Colbart Limited v Eastpack Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND ROTORUA REGISTRY

CIV 2011-463-000828 [2012] NZHC 2175

BETWEEN  COLBART LIMITED Plaintiff

ANDEASTPACK LIMITED First Defendant

ANDEASTPACK KIWIFRUIT OPERATIONS LIMITED

Second Defendant

ANDRIVERLOCK ORCHARD PACK AND COOLSTORE LIMITED

Third Defendant

Hearing:         23 August 2012

Appearances: D Llewell and W J Revell for the Plaintiff

A A Hopkinson for the First and Second Defendants
J H Olphert for the Third Defendant

Judgment:      23 August 2012

ORAL JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE CHRISTIANSEN

Solicitors/Counsel:

W Revell, Dowthwaite Law, Rotorua – Wallace@dowthwaitelaw.co.nz

A A Hopkinson, CooneyLeesMorgan, Tauranga – ahopkinson@clmlaw.co.nz

J Olphert, Olphert & Associates, Rotorua –  jon@olphert.co.nz

COLBART LIMITED V EASTPACK LIMITED HC ROT CIV 2011-463-000828 [23 August 2012]

[1]      The defendants have applied for security for costs.  They believe the plaintiff

(Colbart) will be unable to pay costs if it is unsuccessful in its proceeding.

[2]      These  applications  will  focus  upon  a  consideration  of  the  merits  of  the Colbart’s claims.   Colbart does not accept it would be unable to meet security if ordered.   Colbart says the defendants have fallen short of proof that it would be unable to meet a costs award.

The proceeding

The claim

[3]      The claim is about the purchase of kiwifruit rootstock for planting in the Te Kaha area.  Colbart pleads that on or about 4 July 2011 it entered into a contract by which the first defendant (Eastpack) and or the second defendant (EKO) would sell 1,800 items of kiwifruit vine rootstock (the Eastpack-EKO plants) and Colbart would pay $8.50 plus GST plus freight for each of those.

[4]      On  or  about  16  August  2011  Colbart  says  it  and  the  third  defendant (Riverlock) entered into an agreement by which Riverlock would supply 2,000 items of kiwifruit vine rootstock (the Riverlock plants) to it at a cost of $7.00 plus GST for each item.

[5]      As to the Eastpack – EKO contract Colbart claims that a Ms MacDonald of those  companies  contacted  Mr  Campbell  of  Colbart  with  an  offer  to  sell  the Eastpack-EKO plants; that Mr Campbell inspected those plants on or about 3 July

2011 and afterwards telephoned Ms MacDonald to ask for a price; that on 4 July

2011 Ms MacDonald sent a txt message to Mr Campbell to say the price of those plants  was  $8.50  plus  GST  and  freight  per  plant;  and  that  same  day  that  Mr Campbell spoke with Ms MacDonald by telephone to say he was happy with that price and he requested an invoice to be sent.

[6]      Mr Campbell says that he and another pruned and sprayed the plants to ready them for transportation, and on 20 July 2011 Colbart paid the amount due under the

contract, less the freight component which was then unknown.  Earlier on 20 July

2011 Mr Campbell said he enquired of Ms MacDonald to whom he should pay the amount and that Ms MacDonald told him to pay the money to EKO.

[7]      Mr Campbell said that subsequently Eastpack/EKO subsequently advised it was their intention not to perform the contract.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Colbart Limited v Eastpack Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 2175
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Colbart Limited initiated proceedings against Eastpack Limited, Eastpack Kiwifruit Operations Limited, and Riverlock Orchard Pack and Coolstore Limited, concerning the purchase of kiwifruit rootstock. The defendants applied for security for costs, believing that Colbart would be unable to pay costs if it was unsuccessful. Colbart, however, argued that there was no evidence to support such a belief.

The central legal issues were whether there was evidence indicating that Colbart would be unable to pay costs if unsuccessful, and whether the merits of Colbart's claims suggested a likelihood of failure. The court considered Rule 5.45, which allows for the ordering of security if the court believes the plaintiff may be unable to pay costs. The court must balance the plaintiff's right to pursue claims against the defendant's right to protection from unjustified litigation.

The court found that Colbart, which had no real estate and an uncertain trading history, likely relied on its director's personal funds. Given Colbart's financial situation, the court concluded there was good reason to believe it would be unable to pay costs if unsuccessful. On the merits, the court found Colbart's claims equivocal and difficult to assess at that stage, with significant reliance on the credibility of Colbart's representative.

As for the quantum, the court ordered security of $40,000, to be paid in cleared funds, to be held on interest-bearing deposit until further order. The court reserved leave for the defendants to make a further application for security in connection with the trial. The proceeding would be stayed until the security was paid. Colbart was to pay costs on a 2B basis, together with disbursements to the defendants.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.