, providing wholesale telecommunications services, predominantly via fibre and copper, to retailers of telecommunications services. Chorus was created by a separation of the wholesale component of the former Telecom New Zealand business, with the retail component becoming the telecommunications services provider now known as Spark.

[5]    Creative, with MDC’s concurrence and participation, shared…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Creative Development Solutions Limited v Chorus New Zealand... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZHC 2959
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Creative Development Solutions Limited (Creative) sued Chorus New Zealand Limited (Chorus) for breach of a non-disclosure agreement (NDA), breach of fiduciary duty, breach of an equitable duty of confidentiality, and estoppel. The court dismissed all of Creative's claims. Creative alleged that it had shared confidential information about its Smart Services Infrastructure initiative with Chorus, and that Chorus used that information in breach of the NDA. The court found that the information provided by Creative was not confidential because it was either already in the public domain or already known to Chorus. Creative also alleged that Chorus owed it fiduciary duties, but the court found that the relationship between the parties was a commercial one, and not a fiduciary one. Creative also alleged that Chorus breached an equitable duty of confidentiality, but the court found that there was no misuse of the confidential information. Finally, Creative alleged that Chorus was estopped from competing with it for funding from the Crown Infrastructure Partners because Chorus had represented that it would not compete. The court found that there was no representation by Chorus that it would not compete, and that even if there had been, Creative had not suffered any detriment from the alleged breach of that representation.