Cochrane v Totara Properties Whangarei Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WHANGAREI REGISTRY

CIV-2012-488-177 [2014] NZHC 1006

UNDER the Companies Act 1993 setion 174

IN THE MATTER OF

TOTARA PROPERTIES WHANGAREI LIMITED

BETWEEN

GRANT ALEXANDER C OCHRANE NOEL BRENT COCHRANE and LARRY PETER COCHRANE Plaintiffs

AND

TOTARA PROPERTIES WHANGAREI LIMITED

First Defendant

ALEXANDER REGINALD COCHRANE Second Defendant

ALEXANDER REGINALD COCHRANE MAQ TRUSTEES 2011 LIMITED and MAC TRUSTEE SERVICES LIMITED as trustees of the SNOW COCHRANE NO.1

TRUST
Third Defendants

Continued over the page

Hearing: 14 May 2014

Appearances:

J A Browne for Plaintiffs
G P Curry and P J Magee for Second to Ninth Defendants

Judgment:

14 May 2014

ORAL JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE BELL

COCHRANE and OTHERS v TOTARA PROPERTIES WHANGAREI LIMITED [2014] NZHC 1006 [14 May

2014]

MAREE JOYCE COCHRANE Fourth Defendant

MAREE JOYCE COCHRANE

MAQ TRUSTEES 2011 LIMITED and SHAREE MILDRED COCHRANE as trustees of the MAREE COCHRANE NO.1 TRUST Fifth Defendants

SHAREE MILDRED COCHRANE Sixth Defendant

SHAREE MILDRED COCHRANE and

CAROLYN JANICE HARRISON

as trustees of the JS FAMILY TRUST Seventh Defendants

SHARLA COCHRANE Eighth Defendant

SHARLA COCHRANE and CAROLYN JANICE HARRISON as trustees of the SHARLA COCHRANE FAMILY TRUST Ninth Defendant

[1]      This case has been set down for a substantive hearing for five days beginning on 26 May 2014.  That is only eight working days away.  At the same time as this proceeding is to be heard, the plaintiffs also wish the court to hear their application that at least some of the defendants are in breach of interim injunction orders made in December 2012.

[2]      The second to ninth defendants have applied for leave to join a third party. They  do  not  want  the  hearing  in  this  case  to  go  ahead  unless  they  have  the opportunity to have their claims against the third party heard and decided at the same time.  If that third party is to be joined, there is obviously not enough time to serve him and give him adequate opportunity to file a defence, go through all the interlocutory steps (including discovery) and to prepare for a hearing.  That means that this application to join the third party also requires me to consider whether the hearing to start on 26 May should be adjourned.

[3]      The joinder and adjournment decision involves the exercise of a discretion under which the court has to weigh up competing considerations.  Rule 4.8 of the High Court Rules recognises that the decision to join a third party involves the exercise of the discretion.  Similarly, in O’Malley v Southern Lakes Helicopters Ltd Tipping J recognised the discretionary nature of adjournment decision when he said:1

However the essential question which the Court always has to consider when asked for an adjournment is whether or not that is necessary in order to do justice between the parties.   One must not overlook that not only is it necessary to do justice to the party who is seeking the adjournment but also justice to the party who wishes to retain the benefit of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cochrane v Totara Properties Whangarei Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 1006
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves a family dispute within the Cochrane family. The plaintiffs, the sons of Snow Cochrane, allege that they have been unfairly treated as shareholders of Totara Properties Whangarei Limited. They seek relief under section 174 of the Companies Act 1993. The defendants include Snow Cochrane, his wife Maree, their daughter Sharee, and other trustees associated with the family trusts. The plaintiffs claim that the company has been run in a way that benefits others but excludes them. The defendants argue that they acted on advice from their former lawyer, Mr Swanepoel.

The legal issues in this case revolve around the nature of a claim under section 174 of the Companies Act and the appropriate relief for the plaintiffs if their claims are successful. The court must also consider the defendants' application to join Mr Swanepoel as a third party and whether to adjourn the hearing to allow for the joinder.

The court dismissed the application for joinder and refused the adjournment. The court considered the exercise of discretion under Rule 4.8 of the High Court Rules and the discretionary nature of adjournment decisions. The court weighed various factors, including the efficiency of hearing all matters together, the potential for wasted costs and delay, and the desirability of adhering to fixtures. The court found that the dominant consideration was to maintain the fixture and allow the plaintiffs to have their claims heard. The court also considered the potential impact on Mr Swanepoel and the need for him to be heard separately. The court concluded that it would be in the best interest of the case and the parties to proceed with the hearing as scheduled.

The court ordered that the case may require up to seven days and made an order for costs in favour of the plaintiffs under category 2.