Commerce Commission v Whirlpool SA HC Auckland CIV 2011-404-6362

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

NOT TO BE DISTRIBUTED (OTHER THAN TO THE PARTIES) FOR

72 HOURS FOLLOWING DELIVERY

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

COMMERCIAL LIST

CIV 2011-404-6362

BETWEEN  COMMERCE COMISSION Plaintiff

ANDWHIRLPOOL SA Defendant

Hearing:         25 November 2011

Appearances: J C L Dixon and B Hamlin for plaintiff

S C Keene and T J Pilkington for defendant

Judgment:      19 December 2011

JUDGMENT OF ALLAN J

In accordance with r 11.5 I direct that the Registrar endorse this judgment with the delivery time of 11.30 am on Monday 19 December 2011

Solicitors:

Meredith Connell, Auckland  john.dixon@meredithconnell.co.nz

Ben.hamlin@meredithconnell.co.nz

Russell McVeagh, Auckland  sarah.keene@russellmcveagh.com

COMMERCE COMISSION V WHIRLPOOL SA HC AK CIV 2011-404-6362 [19 December 2011]

Introduction

[1]      The plaintiff alleges breaches by the defendant of Part 2 of the Commerce Act 1986 (the Act).  The defendant has filed a statement of defence, in which it does not plead to certain allegations in the Commission’s statement of claim. By virtue of r 5.48(3) of the High Court Rules, those allegations are deemed to be admitted.

[2]      The Court is now asked to impose a pecuniary penalty of $3 million, agreed between the Commission and the defendant, and to approve a proposed payment of

$50,000 by the defendant towards the costs of the Commission.

Agreed facts

[3]      This case is concerned with the markets for domestic and light commercial hermetic  compressors  under  one  horsepower  (DLCs)  in  New  Zealand.     The impugned conduct is that of employees of Empresa Brasileira de Compressores SA (Embraco SA).   Following a merger which led to the formation of the defendant, those employees became the defendant’s employees in May 2006.

[4]      During the period under consideration, Embraco was a company incorporated in Brazil, but carrying on business in New Zealand as a supplier of DLCs.  On any view it is a large international organisation, having approximately 10,000 staff worldwide, operating in more than 80 countries and ranking as one of the largest compressor manufacturers in the world in terms of revenue.  During the period under consideration it sent communications into, and met with customers in, New Zealand.

[5]      At all relevant times there were markets in New Zealand for the supply of DLCs.  The two largest suppliers in the New Zealand market were Panasonic and Embraco.   The annual value of sales within the markets was of the order of $15 million.   Embraco’s market share was about one-fifth of that figure.   Panasonic is Embraco’s largest competitor in New Zealand.  It enjoys a market share of the order of 60%.

[6]      From  at  least  2004  onwards,  in  response  to  growing  global  demand  for natural resources, there were significant increases in the price of steel and copper used in compressor manufacturing.  Steel and copper are significant inputs into the manufacture of compressors.

[7]      In 2005 and 2006, Embraco and Panasonic exchanged information on prices, production capacities and other market intelligence.   In the course of those communications there arose an understanding and expectation between Embraco and Panasonic that each would increase prices for certain DLCs in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commerce Commission v Whirlpool SA HC Auckland CIV 2011-404-... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 2109
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Commerce Commission v Whirlpool SA HC Auckland CIV 2011-404-6362 concerns an allegation by the Commerce Commission that Whirlpool SA breached Part 2 of the Commerce Act 1986. The Commission alleged that Whirlpool SA had entered into two understandings with Panasonic, another major supplier of domestic and light commercial hermetic compressors under one horsepower (DLCs) in New Zealand. These understandings had the purpose, effect, or likely effect of controlling or maintaining prices for the supply of DLCs in New Zealand, which substantially lessened competition in contravention of the Act. The Court was required to decide whether the proposed penalty of $3 million was appropriate, and whether Whirlpool SA should contribute $50,000 towards the Commission's costs.

The court considered the maximum applicable penalty under the Act, which could be either the greater of $10 million or three times the commercial gain, or 10% of the turnover of Whirlpool SA and all of its interconnected bodies corporate. However, since the commercial gain could not be readily ascertained, the maximum penalty was set at $10 million for each of the three breaches, totalling $30 million. The court then assessed the appropriate starting point for the penalty, taking into account factors such as the nature and extent of the conduct, the size of the market, and the defendant's commercial gain. The court determined that a starting point of $4-6 million was appropriate, and that a one-third discount should be applied for mitigating factors such as the defendant's acceptance of responsibility and submission to the court's jurisdiction.

The court concluded that the proposed penalty of $3 million was within the appropriate range and consistent with penalties imposed in similar cases. The court approved the recommended penalty of $3 million, as well as the proposed contribution of $50,000 towards the Commission's costs. The court also noted that the defendant's position in respect of the deemed admissions was limited to the present application for approval only, and that any restriction on search of the court file was discharged. An order was made to defer distribution of the judgment to any person other than the parties for 72 hours following delivery, to enable the terms of the judgment to be notified to the management of the defendant in Brazil before it reached the public domain.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established