Combined Industrial Services Ltd (in liq) v Dewar

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND PALMERSTON NORTH REGISTRY

CIV-2014-454-49 [2015] NZHC 1924

BETWEEN

COMBINED INDUSTRIAL SERVICES

LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) Plaintiff

AND

DAVID PAUL DEWAR First Defendant

KIERON MAURICE CLARKE Second Defendant

Hearing:

28 May 2015

Teleconference 5 August 2015

Counsel:

N J Davis for Plaintiff
J Maassen and N Jessen for the First and Second Defendants

Judgment:

13 August 2015

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE SMITH

The applications

[1]      The defendants applied for an order for further particulars of the plaintiff’s

first amended statement of claim. They also applied for security for their costs.

[2]      The application for further particulars has now been resolved.  Following the hearing on 28 May 2015 the plaintiff (CIS) filed a memorandum setting out in some detail the nature of its claim, and at a telephone conference convened on 5 August

2015  Mr Maassen  advised  that  if  the  matters  stated  in  the  memorandum  were acknowledged to have been provided as further particulars of the plaintiff’s claim, the defendants would not need to pursue their further particulars application.   Mr Davis gave that assurance in the course of the telephone conference, and I directed that the matters set out in the memorandum were to be treated as further particulars

accordingly.

COMBINED INDUSTRIAL SERVICES LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) v DAVID PAUL DEWAR [2015] NZHC 1924 [13 August 2015]

[3]      I now give judgment on the defendants’ application for security for costs.

Background

[4]      The defendants, Mr Dewar and Mr Clarke, are sued as the former directors of CIS.  CIS was placed in liquidation on 9 July 2013, and the present proceeding is effectively brought by CIS’ liquidator.

[5]      CIS alleges that Mr Dewar and Mr Clarke wrongfully caused CIS to make distributions to its shareholders which had the effect of leaving CIS with insufficient assets to pay all of its creditors.  One creditor, Henry Services Limited (HSL), was not paid.

[6]      Mr Dewar and Mr Clarke were aware of the possibility of HSL making a claim against CIS, but say that they considered there was no merit in HSL’s claim. They proceeded to wind up CIS’ trading operations, and took steps to distribute its assets to its shareholders without making provision for the payment of any amount which might be found to be due to HSL.

[7]      In September 2011 HSL obtained a judgment against CIS for $113,541.43. HSL then commenced the enforcement proceedings which resulted in the liquidation of CIS.

[8]      CIS   claims   that   when   the   dividend   distribution   was   made   to   CIS’ shareholders the company did not, immediately after the distribution, satisfy the solvency  test  set  out  in  s  4  of  the  Companies Act  1993  (the Act).    In  those circumstances  it  says  that  the board of CIS  (Mr Dewar and  Mr Clarke) had  no

authority to make the distribution.1

1      Section 52 of the Act materially provides:

52        Board may authorise distributions

(1) The board of a company that is satisfied on reasonable grounds that the company will, immediately after the distribution, satisfy the solvency test may,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Combined Industrial Services Ltd (in liq) v Dewar and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 1924
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Combined Industrial Services Limited (CIS), in liquidation, sued David Paul Dewar and Kieron Maurice Clarke for allegedly causing CIS to make improper distributions to its shareholders. The former directors, Dewar and Clarke, sought security for their costs, arguing that they would be unable to recover any costs if they were successful at trial. The court held that the threshold test for granting security for costs was met because CIS was insolvent and would be unable to pay any costs if unsuccessful. The court then balanced the interests of the parties and concluded that the decisive factors were the defendants' potential costs and the likelihood that CIS was being funded by a third party. The court found that the defendants had not delayed in seeking security for costs, and that CIS had not been prejudiced by any delay. The court also found that the merits of the parties' positions on the substantive claims were not so clearly in CIS's favour that no security should be ordered. The court ordered security for the sum of $10,000, to be provided by payment into court or an independent solicitors' trust account. The court also stayed the proceeding pending the posting of the security.

The background of the dispute is that CIS was placed in liquidation in July 2013, and the present proceeding is effectively brought by CIS' liquidator. CIS alleges that Dewar and Clarke wrongfully caused CIS to make distributions to its shareholders, leaving it with insufficient assets to pay all of its creditors. One creditor, Henry Services Limited (HSL), was not paid. Dewar and Clarke say that they considered there was no merit in HSL's claim and took steps to distribute CIS' assets to its shareholders without making provision for the payment of any amount which might be found to be due to HSL. In September 2011 HSL obtained a judgment against CIS for $113,541.43. HSL then commenced the enforcement proceedings which resulted in the liquidation of CIS. There is a substantial dispute over the date or dates on which the distributions to the shareholders were made. Dewar and Clarke say that the distributions were completed on or about 30 June 2007, being the date on which they closed down the business of CIS and arranged for its assets to be taken over by separate companies each of them had established for that purpose. If the distributions were made on 30 June 2007, the claim by CIS, which was not filed until 14 April 2014, would be statute-barred under s 4 of the Limitation Act 1950.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.