Clark v Hansen

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND PALMERSTON NORTH REGISTRY

CIV-2011-454-396 [2016] NZHC 764

BETWEEN

CHRISTINE ANNE CLARK

Plaintiff

AND

WILLIAM JOHN HANSEN AND ALEXANDER MCKENZIE GILCHRIST Defendants

Hearing: 4 March 2016

Counsel:

R Parmenter for the Plaintiff
No appearance for the Defendants

Judgment:

22 April 2016

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE SMITH

[1]      This is a matter with a fairly long history.  The plaintiff (Ms Clark) owned a property in  Levin  (the land) with the defendants (Mr Hansen and Mr Gilchrist). Ms Clark owned a one half share in the land, and the defendants each owned (as tenants in common with Ms Clark) a quarter share in the land.

[2]      The  parties  had  entered  into  a  property  agreement  dated  21  July  2006 recording the terms of their “partnership” in the land (the property agreement). Relevant terms of the property agreement included a provision that rates, insurance and other outgoings (but not mortgages) were to be shared equally between Ms Clark and the defendants (cl 2), and each party was entitled to secure a debt by way of mortgage over the land, that party being responsible for his or her particular obligations under the mortgage and being responsible to indemnify the co-owners in

respect of that liability (cl 3).

CHRISTINE ANNE CLARK v WILLIAM JOHN HANSEN AND ALEXANDER MCKENZIE GILCHRIST [2016] NZHC 764 [22 April 2016]

[3]      In the event of the parties agreeing to sell the land, the net proceeds of sale were to be divided in the proportions 50 per cent to Ms Clark, and 50 per cent to Messrs Hansen and Gilchrist (cl 4).

[4]      In   June   2011,   Ms Clark   applied   for   orders   under   s 339   of   the Property Law Act 2007 (the Act) directing that the land be sold and the proceeds distributed between the co-owners as if the sale had been made pursuant to the property agreement.  Certain other orders were sought which are not now relevant.

[5]      Ms Clark applied for summary judgment on her claims, and orders were made by Miller J on 4 October 2011.  The Judge made an order under s 339(1) of the Act for the sale of the land.  Detailed provisions were included in the order for the manner in which the land was to be marketed, and a procedural mechanism was included which would have permitted a party to buy out his or her co-owners.  An independent solicitor was appointed to act for the parties on the sale of the land.  The independent solicitor was required to repay and discharge any mortgages over the land, apportion any amount repaid to any mortgagee to the appropriate party’s account, pay any outgoings due in respect of the land such as rates, and balance and apportion between the parties all outgoings previously paid by one or other of the parties (including land agent’s marketing costs and valuer’s costs), to the intent that all the outgoings which had been paid would end up being shared in the proportions of the parties’ ownership of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clark v Hansen and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 764
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Christine Anne Clark sued William John Hansen and Alexander McKenzie Gilchrist over the sale of a property in Levin. The property was owned by the parties as tenants in common. The dispute arose from the property agreement dated 21 July 2006, which outlined the terms of their partnership in the land. The agreement stipulated that the net proceeds from the sale of the land were to be divided in the proportions of 50 per cent to Ms Clark and 50 per cent to Messrs Hansen and Gilchrist. The court was required to determine how the net proceeds from the mortgagee sale of the property should be apportioned among the parties. The court needed to consider whether Ms Clark was entitled to reimbursement for payments made on behalf of Messrs Hansen and Gilchrist and if there was a basis for awarding interest on those payments.

The court reasoned that the changed circumstances justified further variation of the judgment. Ms Clark was responsible for a half share of the agent's commission and legal and other costs on the mortgagee sale, but she was not liable for the total amount paid from the sale proceeds to Messrs Hansen and Gilchrist's mortgagee. Messrs Hansen and Gilchrist were liable to indemnify Ms Clark for the respective amounts of $69,544.76 and $65,783.47 under clause 3 of the property agreement. Ms Clark was also entitled to reimbursement for outgoings she had paid on behalf of Messrs Hansen and Gilchrist, such as marketing costs, rates, and a valuation fee. The court found that Ms Clark was entitled to the sums she claimed, including interest on the payments made on behalf of Messrs Hansen and Gilchrist. The judgment of the court dated 4 October 2011, as subsequently varied, was further varied to reflect the apportionment of the net proceeds from the mortgagee sale. Judgment was entered for Ms Clark against Messrs Hansen and Gilchrist for interest on the payments made on their behalf. Costs and disbursements were awarded to Ms Clark, and Messrs Hansen and Gilchrist were ordered to be jointly and severally responsible for the costs and disbursements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established