Commissioner of Inland Revenue v Wright

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2012-404-5449 [2013] NZHC 476

BETWEEN  COMMISSIONER OF INLAND REVENUE

Plaintiff

ANDHADLEY JOHN WRIGHT Defendant

Hearing:         1 March 2013

Appearances: A H J Commons for the Defendant, in support

W P Cathcart and F F Nizam for the Plaintiff, to oppose

Judgment:      1 March 2013

ORAL JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE R M BELL

Solicitors:

Hornabrook Macdonald (Mark Hornabrook), Auckland, for Defendant

Email:   msh@hmlaw.co.nz

Meredith Connell, P O Box 2213 Auckland 1140, for Commissioner

Email:   warren.cathcart@meredithconnell.co.nz

Farzana.Nizam@meredithconnell.co.nz

Copy for:

Andrew H J Commons, P O Box 1804 Auckland 1140 for Defendant

Email:   Andrew@andrewcommons.co.nz

COMMISSIONER OF INLAND REVENUE V WRIGHT HC AK CIV-2012-404-5449 [1 March 2013]

[1]      In this proceeding the Commissioner of Inland Revenue sues Mr Hadley

Wright  under  the  phoenix  company provisions  of  the  Companies Act  1993  for

$1,170,383.78, a sum for which Mr Wright is allegedly liable as a relevant debt owed by a phoenix company called Wire By Design Ltd.

[2]      Among other things in his statement of defence, Mr Wright says that the Crown owes Wire By Design Ltd more than $1,170,383.78.   That indebtedness is said to be for compensation payable under the Public Works Act 1981.   Wire By Design Ltd has issued a proceeding in this court.1    That proceeding is part of its pursuit of compensation under the Public Works Act.   It has also started a claim before the Land Valuation Tribunal, which is on hold awaiting the outcome of its

High Court proceeding.

[3]      Mr Wright applies for a stay of this proceeding under r 10.12, until the claim by Wire  By  Design  Ltd  has  been  heard  or,  alternatively,  for  leave  to  join  the Attorney-General on behalf of Land Information New Zealand.  The Commissioner opposes.

Background

[4]      For the background I draw largely on the parties’ pleadings.  There are large areas where the facts are not in dispute.

[5]      Mr Wright was a director of Faulkner Collins Ltd.  That company carried on a manufacturing business at premises at 142 Stoddard Road, Mt Roskill, Auckland. Faulkner Collins Ltd had been incorporated back in 1931.  It leased the premises at

142 Stoddard Road.   Mr Wright was sole director of Faulkner Collins Ltd in the years up to November 2010.

[6]      On 22 November 2010, Faulkner Collins Ltd sold its business and assets to

Wire By Design  Ltd  for a purchase price of $3,585,503.95.   Among the assets

1      Wire By Design Ltd (In Rec and In Liq) v Attorney-General (Minister of Land Information)

HC Auckland CIV-2012-404-1491.

transferred were the goodwill of the business, the benefit and exclusive use of the name Faulkner Collins, the assignment of Faulkner Collins’ interest as lessee in the premises at 142 Stoddard Road, and the benefit of all legal, statutory and other rights from the relocation claimed against the Crown under the Public Works Act 1981 in respect of the premises at 142 Stoddard Road.

[7]      As  to  claims  under  the  Public  Works  Act,  the  New  Zealand  Transport Authority wanted to assume control of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Inland Revenue v Wright and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 476
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Commissioner of Inland Revenue sued Mr Hadley Wright under the phoenix company provisions of the Companies Act 1993 for $1,170,383.78, a sum for which Mr Wright is allegedly liable as a relevant debt owed by a phoenix company called Wire By Design Ltd. Mr Wright applied for a stay of this proceeding until the claim by Wire By Design Ltd has been heard, or, alternatively, for leave to join the Attorney-General on behalf of Land Information New Zealand. The Commissioner opposed.

The legal issues were whether there was a common thread between the two proceedings and if so, whether a stay should be granted. The court found that there was a common thread between the two proceedings. Under s 386C of the Companies Act, Mr Wright was in a position of secondary liability for the relevant debts of Wire By Design Ltd. The court found that the insolvency set-off provision under s 310 of the Companies Act applied when the Crown was both a creditor and a debtor of a company in liquidation, even when different government departments were the creditor and the debtor. The Commissioner’s claim for unpaid taxes and the claim by Wire By Design Ltd for compensation under the Public Works Act came within s 310 as mutual dealings. Mr Wright could properly raise the insolvency set-off argument by way of defence to the Commissioner’s claim against him. However, the court did not grant a stay. The court directed the Registrar to arrange a telephone case management conference and urged the parties to exchange proposals beforehand.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established