Cogle v IAG New Zealand Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2018-409-258

[2019] NZHC 793

BETWEEN

STEPHEN COGLE and ALEXIS COGLE

Plaintiffs

AND

IAG NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 9 April 2019

Appearances:

J W Goddard and J R Parker for Plaintiffs

R W Raymond QC and V A Ma for Defendant

Judgment:

11 April 2019


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE LESTER


[1]    The defendant, IAG New Zealand Ltd (“IAG”), has applied for an order under r 9.34 of the High Court Rules, requiring the plaintiffs to make available “electronic information” for inspection by IAG’s expert. The specific information that is sought to be cloned and subjected to inspection was broadly described in the application as “all information held electronically on the plaintiffs’ computer equipment”. The specific equipment in relation to which orders are sought was refined in the draft order tabled by Mr Raymond QC during the hearing.

[2]    The plaintiffs’ counsel Mr Goddard understandably did not take issue with the draft order referring to specific electronic equipment as such narrowed the breadth of the application.

COGLE v IAG NEW ZEALAND LTD [2019] NZHC 793 [11 April 2019].

Context

[3]    The plaintiffs are the owners of a property damaged in the Canterbury earthquakes. The defendant provided insurance cover for the property.

[4]    On 24 May 2017, IAG’s solicitors declined the plaintiffs’ claim on the grounds that they had fabricated or modified documents to inflate the cost to rebuild the damaged property so as to bolster their position in the course of the negotiation of    a cash settlement of their claim. The claim was declined prior to any payment being made and the plaintiffs issued proceedings in April 2018 asserting, among other things, that IAG’s declining their claim amounted to a breach of contract.

[5]    The statement of defence set out what proper particulars in relation to IAG’s allegations of submission of fraudulent documents and the making of false/untrue/incomplete/misleading statements.

[6]    Prior to the case management conference on 14 August 2018, IAG in its memorandum for the conference sought access to information held electronically on the plaintiffs’ computer equipment, given the suspicion that such computer equipment may have been used to amend or create the documents. While Associate Judge Osborne’s Minute after the conference contemplated that IAG’s  computer expert,  Mr Whale, would have access to the electronic information, His Honour did not make an express order in that regard.

[7]    On 25 September 2018, counsel for IAG wrote to the plaintiffs’ counsel with a suggested proposed protocol for the cloning and searching of the electronic data. The letter concluded:

As indicated above, Mr Whale, Duncan Cotterill and IAG are willing to provide undertakings as required. If agreement cannot be reached we will be seeking from the Court orders for the hard drive and other digital information to be disclosed.

[8]    “Duncan Cotterill are IAG’s solicitors and are included as the protocol suggested that Duncan Cotterill’s IT team, upon providing appropriate undertakings, would be involved in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cogle v IAG New Zealand Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZHC 793
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand was asked to decide whether IAG New Zealand Limited should be allowed to inspect electronic information held on the plaintiffs' computer equipment. The plaintiffs, Stephen Cogle and Alexis Cogle, own a property that was damaged in the Canterbury earthquakes. IAG provided insurance cover for the property, but declined the plaintiffs' claim on the grounds that they had fabricated or modified documents to inflate the cost to rebuild the damaged property. The plaintiffs issued proceedings against IAG, alleging, among other things, that IAG's declining their claim amounted to a breach of contract. IAG sought an order under r 9.34 of the High Court Rules, requiring the plaintiffs to make available "electronic information" for inspection by IAG's expert. The plaintiffs opposed the order.

The court had to decide whether the inspection was necessary to enable the proper determination of any matter in question in the proceeding, and if so, what terms should be attached to the order. The court found that the inspection was necessary as it may directly shed light on key allegations in the proceeding. The court also considered the principles of inspection and ordered that IAG's expert, Brent Peter Whale, would provide a confidentiality undertaking to the plaintiffs' solicitors. The court ordered that Mr Whale would clone the electronic equipment within 48 hours of receipt of the plaintiffs' undertaking and return the equipment within 48 hours of taking the clones. The court also ordered that Mr Whale would focus his investigation on specific documents identified as Exhibits "A" to "E" of the affidavit of Caroline Pua Emile dated 6 December 2018. The court ordered that the costs of the cloning and the report to IAG would be met by IAG. The court also ordered that the data on the clones taken by Mr Whale would be forensically wiped once the Court process is complete. The court ordered that IAG is to file submissions on costs within five working days of this judgment.