Commerce Commission v Lodge Real Estate Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

FOR A COURT READY (FEE REQUIRED) VERSION PLEASE FOLLOW THIS LINK

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA678/2017
 [2018] NZCA 523

BETWEEN

COMMERCE COMMISSION
Appellant

AND

LODGE REAL ESTATE LIMITED
First Respondent

MONARCH REAL ESTATE LIMITED
Second Respondent

BRIAN KING
Third Respondent

JEREMY O’ROURKE
Fourth Respondent

Hearing:

25, 26 and 27 September 2018 (further submissions received 23 October 2018)

Court:

Asher, Brown and Gilbert JJ

Counsel:

J C L Dixon QC, L C A Farmer and A L McConachy for Appellant
L J Taylor QC and M A Cavanaugh for First and Fourth Respondents
D H McLellan QC, M S Anderson and J H Whitehead for Second and Third Respondents

Judgment:

23 November 2018 at 9.30 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed.

BThe cross-appeal is dismissed.

CThere is a declaration that the respondents’ conduct contravened s 27 of the Commerce Act 1986, applying s 30 of that Act.

DThe case is remitted back to the High Court for the assessment of pecuniary penalties.

E        The respondents are jointly and severally liable to pay the appellant one set of costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.  We certify for two counsel. 

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Asher J)

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction
A brief history
The High Court judgment
The issues
The respondents’ challenge — was there an arrangement or understanding?
The Judge’s consideration of the facts
Our analysis
Conclusion on arrangement and understanding on the evidence
The Giltrap decision

What the Judge said
Moral obligation

Conclusion on arrangement or understanding
Giving effect to the arrangement or understanding

The appellant’s appeal — the finding of no fixing, controlling or maintaining of the price

The Judge’s reasoning
Analysis

The “de minimis” argument
The pleading point
The third and fourth appellants
The cross-appeal — expert evidence
Result
Costs

[1]
[3]
[17]
[24]

[27]
[31]
[35]
[52]
[53]
[53]
[55]
[68]
[71]

[75]
[75]
[78]
[94]
[101]
[110]
[111]
[115]
[119]

Introduction

  1. The respondents have been found to be not liable for penalties arising from an alleged arrangement or understanding prohibited under ss 27 and 30 of the Commerce Act 1986 (the Act).  In a High Court decision delivered on 2 November 2017 Jagose J dismissed the appellant Commerce Commission’s claims, holding that although there was an arrangement or understanding between the respondents, it did not have the purpose or effect of fixing, controlling, or maintaining the price for goods or services, or any related discount, allowance, rebate or credit.[1]  The Commerce Commission has appealed. 

  2. Significantly, the respondents have sought to support the judgment on grounds other than on which it was based, challenging the finding that there was an arrangement or understanding.  The respondents have also cross-appealed against the Judge’s refusal to admit the evidence of an expert economist the respondents wished to call, James Mellsop, who offered a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commerce Commission v Lodge Real Estate Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZCA 523
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

- Parties
The Commerce Commission has appealed a decision of the High Court dismissing its claim against Lodge Real Estate Limited, Monarch Real Estate Limited, Brian King, and Jeremy O’Rourke. The respondents have cross-appealed against the High Court’s refusal to admit the expert evidence of an economist, James Mellsop.

- Nature of the Dispute
The Commerce Commission brought proceedings against the respondents alleging breaches of ss 27 and 30 of the Commerce Act 1986 (the Act). The Commission sought pecuniary penalties. The respondents denied the claims and the proceedings were dismissed by the High Court.

- Court
Court of Appeal of New Zealand

- Legal Issues
The central issues on appeal were whether the respondents had entered into an arrangement or understanding, and if so, whether that arrangement or understanding had the purpose or effect of fixing, controlling or maintaining the price for the purposes of s 30. The Court also considered whether the Judge had erred in ruling that the case of Giltrap City Ltd v Commerce Commission did not require the Commission to prove the assumption of a moral obligation as an element of proving an arrangement or understanding.

- Court's Reasoning and Outcome
The Court found that there was an arrangement or understanding between the respondents. The Court held that the Judge had not erred in ruling that the assumption of a moral obligation was not a requirement to prove an arrangement or understanding under ss 27 and 30. However, the Court held that the Judge had erred in finding that the arrangement or understanding did not have the purpose or effect of fixing, controlling or maintaining price. The Court found that the arrangement or understanding to move to vendor funding for Trade Me advertisements had the effect of fixing, controlling or maintaining price. The appeal was therefore allowed and the matter was remitted back to the High Court for the assessment of pecuniary penalties.

- Final Orders
The appeal was allowed and the cross-appeal was dismissed. There is a declaration that the respondents’ conduct contravened s 27, applying s 30 of the Act. The case is remitted back to the High Court for the assessment of pecuniary penalties. The respondents are jointly and severally liable to pay the appellant one set of costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.