Cheng v Prison Manager, Auckland South Corrections Facility (Serco)

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2020-404-001704

[2022] NZHC 3015

BETWEEN

THOMAS CHENG

First Applicant

JAMES ALLAN HEMANA
Second Applicant

AND

PRISON MANAGER, AUCKLAND SOUTH CORRECTIONS FACILITY (SERCO)

First Respondent

SECUREFUTURE WIRI LIMITED
Second Respondent

SERCO NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
Third Respondent

MINISTER OF CORRECTIONS

Fourth Respondent

Hearing: 3 October 2022

Counsel:

TC Stephens and MRG van Alphen Fyfe for Applicants JK Scragg and EM Greig for First and Third Respondents EM Watt and SK Shaw for Fourth Respondent

Judgment:

18 November 2022


JUDGMENT OF DOWNS J


This judgment was delivered by me on Friday, 18 November 2022 at 11 am

pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors/Counsel:

Ord Legal, Wellington. Duncan Cotterill, Wellington. Meredith Connell, Auckland. TC Stephens, Wellington.

MRG van Alphen Fyfe, Wellington.

CHENG v PRISON MANAGER, AUCKLAND SOUTH CORRECTIONS FACILITY (SERCO) [2022] NZHC 3015 [18 November 2022]

The case

[1]    Thomas Cheng and James Hemana1 seek judicial review of three matters in relation to their incarceration: rates of earnings for prison work; the cost of telephone calls   at   Auckland   South   Corrections   Facility,2   which   is   managed    by  Serco New Zealand Ltd;3 and the process followed by Serco in setting canteen prices at the facility. Mr Cheng is serving a long prison sentence for importing and supplying methamphetamine. He was recently convicted of like offending committed within and from prison.4 Mr Hemana is serving a life sentence for murdering his stepson. Both applicants served time at the facility but are now incarcerated elsewhere.

[2]For those short of time, a précis of what this judgment holds is at [76]–[78].

Rates of earnings paid to prisoners

Background

[3]    Prisoners are offered employment to promote their rehabilitation. A variety of work is available, including, for example, within kitchens, laundries, and other parts of prison facilities. Some prisons facilitate farming, forestry, and horticultural work. In each case, the aim is the same: establishment of a work ethic; acquisition of a skillset; and the fostering of a pro-social mindset.5

[4]    Prisoners are paid for their work. However, as may be expected, their rates of remuneration bear little resemblance to those offered by the market. The applicable rates are in this table:


1      The applicants.

2      The facility.

3      Serco.

4      R v Cheng [2022] NZDC 11309.

5      The applicants have had various prison jobs. Mr Cheng worked in the kitchen at Rimutaka prison. At Tongariro prison, he cleaned, and maintained the computer room. Mr Hemana worked in the kitchen at Paremoremo prison. In other prisons, he has been a cleaner.

Class

Category

Rates of earnings per hour

Earnings for 30-hour week

Earnings for 40-hour week

Zero

Refused / removed from work

$0.00

$0.00

$0.00

1

Sick or unemployed

$0.09

$2.70 max

$2.70 max

2

Initial

$0.20

$6.00

$8.00

3

Average

$0.30

$9.00

$12.00

4

Senior

$0.40

$12.00

$16.00

5

Advanced

$0.60

$18.00

$24.00

6

Programme / study allowance

Per employment status, or class 2, 3 or 4 if…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cheng v Prison Manager, Auckland South Corrections Facility... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZHC 3015
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves judicial review of three matters related to the incarceration of Thomas Cheng and James Hemana at Auckland South Corrections Facility, managed by Serco New Zealand Ltd. The applicants seek a review of the rates of earnings for prison work, the cost of telephone calls at the facility, and the process followed by Serco in setting canteen prices. The primary legal issues revolve around whether the Minister of Corrections was required to approve rates of earnings under the Corrections Act 2004 and whether the Minister's failure to do so constituted an unlawful omission. Additionally, the applicants argue that Serco unlawfully set fees for outgoing telephone calls without proper delegation and that Serco failed to consider mandatory factors in setting canteen prices.

The Court found that the Corrections Act 2004 required the Minister to approve rates of earnings under that Act, and the Minister's failure to do so constituted an unlawful omission. The Court reasoned that the statutory language, the purpose of the Act, and the principles guiding the operation of the corrections system all pointed to a duty on the Minister to approve rates under the Act. The Court rejected the Minister's argument that the power to approve rates was merely discretionary, noting that the nature of the power and its implications for prisoners' rights necessitated a duty to exercise it.

Regarding the fee for outgoing telephone calls, the Court concluded that Serco acted unlawfully by setting the fee without the required delegation from the chief executive of the Department of Corrections. This finding was based on a concession by Serco that it had not obtained the necessary delegation. The Court also noted that the applicants' claim regarding canteen pricing was dismissed because it was not adequately pleaded, as the real issue appeared to be the adequacy of food and hygiene provisions, not the pricing itself.

In summary, the Court granted declarations that the Minister of Corrections acted unlawfully by not approving rates of earnings under the Corrections Act 2004 and that Serco acted unlawfully in setting fees for pre-April 2020 outgoing telephone calls without the required delegation. The claim regarding canteen pricing was dismissed due to inadequate pleading.