Church Property Trustees v Attorney-General

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2012-409-002745 [2015] NZHC 1843

BETWEEN

CHURCH PROPERTY TRUSTEES

Plaintiff

AND

ATTORNEY-GENERAL First Defendant

THE GREAT CHRISTCHURCH BUILDINGS TRUST

Second Defendant

Hearing: 22 April 2015

Counsel:

JWA Johnson for Plaintiff Trustees
P J Gunn for First Defendant
FMR Cooke QC, A Foote for Second Defendant

Judgment:

5 August 2015

JUDGMENT OF DUNNINGHAM J

Summary of findings

A.The restitution of the funds expended on the Transitional Cathedral, to the Cathedral Trust, plus interest, means there is no requirement for CPT to seek relief from liability under s 73 of the Trustee Act 1956.

B.       If  an  application  for  relief  under  s  73  was  live,  there  is  insufficient information to conclude that relief should be granted.

C.       CPT is not in breach of trust for failing to insure the Cathedral for full replacement value.

D.The insurance moneys received in respect of the claim under the insurance policy that insured the Cathedral contents are not held on the Cathedral trust,

but are the property of the Chapter and declarations are made accordingly.

CHURCH PROPERTY TRUSTEES v ATTORNEY-GENERAL AND ANOR [2015] NZHC 1843 [5 August 2015]

Contents

Introduction ............................................................................................................[1] The issues for determination in this case ...............................................................[8] Is the application for relief to be addressed under s 73 of the Trustee Act 1956 or

s 11 of the CPT Act?.............................................................................................[17]

Does repayment of the monies spent in breach of trust eliminate any issue of liability?................................................................................................................[19]

CPT’s position  [19] GCBT’s position  [21] Discussion  [22]

Relief under s 73 ..................................................................................................[27]

CPT’s position  [31]

GCBT’s position  [32]

When was CPT “on notice” of the potential breach and was its decision not to seek directions from the Court at that stage, honest and reasonable, and would it

be fair to excuse?..................................................................................................[36]

CPT’s position  [36] GCBT’s position  [40] Discussion  [45]

Should CPT’s decision not to insure the Cathedral for full replacement value tell against relief? .......................................................................................................[58]

CPT’s position  [59] GCBT’s position  [60] Discussion  [62]

Was it reasonable to decide to gift to St John’s church the Transitional Cathedral

and not seek restitution from the St John’s insurance proceeds? .........................[75] Conclusion on relief under s 73 ...........................................................................[78] Use of the Cathedral contents policy proceeds ....................................................[79]

CPT’s position  [81] GCBT’s position  [88] Discussion  [92]

Costs ...................................................................................................................[108]

Introduction

[1]      This decision represents a further chapter in the litigation which has ensued over the fate of the Christchurch Cathedral after it suffered significant damage in the Canterbury Earthquakes of 2010 and 2011.  The full background to the litigation is traversed in previous decisions, and will not be repeated here except where directly relevant to the issues in dispute.1

[2]      The Great Christchurch  Buildings Trust (GCBT) is concerned to see the reinstatement of the existing Christchurch Cathedral, which it says (and this Court has accepted) has social, cultural and heritage values beyond its role as a key place of worship for the Anglican Church.

[3]      The Church Property Trustees (CPT) is a statutory body, recognised in the Anglican (Diocese of Christchurch) Church Property Trust Act 2003…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Church Property Trustees v Attorney-General and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 1843
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case is a further chapter in the litigation that ensued over the fate of the Christchurch Cathedral following the Canterbury Earthquakes of 2010 and 2011. The Church Property Trustees (CPT), a statutory body holding property on various trusts for the Anglican Diocese of Christchurch, was found to have breached trust by spending insurance proceeds on the construction of a Transitional Cathedral. The Great Christchurch Buildings Trust (GCBT) opposed CPT's decision and sought judicial review of CPT's decision to deconstruct the existing Cathedral. The Court found that CPT was trustee of the Cathedral Trust, which required there to be a Cathedral on the Cathedral Square site in central Christchurch. However, it did not have to replicate the Cathedral as it stood before the earthquakes. The Court also found that the insurance proceeds for the material damage to the Cathedral were held for the same site-specific purpose. CPT subsequently sought relief from liability under s 73 of the Trustee Act 1956, if a breach of trust was found. The Court found that CPT had made good any breach of trust by repaying the funds used to construct the Transitional Cathedral, and there was no requirement for CPT to seek relief from liability under s 73. The Court also found that CPT was not in breach of trust for failing to insure the Cathedral for full replacement value. The insurance moneys received in respect of the claim under the insurance policy that insured the Cathedral contents are not held on the Cathedral trust, but are the property of the Chapter. The Court made declarations accordingly. The Court reserved the issue of costs, and if they are sought, memoranda may be filed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.