Child v Blackley

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WHANGAREI REGISTRY

CIV-2013-488-140 [2013] NZHC 490

UNDER  the High Court Rules

BETWEEN  LESLIE BRYAN CHILD AND AVRIL JEAN CHILD

Plaintiffs

ANDDAVID CHARLES BLACKLEY First Defendant

ANDPARUA BAY FARMS LIMITED Second Defendant

ANDALLAN ROY WILD Third Defendant

Hearing:         14 March 2013

Counsel:         W W Peters for the Plaintiffs

S R Carey for the Defendants

Judgment:      14 March 2013

(ORAL) JUDGMENT OF WOODHOUSE J

Counsel / Solicitors:

Mr W W Peters, Wayne Peters Lawyers, Solicitors, Whangarei

Mr S R Carey, Barrister, Auckland

Mr D M Grindle (for the defendants), Webb Ross McNab Kilpatrick Ltd, Solicitors, Whangarei

CHILD V BLACKLEY HC WHA CIV-2013-488-140 [14 March 2013]

[1]      The  plaintiffs  have  sought  an  interim  injunction  or,  in  the  alternative,  a freezing order in relation to 67 cows and 66calves.  This is the first mention in the Duty Judge list.

[2]      The plaintiffs’ case is that they purchased the animals from Country Land Ltd and at the same time took a lease from Country Land Ltd of a farm at Pullin Road near Whangarei (the Pullin Road farm).   The first defendant, Mr Blackley, as I understand  it,  is  a  shareholder  in  the  company.    The  other  shareholder  is  his estranged wife.   There are relationship property proceedings between Mr and Mrs Blackley and a number of other proceedings before the District Court and the High Court relating to the affairs of Mr and Mrs Blackley or companies in which they are interested.

[3]      The plaintiffs’ application for interim relief in respect of the cows and calves arises from the removal of the animals from the Pullin Road farm by Mr Blackley, or parties associated with him, in December 2012.  It appears not to be in issue that the animals were removed by, or at the request of, Mr Blackley and that he effectively retains possession of them.   It also appears not to be in dispute that the surviving animals are now on a farm owned by the third defendant, Mr Wild.

[4]      The plaintiffs now seek interim relief pending a fully defended hearing of the applications.  The interim relief sought by the plaintiffs in relation to these cows and calves is that they be returned to the Pullin Road farm where they would be managed by Mr Child, who is an experienced farmer, and held by him pending determination of the substantive claim.   There might also need to be arrangements for sale of calves.

[5]      The  defendants  resist  the  application  for  what  amounts  to  a  mandatory interim injunction.   They say they have had insufficient time to respond to voluminous evidence for the plaintiffs.  They say, through Mr Carey on their behalf, that the animals will be preserved in the meantime.  Mr Carey also submits that if anything untoward happens to any of the animals damages would be in any event an adequate remedy.

[6]      In respect of these animals I am satisfied that there are no grounds, at this stage at least, to make the mandatory orders sought by the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Child v Blackley and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 490
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, the plaintiffs Leslie Bryan Child and Avril Jean Child sought interim relief against David Charles Blackley, Parua Bay Farms Limited, and Allan Roy Wild. The plaintiffs sought an interim injunction or, alternatively, a freezing order in relation to 67 cows and 66 calves, which were removed from a farm they had leased. The plaintiffs argued that they had purchased the animals from Country Land Ltd, but the defendants claimed the sale was invalid. The defendants resisted the application for interim relief, arguing that damages would be an adequate remedy. The court found that there were no grounds to make the mandatory orders sought by the plaintiffs. The court ordered that the animals be held by or on behalf of the defendants, with a requirement that they manage the animals in accordance with good stock management practices. The court also ordered that animals, including calves, could be sold on such terms as the parties may agree, or in the alternative, the proceeds of sale could be paid into a solicitor’s trust account to be held in the meantime pending further order of the Court. The court also made an interim order in respect of the sheep owned by the plaintiffs and presently grazing on the Pullin Road farm. The court ordered that the defendants and any person associated with any of the defendants are not directly, or through any person on their behalf, to interfere with the sheep or otherwise interfere with the management of the sheep on the Pullin Road farm by or on behalf of the plaintiffs pending further order of the Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established