Commissioner of Police v Read

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

TAURANGA REGISTRY

CIV-2011-470-1070

[2014] NZHC 1758

BETWEEN

COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

Applicant

AND

GARY JOHN READ

First Respondent

AND

WILLIAM JAMES READ

Second Respondent

AND

KEVIN BARRY PARKINSON

Fourth Respondent

AND

PHILLIPA KAREN WILSON

Fifth Respondent

AND

R B A TRUSTEES LIMITED

Party served

Hearing: 22 May 2014

Appearances:

R W Jenson for Applicant

W T Nabney for First Respondent
A Speed for Fourth & Fifth Respondents

Judgment:

28 July 2014


JUDGMENT OF KEANE J


This judgment was delivered by me on 28 July 2014 at 4pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

COMMISSIONER OF POLICE v READ [2014] NZHC 1758 [28 July 2014]

Solicitors:

Crown Solicitor, Tauranga

[1]                 On 6 May 2013 Gary Read was sentenced in this Court to imprisonment for 11 years with a minimum term of five years, three months, for 70 offences of importing pseudoephedrine on a large scale over two years, and for lesser related offending.

[2]                 At the date of his sentence Mr Read’s assets had since 12 December 2011 been subject to restraining orders made under the Criminal Proceeds (Recovery) Act 2009 (CPRA); and amongst the properties restrained were two Tauranga properties, the title to which lay with RBA Trustees Limited, the corporate trustee of the GR Trust, Mr Read’s family trust. He and his children are discretionary beneficiaries.

[3]                 On 22 May 2013 the Commissioner applied for a profit forfeiture order, under the CPRA, in respect of Mr Read’s assets, extending to those two properties, and on 9 August 2013 obtained a further order under the CPRA authorising him to examine a director of RBA Trustees, Mr Bixley, and to obtain from Mr Bixley the records of the trust. On 21 August 2013 Mr Bixley was examined at the police station, Hamilton, and the examination made is recorded in a video recording and in a written transcript.

[4]                 On 5 November 2013 Phillipa Wilson, Gary Read’s partner, applied for two orders. The first, as to which there is no issue, was for an order appointing her the litigation guardian of their infant children, two of whom are named as respondents. The second was for an order requiring the Commissioner to discover the two forms of record made of Mr Bixley’s examination on 21 August 2013, the video and the transcript. That is the disputed application I have to resolve.

[5]                 In his notice opposing that application, dated 13 November 2013, the Commissioner contends that the recording and the transcript are documents attracting litigation privilege, under s 56 of the Evidence Act 2006, because they record an examination made of Mr Bixley, as a director of RBA Trustees, for the dominant purpose of preparing for the profit forfeiture application.

Three issues

[6]                 Three issues arise as a result, and the first is whether an examination made under compulsion, as a result of an order of this Court under s 107 of the CPRA, is as the Commissioner contends capable of being…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Police v Read and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 1758
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Commissioner of Police applied for a profit forfeiture order under the Criminal Proceeds (Recovery) Act 2009 (CPRA) in respect of Gary Read’s assets. The application was made following Read’s conviction and sentencing for importing pseudoephedrine on a large scale over two years, and for lesser related offending. The Commissioner applied for an examination order under s 107 of the CPRA, to examine Bixley, a director of RBA Trustees Limited, the corporate trustee of the GR Trust, Read’s family trust. Bixley was examined, and the examination was recorded in a video recording and a written transcript. Phillipa Wilson, Read’s partner, applied for an order requiring the Commissioner to discover the two forms of record made of Bixley’s examination on 21 August 2013, the video and the transcript. The Commissioner opposed the application, contending that the recording and the transcript are documents attracting litigation privilege, under s 56 of the Evidence Act 2006, because they record an examination made of Bixley, as a director of RBA Trustees, for the dominant purpose of preparing for the profit forfeiture application.

The first issue is whether an examination made under compulsion, as a result of an order of this Court under s 107 of the CPRA, is as the Commissioner contends capable of being a ‘communication’ attracting litigation privilege under s 56(2)(a) of the Evidence Act 2006. Ms Wilson contends that it lies beyond the scope of the privilege, both at common law and under the statute. The second issue is whether, if an examination is capable of being a ‘communication’ under s 56(2)(a), this particular examination was, as the Commissioner contends, a ‘communication’ between himself, a party to the proceeding, and ‘any other person’, a non-party. Ms Wilson contends that, as at the dates of the order authorising the examination, and the examination itself, and her discovery application, RBA Trustees, as the registered owner of the two Tauranga properties then under restraint, and liable to forfeiture on the Commissioner’s application, was or needed to be a party. That the Commissioner had not joined it as a party was incidental. The third issue is whether the Commissioner may claim privilege for the examination records, when he accepts that Read, as one discretionary beneficiary, and Ms Wilson, as litigation guardian for the others, are entitled to obtain from RBA Trustees any trust documents Bixley produced, and any disclosures he made. Ms Wilson contends that is inconsistent with any privilege in the records made, and also constitutes a waiver.

The court found that the Commissioner cannot claim s 56 any privilege because RBA Trustees, the subject of the examination, was entitled to be a party to the Commissioner’s application for forfeiture, for the purpose of which the examination was made. The fact that the Commissioner does not claim privilege for the substance of the examination is also fatal to any privilege in the records made, either because privilege in the record can only derive from privilege in the substance, or because the Commissioner has waived privilege in the substance. The court granted Ms Wilson’s application for discovery in respect of the record of the examination. Ms Wilson is entitled to costs under scale 2B in respect of this application, and costs as fixed by the Registrar.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established