Collard v Mendoza

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read
NOTE: EMAIL ADDRESS IN PARAGRAPH 4 AND 8 HAVE BEEN REDACTED FOR PUBLICATION

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2022-485-618637

[2024] NZHC 346

IN THE MATTER OF The Estate of MARY RUTH MENDOZA

BETWEEN

ROBYN JUNE COLLARD

Applicant

AND

KEVIN JOHN MENDOZA

Respondent

Hearing: On the papers

Appearances:

A Gilchrist for the Applicant

Judgment:

28 February 2024


JUDGMENT OF CHURCHMAN J


Introduction

[1]    The applicants, Mrs Robyn June Collard (Robyn) and Mr Graeme Robert Mendoza (Graeme), apply for substituted service orders in respect of an interlocutory application to transfer the proceedings from the High Court in Wellington to Auckland and to remove Kevin as the Administrator of the Estate of Mary Ruth Mendoza, the deceased mother of the parties (the deceased).

Background

[2]    Mrs Mendoza died on 22 July 2020, leaving a last Will dated 28 August 2002. Her Will was not admitted to Probate until 10 January 2023. Her sons Kevin and

COLLARD v MENDOZA [2024] NZHC 346 [28 February 2024]

Dennis Lionel Mendoza (Dennis) were appointed Executors. Dennis  died  in  August 2017, meaning at the time of the grant of Probate, Kevin was appointed the surviving Executor of the Will.

[3]    The  Estate’s  solicitors   wrote   to   Kevin’s   nominated   solicitors,   Andrew Lynn Lawyers, by letter dated 10 May 2023, which provided the Probate Order and advised as to the estate funds and realisation. However, Kevin did not respond to this nor a number of follow up communications from the applicant’s solicitors, and so the applicant filed an interlocutory application on 26 October 2023 to remove Kevin as executor, as well as transfer the proceedings to the Auckland High Court. This application was supported by two affidavits, one from Robyn and one from Graeme.

[4]    The applicant’s solicitor contacted Kevin by telephone on 22 January 2024. During this conversation, Kevin is reported to have become verbally abusive in response to being informed there was an application to remove him as Executor. He confirmed his email address as [ ], but otherwise stated his belief that he had done everything required of him and that the issue lay with the applicant’s solicitors.

[5]    On 30 January 2024, the applicant filed a memorandum seeking that the matter be enlarged by one month to allow for a without notice application for substituted service to be filed. This  was granted by Associate Judge Skelton via minute dated  30 January 2024.

[6]    The application for substituted service was filed on 22 February 2024, and was accompanied by a supporting memorandum, an affidavit from the applicant’s solicitor, and a draft substituted service order.

Submissions

[7]    In his memorandum dated 22 February 2024, the applicant submitted that Kevin, as Executor of Mrs Mendoza’s estate, had taken steps in relation to the obtaining of Probate of the estate, but had done nothing since. He further stated subsequent communications to the lawyers acting for him at the time had gone

unanswered.   He submitted that based on the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Collard v Mendoza and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZHC 346
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Collard v Mendoza involves an application by Robyn June Collard and Graeme Robert Mendoza to the High Court of New Zealand, Auckland Registry, seeking substituted service orders in relation to an interlocutory application to transfer proceedings from Wellington to Auckland and to remove Kevin John Mendoza as the Administrator of the Estate of Mary Ruth Mendoza. Mary Ruth Mendoza passed away on 22 July 2020, and her will, dated 28 August 2002, was admitted to probate on 10 January 2023. Kevin Mendoza was appointed as the surviving executor of the will following the death of his brother, Dennis Lionel Mendoza, in August 2017. Despite communications from the estate's solicitors to Kevin's nominated solicitors, Kevin did not respond, prompting the applicants to file an interlocutory application on 26 October 2023 to remove Kevin as executor and transfer the proceedings to Auckland. The applicants further sought substituted service orders due to Kevin's unresponsiveness and his alleged verbal abuse during a phone call with the applicants' solicitor.

The central legal issues in this case revolve around the applicability of substituted service under Rule 6.8 of the High Court Rules 2016, given the impracticability of serving Kevin Mendoza personally. The applicants argued that reasonable efforts had been made to serve Kevin, and it was impractical to serve him personally due to his unresponsiveness and verbal abuse. They also contended that forwarding documents to Kevin's email address and his solicitor's email address would likely bring the documents to his attention, satisfying the requirement of serving the document at a place where it is likely to come to the notice of the person served. Additionally, the applicants sought to rely on an affidavit from their solicitor, Mr Francis Hugh Stott, despite the potential conflict of interest under Rule 13.5 of the Lawyers and Conveyancers Act (Lawyers: Conduct and Client Care) Rules 2008 (ROCCC).

The Court granted the order for substituted service, finding that reasonable efforts had indeed been made to serve Kevin Mendoza personally. Given Kevin's unresponsiveness and verbal abuse, the Court determined it was impracticable for the applicants to serve him personally. The Court also noted that forwarding the documents to Kevin's email address and his solicitor's email address would satisfy the requirement of serving the document at a place where it is likely to come to the notice of the person served. Regarding the affidavit of Mr Stott, the Court directed that he could continue acting for the applicants, as it was the only supporting evidence available other than the one-way email correspondence with Kevin, and Rule 13.5.2 of the ROCCC applied.