IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND TAURANGA REGISTRY
CIV-2010-470-000360 [2017] NZHC 748
BETWEEN THE COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
Applicant
AND
VALENTINE BARCLAY NICHOLAS First Respondent
SHEILA PETRINA PAYNE Second Respondent
WILLIAM FRANCIS NICHOLAS Third Respondent
Applicant for Relief
BRETT ANTHONY GEORGE, KARYN JANE GEORGE and VLN TRUSTEE LIMITED as trustees of the BA & KJ GEORGE TRUST
Fourth Respondents
Applicants for Relief
CLINTON MILLS Fifth Respondent Applicant for Relief
On thepapersand
bytelephone:
5 April 2017
Appearances:
R Jenson for the Applicant, by telephone
W Nabney for the First and Second Respondents, by telephone
No appearance for the Third and Fifth RespondentsJudgment:
13 April 2017
[COSTS] JUDGMENT OF HINTON J
THE COMMISSIONER OF POLICE v NICHOLAS & OTHERS [2017] NZHC 748 [13 April 2017]
This judgment was delivered by me on 13 April 2017 at 1.00 pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules
……………………………………………………………………
Registrar/Deputy Registrar
Counsel/Solicitors:
Hollister-Jones Lellman, Tauranga
William Nabney, Barrister, Tauranga
Jonathan Temm, Barrister, Rotorua
Parties:
W Nicholas
C Mills
[1] On 17 August 2016, I delivered my judgment in this proceeding. I allowed the Commissioner’s application for asset and profit forfeiture orders and I dismissed the applications for relief by the third to fifth respondents. Costs were reserved.
[2] The first and second respondents were legally aided throughout the proceeding and the Commissioner does not seek costs against them.
[3] The Commissioner seeks costs against the third to fifth respondents.
[4] The Commissioner filed a memorandum dated 7 September 2016 seeking
2A costs in the sum of $8,251 against each of the third and fifth respondents and
2B costs in the sum of $27,986.50 against the fourth respondent. Two separate costs schedules were provided, one listing all steps on a 2A basis and the other listing all steps on a 2B basis.
[5] I issued a Minute noting that those costs appeared to be somewhat on the high side. I asked that the third to fifth respondents be notified as fully as possible of the application and given further time to respond. I am satisfied that the application has been brought to their attention in every way possible by the Registrar and by other counsel and they have had ample time to make any submissions.
[6] Mr Temm, who was formerly counsel for the fourth respondents, filed a memorandum dated 4 April 2017 on the basis that it was to assist the Court and not on instructions. I thank him for that. Mr George apparently then insisted that the Registrar include Mr Temm in the teleconference that I arranged on 5 April 2017 to give any parties an opportunity to be heard. However, as Mr Temm was clear that he still had no instructions, I excused him from the teleconference. Mr George’s position was well-covered, in any event, by Mr Temm’s memorandum.
[7] Mr Nabney was joined in the teleconference, but was excused as no application is made against the first and second respondents. He had kindly, again without instructions, filed a brief…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Police v Nicholas and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] NZHC 748
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Court included the appropriateness of the Commissioner's two-schedule approach and the allocation of costs between the parties. The Court found that the Commissioner was the successful party and costs should follow the event. However, the Court decided that the costs should not be apportioned on a joint and several basis but rather by allocating a fair proportion to each party, in accordance with the Court's overriding discretion. The Court also determined that the appropriate costs categorisation for the proceeding was 2B.
The Court found that the fourth respondents' application for relief was significant and intertwined with the Commissioner's claim, but the case against the first and second respondents involved wider issues. The Court awarded 50% of the costs sought by the Commissioner against the fourth respondents on a 2B basis, resulting in a consequential costs award of $13,993.25. The third and fifth respondents' applications for relief were considered minor, and the Court found it fair for them to pay one-fifth each of the 2B costs, resulting in a costs award of $5,597.30 against each of them.
The Court also made a further order in respect of dividends obtained on Trust Power shares, which were to be realised to satisfy the Profit Forfeiture Order made against the first respondent.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi