Confident Trustee Limited v Garden and Trees Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV2016-404-003118

[2017] NZHC 470

BETWEEN

CONFIDENT TRUSTEE LIMITED

Applicant

AND

GARDEN AND TREES LIMITED

Respondent

Hearing: 16 March 2017

Appearances:

W McCartney for the Applicant D A Jaques for the Respondent

Judgment:

16 March 2017


ORAL JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE CHRISTIANSEN


CONFIDENT TRUSTEE LIMITED v GARDEN AND TREES LIMITED [2017] NZHC 470 [16 March 2017]

The application

[1]                 The applicant (CTL) has applied to set aside a statutory demand served on it by the respondent (Garden and Trees). Garden and Trees statutory demand claims payment of $21,753.36 as the balance due for services provided.

The applicant’s case

[2]                 CTL claims on 29 January 2016 Garden and Trees were contracted to clear a section at Massey at a contract price and that it was a term of the contract that work be completed within three weeks of the date of the contract. CTL says time was of the essence because it had contracted with Cameron Civil Ltd for civil engineering earthworks to commence on the site in mid-February 2016.

[3]                 CTL says Garden and Trees had inadequate machinery and insufficient labour to complete the works within three weeks and says by 24 February 2016 no more than 40 per cent of the work had been done.

[4]                 On 24 February 2016 CTL engaged the services of another contractor, Tree Safe Ltd (Tree Safe) to assist with the works contracted to be undertaken by Garden and Trees.

[5]                 CTL says two days later Garden and Trees refused to carry out any further work and left the site. The cost of Tree Safe’s services amounted to $66,684.02. Garden and Trees were paid $35,000 and CTL does not accept that it is liable for the statutory demand claimed as the balance due.

The applicant’s evidence

[6]                 Evidence in support of the application was provided by Jeff Yuan (Mr Yuan) a director of CTL. That evidence is supported in part by Mr Wilson of Cameron Civil Limited (Cameron Civil) which had been contracted to carry out earthworks at the property beginning 17 February 2016, earthworks that could not be completed until Garden and Trees section clearing work had been completed.

[7]                 Mr Yuan recalls meeting Mr Welch of Garden and Trees at his home on 25 or 26 January 2016. He says he stressed the work must be finished within three weeks because the earthworks would be starting. He says on 29 January Mr Welch gave him a firm price of $58,000 plus GST. There was no written contract. A deposit of $20,000 was paid on 3 February and a further sum of $5,000 was paid on 11 February. He thinks the work began on 4 or 5 February. He was concerned Garden and Trees’ small digger was not suitable for the amount of work to be done. He said it broke down often and he was worried the job would not be finished in time. He talked to Mr Welch and it was agreed a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Confident Trustee Limited v Garden and Trees Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 470
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Confident Trustee Limited (CTL) applied to set aside a statutory demand served on it by Garden and Trees Limited. Garden and Trees claimed payment of $21,753.36 as the balance due for services provided. CTL argued that it had engaged Garden and Trees to clear a section at Massey, and that the work was to be completed within three weeks of the contract date. CTL claimed that Garden and Trees had inadequate machinery and insufficient labour to complete the works within the timeframe and by 24 February 2016, no more than 40 per cent of the work had been done. On 24 February 2016, CTL engaged the services of another contractor, Tree Safe Ltd (Tree Safe) to assist with the works contracted to be undertaken by Garden and Trees. CTL says two days later Garden and Trees refused to carry out any further work and left the site. The cost of Tree Safe’s services amounted to $66,684.02. Garden and Trees were paid $35,000 and CTL does not accept that it is liable for the statutory demand claimed as the balance due. The court found that the evidence strongly suggested that 15 February 2016 was the starting date of Garden and Trees’ services. Mr Yuan asserts he required the work to be done by 19 February. However the consent or approval even for the preliminary vegetation clearance work had not been authorised. The evidence of Mr Welch is supported in part at least by the evidence of Mr Gibbons and Mr Pope. On the other hand, and as Mr Jaques submits CTL has no paperwork, no emails, no records of phone calls to support Mr Yuan’s contentions. Claims of there being no obligation to pay, were not raised until the statutory demands were served, despite frequent requests for payment having earlier been made. The invoice, which supported the statutory demand was for a GST inclusive sum of $56,753.36. That invoice included ‘Tree removal/chipping’ at $700 per day for eight days. The original estimate indicated an estimated price of $2,000 per day for tree removal. Also, the invoice referred to charges which were not identified in the estimate. These factors notwithstanding, it is clear that Garden and Trees’ invoice is a calculation of costs which clearly did not prevent invoicing for actual costs incurred. Finally, it is clear for reasons already detailed that CTL effectively cancelled its contract with Garden and Trees thereby justifying them leaving the site. The application to set aside the statutory demand was dismissed. The court directed the time for compliance with the statutory demand shall be extended to 9:45am, 23 March 2017 when this matter will be called again before the court. An order for liquidation will then be made unless the statutory demand of $21,753.36 has been paid in cleared funds to Garden and Trees. Garden and Trees costs and disbursements are payable on a 2B basis. Those costs are strictly limited to attendances in connection with the first statutory demand. It is expected those costs will also be paid by 23 March 2017. The second statutory demand will also be recalled before the court at 9:45am, 23 March 2017. If a fixture upon that application is still required then it will be scheduled.