Commerce Commission v Singapore Airlines Cargo Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV 2008-404-8356 [2012] NZHC 3583

BETWEEN  THE COMMERCE COMMISSION Plaintiff

ANDSINGAPORE AIRLINES CARGO PTY LTD

Defendant

Hearing:         7 December 2012

Appearances: J C L Dixon and A M Boberg for plaintiff

M D O'Brien and J Stevens for defendant

Judgment:      21 December 2012

JUDGMENT OF ALLAN J

In accordance with r 11.5 I direct that the Registrar endorse this judgment with the delivery time of 10 am on Friday 21 December 2012

Solicitors:

Meredith Connell, Auckland  john.dixon@meredithconnell.co.nz

Bell Gully, Wellington  Jenny.stevens@bellgully.com

THE COMMERCE COMMISSION V SINGAPORE AIRLINES CARGO PTY LTD HC AK CIV 2008-404-

8356 [21 December 2012]

Introduction

[1]      The defendant, Singapore Airlines Cargo Pte Ltd, (SIA Cargo), has admitted breaches of Part 2 of the Commerce Act 1986 (the Act).  The plaintiff accordingly asks  the  Court  to  impose  a  pecuniary  penalty  under  the Act.    The  Commerce Commission (the Commission) and SIA Cargo are agreed that, subject to the view of the Court, an aggregate penalty of $4.1 million is appropriate, together with costs totalling $259,079.18.

Background

[2]      SIA Cargo is an international airline with its global head office in Singapore. It is registered as an overseas company in New Zealand, pursuant to the Companies Act 1993.  Throughout the relevant period it carried on business in New Zealand and elsewhere as a carrier of cargo by air.

[3]      With effect from 1 July 2001, SIA Cargo has provided air cargo transport services using its own freighters and belly hold space on aircraft operated by Singapore Airlines Ltd (Singapore Air), pursuant to an exclusive contractual arrangement.  SIA Cargo and Singapore Air are separate legal entities with different boards, management and reporting structures.

[4]      During the relevant period, SIA Cargo was the fifth largest air cargo carrier in the world in terms of freight tonne-kilometres flown.  Throughout the period with which  this  case  is  concerned,  SIA  Cargo  maintained  scheduled  cargo  services between Singapore and Auckland using its own aircraft, as well as utilising belly hold space on passenger services between Singapore and Auckland operated by Singapore Air.

[5]      For the purposes of this proceeding, SIA Cargo and the Commission are agreed that separate markets existed during the relevant period, including in New Zealand, for air cargo services between Indonesia and Malaysia respectively, and

New Zealand.  A number of airlines competed with each other to supply air cargo services in these markets.

[6]      The Commission’s allegations, relate to Fuel Surcharge Agreements (FSA) and Security Surcharge Agreements (SSA), entered into with a number of other airlines in respect of the carriage of air cargo from Indonesia and Malaysia respectively to New Zealand.

[7]      In October 2001, PT Garuda Indonesia and other members of the Air Cargo Representative Board – Indonesia, reached an agreement regarding the imposition of a fuel surcharge on cargo carried by air from Indonesia to New Zealand.   The agreement provided that members would exchange information as to their fuel surcharge intentions,  charge  fuel  surcharges  in  accordance with  those  expressed intentions, and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commerce Commission v Singapore Airlines Cargo Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 3583
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand presided over a case between the Commerce Commission and Singapore Airlines Cargo Pty Ltd (SIA Cargo), concerning breaches of the Commerce Act 1986. SIA Cargo admitted to breaches of the Act through its participation in Fuel Surcharge Agreements (FSA) and Security Surcharge Agreements (SSA) related to air cargo services from Indonesia and Malaysia to New Zealand. The court was required to decide on an appropriate pecuniary penalty for these breaches.

The primary legal issues involved determining the maximum penalty under the Commerce Act, assessing the seriousness of the contravening conduct, and considering various mitigating and aggravating factors. The court noted that the conduct was price-fixing, which is deemed anti-competitive per se. The maximum penalty for each breach was determined to be the greater of $10 million or 10% of SIA Cargo’s relevant turnover, which amounted to just under $10 million. Given that SIA Cargo was liable for both entering into and giving effect to each of the surcharge agreements, the maximum penalty available was $80 million.

The court considered factors such as the duration and nature of the conduct, the degree of market power held by SIA Cargo, the extent of commercial gain, and the level of cooperation with the Commission. The court found that the commercial gain from the surcharges was minimal, but emphasized the importance of deterrence. The court adopted a single starting point for the totality of the acknowledged breaches, considering the conduct in light of the totality principle. The starting point was set at a range of $5.0 to $5.4 million, drawing comparisons with penalties imposed in similar cases involving other airlines. After considering various mitigating factors, including SIA Cargo's cooperation with the Commission and its implementation of a global competition law compliance program, the court approved a recommended penalty of $4.1 million, within the proposed range of $4.0 to $4.23 million.

The court ordered SIA Cargo to pay a pecuniary penalty of $4.1 million and costs of $259,079.18 to the Commerce Commission.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.