Cleven v R HC Auckland CRI 2011-404-268

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CRI 2011-404-268

BETWEEN  PETER WILLIAM CLEVEN Appellant

ANDTHE QUEEN Respondent

Hearing:         15 November 2011

Appearances: R Mansfield for appellant

B Hamlin for respondent

Judgment:      18 November 2011

JUDGMENT OF ALLAN J

Solicitors:

R Mansfield, Auckland  ron@22lorne.co.nz

Crown Solicitor Auckland,  ben.hamlin@meredithconnell.co.nz

CLEVEN V R HC AK CRI 2011-404-268 18 November 2011

[1]      This is an appeal against a sentence of 20 months imprisonment imposed upon the appellant by Judge Lovell-Smith in the Pukekohe District Court on 25 July

2011.  Mr Cleven had pleaded guilty to a charge of theft in respect of a 2005 Ducati motorcycle, valued at $15,000.

[2]      Mr Mansfield does not cavil at the Judge’s assessment of an appropriate term of imprisonment, but argues that a sentence of home detention ought to have been imposed instead.

Factual background

[3]      On 7 January 2011 the appellant sent a text message to the complainant, asking him to come to the appellant’s address with his Ducati motorcycle.   The complainant did so.  When he arrived, the appellant accused him of having had a relationship with the appellant’s partner in his absence.  There was an allegation of attempted drug rape.

[4]      Both the appellant and the complainant had an extensive criminal history. The appellant, a friend of the complainant, felt betrayed.  Motivated by a desire to protect his partner he took matters into his own hands and asked the complainant what the latter thought ought to be done.   Although the complainant denied any wrong-doing, he offered to repair the appellant’s driveway without charge.  He also suggested that the appellant give him (the complainant) a hiding.  Neither alternative was accepted by the appellant, who instead asked for the keys to the motorcycle. They were handed over by the complainant, who later said he had felt intimidated. The appellant indicated to the complainant that he did not intend to keep the bike, but that he would do so until the problems had been “sorted out”.

[5]      When the complainant returned to the appellant’s residence on 10 January

2011 (three days later), he was told he could have the bike back for $10,000.  Later, the appellant telephoned the complainant to advise that the price was now $11,000.

[6]      On the following day, the appellant went to the complainant’s residence. There he waved a stick at the complainant, shouted at him and complained that the complainant had “disrespected” the appellant.   But the price for return of the motorcycle had fallen back to $10,000 once more.

[7]      On 13 January 2011 the appellant sent a text message to the complainant, asking  if  he  wanted  his  bike  back.    Thereafter,  the  appellant  transferred  the ownership of the bike into his own name.

[8]      The complainant complained to the police. The motorcycle was subsequently returned undamaged.

District Court sentencing

[9]      The Judge commenced her detailed sentencing remarks by reviewing the facts and then the appellant’s personal and offending history.  In particular, she noted the contents of the pre-sentence report, including a recommendation…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cleven v R HC Auckland CRI 2011-404-268 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 1892
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal pertains to a sentence of 20 months imprisonment imposed on Peter William Cleven by Judge Lovell-Smith in the Pukekohe District Court on 25 July 2011. Cleven had pleaded guilty to a charge of theft in relation to a 2005 Ducati motorcycle valued at $15,000. Counsel for the appellant, Mr Mansfield, did not challenge the appropriateness of the term of imprisonment but argued that a sentence of home detention should have been imposed instead. The court was required to determine whether the sentencing judge erred in her decision to impose a sentence of imprisonment instead of home detention, as argued by the appellant.

The court considered the arguments presented by the appellant's counsel, including the appellant's advanced woodworking skills, recent completion of a sentence of 180 hours community work, low risk to the safety of others, and significant degree of remorse and an early guilty plea. However, the court also considered the appellant's extensive criminal history, including dishonesty, drug, and violent offending. The court found that the circumstances of this offence, Cleven's poor previous record, and the remarkable similarity of this case to the offence for which he was previously sentenced provided an unpromising foundation for a home detention argument. The court concluded that the appellant's personal considerations did not outweigh the countervailing factors, which suggested the unavailability of home detention.

The court dismissed the appeal, finding that the sentencing judge did not fall into error in reaching the conclusion that a sentence of imprisonment was appropriate in this case. The court emphasized the importance of taking into account the appellant's previous record, the seriousness of the offending, and the need to protect victims and the general public in the sentencing exercise. The court also highlighted that a plea for leniency from a victim will not usually be accorded great weight, given that a crime is a public wrong. However, the court acknowledged that the views of the victim are not to be totally ignored and took into account the complainant's lingering concern in considering the argument for home detention.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established