Commissioner of Police v Cooley

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NELSON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA WHAKATŪ ROHE

CIV-2023-442-000055 [2025] NZHC 1519

IN THE MATTER             of an on notice application for an order for

sale to preserve value pursuant to ss 33 and 35(e)(v) of the Criminal Proceedings (Recovery) Act 2009

BETWEENTHE COMMISSIONER, THE NEW ZEALAND POLICE

Applicant

AND  RAYMOND COOLEY

First Respondent

TIARE THOMAS EPERE

Second Respondent

IRENA TEARIKIMATEPO EPERE (NEE OAARIKI)

Third Respondent

ARTHUR STEVEN TARAWA
Fourth Respondent

STENTON PETER WILDE
Fifth Respondent

MARGARET JOY WILDE
Sixth Respondent

JESSICA MARGARET ASHE (NEE GODFREY)

Seventh Respondent

FENIXS TARAWA
Eighth Respondent

NORMA WAIARIA PEKAMA
First Interested Party

THE COMMISSIONER, THE NEW ZEALAND POLICE v COOLEY [2025] NZHC 1519 [11 June 2025]

RIKI LEON COOLEY

Second Interested Party

ARLEE TARAWA

Third Interested Party

ESEKIAH FAAULI

Fourth Interested Party

Hearing:                   (On the papers)

Counsel:                   J M Webber for Applicant

Judgment:                11 June 2025


JUDGMENT OF LA HOOD J


[1]                 The Commissioner has filed an application under ss 33 and 35(e)(v) of the Criminal Proceeds (Recovery) Act 2009 (the Act) seeking an order for sale of certain restrained property so as to preserve its value. The property is:

(a)A 2016 Harley Davidson motorcycle, formerly with registration C8BND, now re-registered C7ZAT, attributed to Stenton Wilde.

(b)A 2006 Harley Davidson Street Rod motorcycle registration C7JUY, attributed to Raymond Cooley.

(c)Parts of a 2005 Harley Davidson V Rod motorcycle, registration 82ZEH, attributed to Raymond Cooley.

(d)A 200HP Yamaha outboard motor, associated with a 2014 Voyager Trailer registration 10F89, registered to Fenixs Tarawa, carrying a Ramco aluminium fishing boat, attributed to Arthur Tarawa.

[2]                 The application  is  no  longer  pursued  at  this  time  in  relation  to  the  2016 Harley Davidson motorcycle, formerly with registration C8BND, now re-

registered C7ZAT, as the Commissioner has identified a person who claims an interest in that motorcycle and has indicated that sale is opposed.

[3]                 The first respondent, Raymond Cooley, has not taken any steps in the proceeding or indicated any opposition to the application for a sale order in relation to the 2006 Harley Davidson Street Rod, or the parts of a 2005 Harley Davidson V Rod.

[4]                 The fourth respondent, Arthur Tarawa, has indicated through counsel that the application for a sale order is not opposed in relation to the 200HP Yamaha outboard motor.

[5]                 The eighth respondent, Fenixs Tarawa, has not taken any steps in the proceeding or indicated any opposition to the application for a sale order in relation to the 200HP Yamaha outboard motor.

[6]                 There has previously been a sale order in relation to the Ramco boat and Voyager trailer with which the 200HP Yamaha outboard motor is associated.

Sale orders – the law

[7]                 I gratefully adopt Gwyn J’s summary of the law from a previous decision granting sale orders in this case:1

[9]        The  vehicles  are  currently  restrained  property   under   the Official Assignee’s (OA’s) custody and control. The effect of a restraining order is to preserve the property itself and not its value.2 The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Police v Cooley and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NZHC 1519
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Nelson Registry, the Commissioner of Police applied for an order under sections 33 and 35(e)(v) of the Criminal Proceedings (Recovery) Act 2009 to sell certain restrained property to preserve its value. The restrained property included a 2006 Harley Davidson Street Rod motorcycle, parts of a 2005 Harley Davidson V Rod motorcycle, and a 200HP Yamaha outboard motor. The application was no longer pursued for a 2016 Harley Davidson motorcycle due to a claim by a person asserting an interest in it. The first respondent, Raymond Cooley, and other respondents did not oppose the application for the sale of the remaining items. The court needed to determine whether the sale of the restrained property was appropriate to preserve its value, considering factors such as the nature and value of the asset, the length of time before the substantive proceeding would be determined, and the wishes of the owner or those with an interest in the assets.

The court examined the evidence provided by the Commissioner, including the valuation, storage costs, and rate of depreciation for the motorcycles, based on Inland Revenue’s IR265 report. The Commissioner argued that the restrained property was depreciating in value, which would decrease the potential return, and that storage costs were substantial. The court considered these factors, along with the lack of opposition from the respondents, and concluded that sale orders were appropriate to preserve the value of the restrained property. The court made sale orders in relation to the 2006 Harley Davidson Street Rod, parts of the 2005 Harley Davidson V Rod, and the 200HP Yamaha outboard motor, on the terms set out in the Commissioner’s application dated 14 April 2025.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established