Cookson v Simmons HC Wellington CIV-2011-485-283

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2011-485-283

BETWEEN  VINCENT BLAIR COOKSON AND BRUCE HOWARD JENSEN AS TRUSTEES OF VINCENT COOKSON TRUST

Plaintiffs

ANDLORNE PERRY SIMMONS, NICOLE LYNLEY SIMMONS AND LIAM MICHAEL O'KEEFFE

Defendants

Hearing:         22 June 2011

(Heard at Wellington)

Counsel:         G. Dewar - Counsel for Plaintiff

K. Sullivan - Counsel for Defendant

Judgment:      4 August 2011 at 3:00 PM

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE D.I. GENDALL

This judgment was re-issued by Associate Judge D.I. Gendall on 4 August 2011 at

3.00 pm under r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Solicitors:           Thomas Dewar, Solicitors, PO Box 31-240, Lower Hutt

Duncan Cotterill, Solicitors, PO Box 10376, Wellington

VB COOKSON AND BH JENSEN AS TRUSTEES OF VINCENT COOKSON TRUST V LORNE PERRY SIMMONS, NICOLE LYNLEY SIMMONS AND LIAM MICHAEL O'KEEFFE HC WN CIV-2011-485-283 4

August 2011

Introduction

[1]      Before the Court is a summary judgment application by the plaintiffs seeking a modest sum for interest and costs from the defendants.  That application is opposed by the defendants.

[2]      The plaintiff’s principal claim in this proceeding has now been resolved but a reasonably  small  issue  concerning  that  additional  claim  for  interest  and  costs remains.

Background

[3]      Some time ago, the plaintiffs and the defendants were in a partnership called “The Next Door II Partnership” which developed a property at Sydney Street, Petone as  a  carparking  and  warehouse  facility.    After  development,  the  property  was occupied by interests associated with the defendants as to the carpark, and by a company controlled by the plaintiff, Virtual Plumbing Limited (Virtual Plumbing) as to the warehouse facility.  Virtual Plumbing conducted its plumbing business from this facility.

[4]      Issues arose between the parties which led to litigation.  This was eventually settled under the terms of a Settlement Agreement dated 17 November 2010 (the Settlement Agreement).    Under the terms  of that  settlement,  the plaintiffs were entitled to call on the defendants to purchase their interest in the Sydney Street property for an agreed sum which they did on 23 November 2010.  The defendants through their solicitor confirmed then that settlement of the purchase would occur on

23 December 2010.

[5]      On 15 December 2010, however, the defendants advised that they would not be able to settle on 23 December 2010.  At that stage, the first-named plaintiff, Mr Vincent Blair Cookson (Mr Cookson) responded, asking whether he would at least get some income from the premises with respect to late settlement.   The plaintiff maintains that its company Virtual Plumbing had vacated the premises it was occupying and Mr Cookson had handed over the keys.

[6]      The defendants did not settle on 23 December 2010.    This proceeding was commenced on 18 February 2011.  In the meantime the plaintiffs had received from the defendants a letter (purported to be dated 15 December 2010 but not received until 7 February 2011) contending that the defendants were not liable to pay interest to the plaintiffs for the delay in settlement because the Settlement Agreement did not provide for it.  In addition, this…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cookson v Simmons HC Wellington CIV-2011-485-283 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 1081
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the High Court of New Zealand involves a summary judgment application by Vincent Blair Cookson and Bruce Howard Jensen as trustees of the Vincent Cookson Trust against Lorne Perry Simmons, Nicole Lynley Simmons, and Liam Michael O'Keeffe. The plaintiffs are seeking interest and costs from the defendants in relation to a delayed settlement of a property sale. The defendants opposed the application, arguing that interest was not payable under the terms of the Settlement Agreement and that they had a counterclaim for damages due to the unlawful removal of fixtures and fittings from the property by the plaintiffs.

The court considered whether the defendants had a defence to the plaintiffs' claim for interest. The court determined that the Settlement Agreement intended to use the standard Auckland District Law Society Agreement for Sale and Purchase, which includes provisions for interest on delayed settlement. As no default interest rate was specified in the Agreement itself, the court found that the plaintiffs' claim for interest at the Judicature Act rate of 7.5% per annum was appropriate. The court rejected the defendants' argument that the Settlement Agreement did not provide for interest and that the plaintiffs had no defence to this claim.

The court also considered whether the defendants had an equitable set-off against the plaintiffs' claim. The court noted that equitable set-off is possible where the claims are interdependent and it would be unjust to allow judgment on one claim without considering the other. However, the court found that the defendants' counterclaim was not sufficiently connected to the plaintiffs' claim for interest, as it involved different parties and contracts. The court held that the contractual arrangements between the parties barred any set-off being made against the interest claimed.

The court granted summary judgment to the plaintiffs, ordering the defendants to pay interest on the sum of $216,680.00 at 7.5% per annum from 23 December 2010 to 18 March 2011, amounting to $3,739.68. The plaintiffs were also awarded their costs on a scale 2B basis, totalling $8,084.00, together with disbursements of $1,165.33.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established