Castle Marsden Trust Limited v Vowles

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY

CIV-2014-412-000069 [2015] NZHC 1175

BETWEEN

CASTLE MARSDEN TRUST LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

SUSAN MARGARET VOWLES AND SOUTHERN TRUSTEES 2005 LIMITED Defendants

Submissions

received:

19 February 2015 (Defendant); 24 March 2015 (Plaintiff); and

14 May 2015 (Defendant)

Appearances:

L A Andersen for Plaintiff
B C Nevell for Defendants

Judgment:

28 May 2015

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE OSBORNE

as to costs

[1]      The  first-named  defendant,  Ms  Vowles,  seeks  an  order  of  costs  and

disbursements upon the plaintiff’s discontinuance of this proceeding.   Rule 15.23

High  Court  Rules  applies  so  that  the plaintiff  must  pay costs  unless  the Court otherwise orders.

[2]      The second-named defendant, Southern Trustees 2005 Ltd, took only a very preliminary part in this proceeding before retiring as a trustee of the Trust, whose interests were represented by Ms Vowles.

[3]      Ms Vowles, on the other hand, has been an active party in the proceeding and seeks costs.  She was belatedly a recipient of legal aid for the proceeding.  Mr Nevell has properly advised the Court that the total fees and disbursements approved by the Legal Services Agency amount to $5,426.85, which constitutes the sum which the

first-named defendant seeks by way of costs and disbursements.  The figure is, as Mr

CASTLE MARSDEN TRUST LIMITED v VOWLES [2015] NZHC 1175 [28 May 2015]

Nevell notes, less than the first-named defendant would have received on a 2B scale basis.

[4]      The  plaintiff,  Castle  Marsden  Trust  Ltd  (CMTL),  opposes  costs.     Mr Andersen, for CMTL, submits that this is a case where costs should not follow the discontinuance for three reasons:

(a)      the validity of CMTL’s substantive case;

(b)      Ms Vowles’ position; and

(c)      access to funds to meet any costs award.

Applicable considerations

[5]      I adopt the summary of principles as stated by the authors of McGechan on

Procedure which are derived from the leading authorities:1

HR15.23.01     Principles

The following emerge from Kroma Colour Prints Ltd v Tridonicatco NZ Ltd [2008] NZCA 150, (2008) 18 PRNZ 973 and FM Custodians Ltd v Pati & Ors [2012] NZHC 1902 at [10]-[12]:

(a)       Although the r 15.23 presumption is designed to give a certain and predictable outcome upon discontinuance, it may be displaced if the Court finds there are circumstances which make it just and equitable that it should not apply.

(b)       Although the Court is not limited in the factors it may take into account when considering whether the presumption is displaced, generally:

(i)        The  Court  will  not  consider  the  merits  of  the  respective cases, unless they are so obvious that they should influence the costs outcome.

(ii)       The Court will consider the reasonableness of the stance of both parties: whether it was reasonable for the plaintiff to bring and continue the proceeding, and for the defendant to oppose the proceeding up to the point of discontinuance.

(iii)      Conduct prior to the commencement of the proceeding may be  relevant  (for  example,  if  any  conduct  by  a  defendant

1      McGechan on Procedure (online looseleaf ed, Brookers)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Castle Marsden Trust Limited v Vowles and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 1175
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand was asked to decide a matter of costs in the case of Castle Marsden Trust Limited v Vowles. The plaintiff, Castle Marsden Trust Limited, sought a determination of its interest in a property owned by the family trusts of the parties, Philip Marsden and Susan Vowles. The defendants were Susan Vowles and Southern Trustees 2005 Limited, a trustee of the Vowles family trust. The plaintiff’s action was discontinued after its application for summary judgment was dismissed, and the defendants sought costs under Rule 15.23 of the High Court Rules. The plaintiff opposed the costs application, arguing that the costs should not follow the discontinuance due to the validity of its substantive case, the position of the defendants, and the access to funds to meet any costs award.

The court considered the principles surrounding the costs following discontinuance, including the general presumption that costs follow discontinuance unless the court finds it just and equitable not to apply the presumption. The court examined the three considerations raised by the plaintiff. The court found that the substantive proceeding was justifiably brought as the parties needed to reach a conclusive determination of their respective interests, despite the dismissal of the summary judgment application. The court also found that the defendants' position, where Ms Vowles wished to maintain the status quo for at least another decade, did not justify refusing costs. However, the court found that the plaintiff’s inability to continue funding loan repayments and the practical and commercial reasons for discontinuing the proceeding justified the court either refusing or reducing costs despite the principle that the determination of costs should be predictable and expeditious.

The court concluded that the proceeding was appropriately and responsibly commenced, but it was just, given that the plaintiff elected to discontinue when unsuccessful at summary judgment, that the plaintiff meet 50 per cent of what would otherwise be an appropriate order of costs, together with reasonable disbursements to be fixed by the Registrar. The court ordered the plaintiff to pay the costs of the first-named defendant in the sum of $2,736.25 and the reasonable disbursements of the first-named defendant, to be fixed by the Registrar. There was no order of costs in favour of the second-named defendant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.