Child Poverty Action Group Inc v Attorney-General

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2009-404-273 [2012] NZHC 675

UNDER  Part 1A Human Rights Act 1993

BETWEEN  CHILD POVERTY ACTION GROUP INCORPORATED

Applicant

ANDTHE ATTORNEY-GENERAL Respondent

Hearing:         26 March 2012

Counsel:         F M Joychild and J M Ryan for applicant

J Foster and C I J Fleming for respondent

Judgment:      4 April 2012

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF DOBSON J

[1]      This is an application for leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal.

[2]      On 25 October 2011, a Court in which I sat with Ms Grant and Ms Ineson as lay members, dismissed an appeal brought by the present applicant (CPAG) from the Human Rights Review Tribunal (the Tribunal).  CPAG had sought a declaration that legislation  delivering  the Working  for  Families  in-work  tax  credit  (IWTC)  was inconsistent with the right to be free from discrimination, in relation to the alleged discrimination against children of those on State benefits.[1]    This was because the eligibility criteria for the  IWTC,  administered  under the  Income Tax Act  2007, excludes families where the caregivers are on State benefits.

[1] Provided for by s 92J of the Human Rights Act 1993

[3]      CPAG had argued that s MD8 in Part M of the Income Tax Act 2007, which requires that a person qualifying for the IWTC has to be a person, inter alia, who is.

not receiving an income-tested benefit, constituted discrimination on the grounds of employment status.   The extended definition of that phrase in s 21 of the Human Rights Act 1993 (HR Act) includes whether a person is a recipient of a benefit under the Social Security Act 1964 or an entitlement under the Injury Prevention, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 2001.

[4]      The first aspect of CPAG’s appeal to this Court was that the exclusionary provision in s MD8 breached s 19 of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 (BORA), which recognises all individuals’ rights to freedom from discrimination on the grounds of discrimination provided in the HR Act, ie including employment status.

[5]      The High Court judgment accepted the approach contended for on behalf of CPAG as to what will constitute discrimination.    However, it found that discrimination did not exist in the present circumstances because the class defined as the complainants, who were excluded from entitlement to the IWTC on account of their status as recipients of State benefits, were also excluded because of a ground

not challenged, namely that recipients have to be “full-time earners”.[2]   Accordingly,

their status as beneficiaries was not applied against them to their disadvantage, and the only ones discriminated against in any real (rather than theoretical) way were the very small number of “full time earners” who also elected to remain on a benefit.

[2] Income Tax Act 2007, s MD9(1).

[6]      The second aspect of the appeal was, if discrimination was made out, then the Crown as the alleged discriminator could not establish, for the purposes of s 5 of BORA, that the discrimination was occurring only to an extent that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Child Poverty Action Group Inc v Attorney-General and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 675
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Child Poverty Action Group Incorporated (CPAG) sought leave to appeal the High Court's decision that rejected its claim that the Working for Families in-work tax credit (IWTC) was inconsistent with the right to be free from discrimination, as provided in the Human Rights Act 1993. CPAG argued that the IWTC's eligibility criteria, which exclude families where the caregivers are on State benefits, constituted discrimination against children of those on State benefits. The central legal issues were whether the exclusionary provision in the Income Tax Act 2007 breached the right to freedom from discrimination on the grounds of employment status under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 (BORA), and if so, whether the Crown could demonstrate that the discrimination was demonstrably justified. The High Court found that discrimination did not exist as the exclusion was due to a ground not challenged, namely that recipients had to be "full-time earners". Even if discrimination were found, the Court concluded it would only be to an extent that was demonstrably justified.

Dobson J dismissed the application for leave to appeal. On the first issue, the Court found that the questions of law regarding the test for a breach of s 19 of the BORA were appropriate for further appellate consideration, subject to them having some utility. However, the Court held that the prospect of overturning the High Court's finding that the IWTC was not discriminatory was minimal. On the second issue, the Court found that the questions regarding the test for s 5 of the BORA were not seriously arguable, as the High Court had already determined that any discrimination would be demonstrably justified. The Court of Appeal had previously ruled in Trevethick v Ministry of Health that a partial or pyrrhic victory in having the Court recognise a relevant form of discrimination was not sufficient to warrant a grant of leave.

The final orders of the Court were that the application for leave to further appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.