Corbans Viticulture Ltd v Waihopai Valley Management Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND BLENHEIM REGISTRY

CIV-2010-406-000046 [2012] NZHC 2799

BETWEEN  CORBANS VITICULTURE LIMITED Plaintiff

ANDWAIHOPAI VALLEY MANAGEMENT LIMITED

First Named First Defendant

ANDACHILLIES VENTURES LIMITED, ATREIDES HOLDINGS LIMITED, BLICKS ROAD INVESTMENTS LIMITED, FARRAH INVESTMENTS LIMITED AND ORS TRADING AS PATRIARCH JOINT VENTURE Second Named First Defendant

ANDANTHONY LEWIS MOORE Second Defendant

ANDDEAN ALFRED STEELE Third Defendant

ANDBEN DOUGLAS Fourth Defendant

ANDDENNIS LUNKEN Counterclaim Defendant

Hearing:         15 October 2012

Appearances: L Ponniah for Plaintiff and Counterclaim Defendant

G M Downing for the first-named First Defendant and Second
Defendant
D J C Russ for second-named First Defendant
T R J Jeffcott for the Third and Fourth Defendants

Judgment:      24 October 2012

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE MATTHEWS

CORBANS VITICULTURE LIMITED V WAIHOPAI VALLEY MANAGEMENT LIMITED HC BLE CIV-

2010-406-000046 [24 October 2012]

[1]      This judgment determines the following interlocutory applications:

a)  By the second-named first defendant, the Patriarch Joint Venture, for security for costs against the plaintiff.

b) By the first-named first defendant, Waihopai Valley Management Limited, for security for costs against the plaintiff and the counterclaim defendant.

c)  By the third and fourth defendants, Mr Steele and Mr Douglas, for further security for costs against the plaintiff.

d) By the third and fourth defendants, Mr Steele and Mr Douglas, for leave to bring a summary judgment application against the plaintiff out of time.

e)  By Waihopai Valley Management Limited for further and better discovery by the plaintiff, and directing the plaintiff to answer interrogatories, and for costs on those applications.

[2]      There is a further application by the plaintiff for security for costs against the first-named first defendant in relation to its counterclaim.   The plaintiff maintains this should be the subject of direction to bring it to a hearing.     I understood at the fixture that counsel agreed it could be determined, but out of caution I defer consideration of it in this judgment.

[3]      As the last of these are largely resolved I will determine these first.   I will then deal with the applications for security for costs by the defendants, followed by the application for leave to bring summary judgment proceedings out of time.

Discovery and interrogatory issues

[4]      Answers to interrogatories which satisfy Waihopai’s request have now been provided.  One attachment is yet to be provided but is not expected to require further directions from the Court.  Costs are sought.

[5]      Waihopai still requires discovery and inspection of documents described in a letter from the plaintiff’s solicitor sent on 10 September, paragraph 1.8.   In that paragraph  the  documents  are  described  as  “all  correspondence  relating  to  the relevant period” but there is no further detail.  Mr Ponniah maintains that it is likely that once these documents are sorted it will be found that they have already been discovered.   Mr Downing says that whilst that may be the case, he is entitled to know whether it is or not, and to have discovery of any documents in this category which have not yet been discovered.

[6]      At…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Corbans Viticulture Ltd v Waihopai Valley Management Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 2799
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, the case of Corbans Viticulture Ltd v Waihopai Valley Management Ltd involved several interlocutory applications, including requests for security for costs, further and better discovery, and leave to bring a summary judgment application out of time. The plaintiff, Corbans Viticulture Ltd, sought to recover damages for the alleged breach of a viticulture contract, while the defendants, including Waihopai Valley Management Ltd and others, sought to defend the claim and counterclaim damages. The court considered the discovery and interrogatory issues first, finding that the plaintiff had not complied promptly with discovery obligations and awarding costs to the first-named first defendant. The court then turned to the applications for security for costs, examining the evidence presented by both parties and ultimately finding that there were sufficient reasons to believe that the plaintiff would be unable to pay the costs of the defendants if unsuccessful in the claim. The court exercised its discretion to order security for costs in favour of the defendants, with varying amounts awarded to each defendant and staged payment ordered. Lastly, the court declined to grant leave to issue a summary judgment application, finding that it would be unfair and costly to proceed with a parallel process while preparing for trial. The court made several orders, including the provision of further discovery, the payment of security for costs, and the dismissal of the application for leave to issue summary judgment.