Coles v Earthquake Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2017-409-824

[2024] NZHC 637

BETWEEN

ANTONY THOMAS COLES

Plaintiff/Respondent

AND

THE EARTHQUAKE COMMISSION

Defendant/Applicant

Hearing: 18 March 2024

Appearances:

A J D Ferguson for Plaintiff/Respondent

M Eastwick-Field and M G Alison for Defendant/Applicant

Judgment:

22 March 2024


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE LESTER


COLES v THE EARTHQUAKE COMMISSION [2024] NZHC 637 [22 March 2024]

[1]                 Mr Coles is the owner of 25 Kellys Road, Mairehau, Christchurch (the house). The house was damaged in the Canterbury Earthquakes. Mr Coles was not the owner of the house at the time of the Canterbury Earthquakes, having purchased the property at auction on 22 August 2013.

[2]                 The owner of the  property at the time of the Canterbury Earthquakes made   a claim with the Earthquake Commission (EQC) relating to the damage to the house. EQC assessed the property.  EQC’s  assessment of the loss was made available to  Mr Coles at the time he purchased the house. The EQC repairs were carried out after his purchase. Mr Coles says EQC’s assessment of the earthquake damage was inadequate.

[3]                 In this proceeding, one of the claims Mr Coles brings is in negligence, alleging in summary  that  EQC  owes  a  duty  of  care  to  subsequent  owners  of  earthquake damaged properties to take  reasonable care when  assessing  the extent of earthquake damage and in scoping repairs. Mr Coles says that duty was breached and the proper cost to carry out the repairs is in excess of $500,000.00 which he claims as damages.1

[4]                 Mr Coles proceeding was commenced in 2017 and is set down for a three-week hearing beginning 8 July 2024. The delay in the matter being  set  down is  due to  Mr Coles having been charged with cannabis dealing offences which were eventually concluded by way of guilty pleas. After guilty pleas were entered, Mr Coles was sentenced in respect of those offences in February 2023.

[5]                 The Crown commenced proceedings under the Criminal  Proceeds (Recovery) Act 2019 (the Act) in 2020. Since then, most of Mr Coles’ assets, including the house, were subject to restraining orders under the Act meaning he did not have the resources to progress this proceeding, leading to various hearing dates being vacated.2 With Mr Coles’ guilty pleas, the Commissioner of Inland Revenue


1      The repair cost pleaded is $564,966.00.

2      A 15 day hearing scheduled to commence 6 March 2023 was vacated on 5 October 2022. An earlier 15 day hearing scheduled for 18 July 2022 was also vacated. A 3 May 2021 hearing date was offered but not suitable to Mr Coles.

(the Commissioner) filed forfeiture proceedings on 30 June 2023. The original forfeiture proceedings included both the house and the benefit of this proceeding.

[6]                 Nonetheless, from 8 March 2023, this matter has been scheduled for hearing in July 2024.

[7]                 In March 2023, aware of the intention of the Commissioner to file forfeiture…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Coles v Earthquake Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZHC 637
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand was called upon to decide a matter brought by Antony Thomas Coles against the Earthquake Commission (EQC). Mr Coles, the owner of a Christchurch house damaged by the Canterbury Earthquakes, alleges that EQC's assessment of the damage and its scope of repairs was inadequate. He claims EQC owes a duty of care to subsequent owners of earthquake-damaged properties to take reasonable care in assessing damage and scoping repairs, asserting this duty was breached, and he seeks damages in excess of $500,000. EQC has applied for a temporary stay of the proceedings pending the resolution of a separate forfeiture proceeding initiated by the Crown under the Criminal Proceeds (Recovery) Act 2019.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the High Court should grant EQC's application for a temporary stay of Mr Coles' proceeding pending the resolution of the forfeiture proceeding. EQC argued that the stay was necessary to prevent inconsistent findings between the two proceedings, given the outcome of the forfeiture proceeding could significantly impact the merits of Mr Coles' negligence claim. The court considered the applicability of Rule 10.12 of the High Court Rules 2016, which allows for the stay of proceedings if a common question of law or fact arises in both proceedings or if it is otherwise desirable to make such an order. The court held that a common thread existed between the two proceedings, as both would canvas the strength of the forfeiture application.

The court found that while there would be some prejudice to Mr Coles in delaying the hearing, the risk of inconsistent findings and the complications that the forfeiture issue would create for the July hearing outweighed this. The court also considered the potential for increased costs and complexity for both parties should the hearing proceed without resolution of the forfeiture application. Therefore, the court concluded that the stay was justified to avoid the risk of inconsistent outcomes and to promote efficiency in court proceedings. Accordingly, the court granted the stay and requested the Registrar to allocate a new three-week hearing for Mr Coles' case as soon as practicable.

In light of the grant of a stay, the court dismissed the application for security for costs, noting that the appropriateness of such security would depend on the circumstances at the time. The court reserved costs to be costs in the cause.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.