IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE
CIV-2021-404-1142
[2025] NZHC 478
BETWEEN MARTIN REES COOPER
Plaintiff
AND
COOPER & CO REAL ESTATE ALBANY LIMITED
First Defendant
ZAIDONG RONG
Second Defendant
CIV-2021-404-1636 BETWEEN
TIEYING MA
First PlaintiffZAIDONG RONG
Second PlaintiffAND
MARTIN REES COOPER
First Defendant
Continued …
Hearing: 12–16 and 19–23 February 2024, 21–25 October, 29 and
31 October 2024
Appearances:
B J Burt, K D Puddle and X Zhu for the Plaintiff
S L Robertson KC, S F Pearson and G W Easton for Defendants R Idoine for the Third Party
Judgment:
12 March 2025
Reissued:
20 March 2025 in redacted and unredated versions
JUDGMENT OF MUIR J
This judgment was delivered by me on 20 March 2025 at 4 pm,
Pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court rules. Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date: ……………………………
COOPER v COOPER & CO REAL ESTATE ALBANY LIMITED [2025] NZHC 478 [12 March 2025]
COOPER & CO REAL ESTATE ALBANY LIMITED
Second Defendant
COOPER & CO. REAL ESTATE ALBANY LIMITED
Third Party
Table of Contents
Para No.
Introduction [1]
Background[10]
Purchase of the Albany Branch[10]
Operation of the Albany Branch[14]
Attempts to formalise the parties’ arrangements[25]
Incorporation of the Albany Company[32]
Operation of the Albany Company[33]
Separation of the parties[47]
Mr Meltzer’s report in detail [51]
Mr Meltzer’s mandate[53]
The written report[54]
Other allegations made by Mr Rong to Mr Meltzer after his appointment[116]
Mr Meltzer’s evidence in this Court[126]
First cause of action [138]
Introduction[138]
Ms Ma’s submission[145]
Mr Cooper’s response[148]
Limitation[151]
Brief consideration of underlying merits[164]
Second cause of action—the law [181]
Section 174 claims[184]
Limitation and s 174 claims[191]
Is the plaintiffs’ s 174 proceeding precluded by the principle of reflective loss?[204]
Creation of contracts by conduct[211]
Quantum meruit[219]
Second cause of action—the individual claims [224]
Overpaid rent and operating expenses[225]
Head office costs[245]
Vendor marketing expenses[306]
Recharges[313]
Franchise fee rebates[316]
Penalties for soliciting sales agents[327]
Profits from redirection of Company inquiries[348]
Loss of the franchise agreement[353]
Retained profits[359]
Purchase of the Silk rent roll[362]
Expenses incurred in 2017, 2018 and 2019[365]
Property management business payments[369]
Waitoki lease and copying costs[375]
The counterclaim[381]
Result[385]
Costs[387]
Introduction
This case represents a further salutary reminder (if ever that were required) of the perils of commencing joint enterprises without appropriate care being given to documenting the relationship.
Prior to the commencement of their joint venture, Ms Tieying (Matty) Ma was a successful real estate agent working in one of Harcourts Cooper & Co’s branch offices. Mr Martin Cooper had been equally successful in building Cooper & Co Real Estate Ltd (CCRE), based on the North Shore and operating under the “Harcourts Cooper & Co” brand.
In 2008 they jointly agreed to acquire Top Bays, a distressed real estate business in Albany. The decision proved to be a fruitful one, delivering millions of dollars of profits to the respective 50 per cent owners over the succeeding years and many millions of dollars more…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Cooper v Cooper & Co Real Estate Albany Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] NZHC 478
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was tasked with deciding whether there was a breach of fiduciary duty during the period when the business operated as a branch, and whether the conduct of CCRE amounted to unfair prejudice under section 174 of the Companies Act 1993 after the business was incorporated as a separate company. The court also had to address the reasonableness of head office costs charged by CCRE to the Albany Company and the appropriateness of various payments made by the Albany Company to CCRE.
The court concluded that there was no breach of fiduciary duty by Cooper, as the claim was barred by limitation. Furthermore, the court found that the plaintiffs did not establish unfair prejudice under section 174 of the Companies Act 1993 in relation to the head office costs or other charges. The court held that the head office costs charged by CCRE to the Albany Company were reasonable, and that there was no evidence to support the plaintiffs' claims of redirection of inquiries, loss of the franchise agreement, or unfair prejudice in respect of the purchase of the Silk rent roll and other expenses.
In relation to the counterclaim, the court awarded CCRE the sum of $432,000 for head office services provided and not paid for by the Albany Company. The court also awarded the plaintiffs $71,270.90 for franchise fee rebates that had been incorrectly deposited to CCRE's account by the franchisor, Harcourts Group Ltd.
The court's judgment reflects the importance of documenting joint ventures and business relationships to avoid future disputes. It also highlights the need for careful consideration of limitation periods and the application of the principles of unfair prejudice under the Companies Act 1993. The case serves as a reminder of the potential consequences of failing to formalize agreements and the importance of clear communication and cooperation between business partners.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi