Carter v Hutt Valley District Health Board

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA

TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2020-485-529

[2021] NZHC 2857

BETWEEN

JOHN CARTER

Applicant

AND

HUTT VALLEY DISTRICT HEALTH BOARD

First Respondent

CAPITAL AND COAST DISTRICT HEALTH BOARD

Second Respondent

ATTORNEY-GENERAL (for the Ministry of Health)

Third Respondent

Hearing: 26 October 2021

Counsel:

Applicant in person

I H V Reuvecamp for First and Second Respondents M L Clarke-Parker for Third Respondent

Judgment:

26 October 2021


JUDGMENT OF CHURCHMAN J


Introduction

[1]    Mr Carter (the applicant) brings proceedings against the Hutt Valley District Health Board (the first respondent), the Capital and Coast District Health Board (the second respondent), and the Attorney General (the third respondent) on the grounds that a summary of patient’s rights contained in a guideline document known as the “YOUR RIGHTS statement” under the Mental Health (Compulsory Assessment and Treatment) Act 1992 (the Act) does not correctly represent the scheme under Part 5 of the Act.

CARTER v HUTT VALLEY DISTRICT HEALTH BOARD [2021] NZHC 2857 [26 October 2021]

[2]    The guideline document in dispute was issued by the Director-General of Health in 2007 and is published by the Ministry of Health. Mr Carter’s position is that the guideline document is overly broad in describing when treatment is given compulsorily.

[3]    The hearing for this application was originally set down for 30 August 2021 but was adjourned as a result of the COVID-19 lockdown. Following this, Mr Carter has filed documents making three additional applications:

(a)leave to file a seventh amended statement of claim;

(b)transfer of the proceeding out of the Wellington Registry of the High Court and into the Supreme Court (in part on the basis of an application for recusal); and

(c)adjournment of the proceeding pending resolution of criminal prosecution of various officials and medical practitioners.

Relevant background

[4]    The background to Mr Carter’s application stretches back to 2010, and has been detailed by both Mr Carter and counsel assisting, Mr Orpin-Dowell. On 25 May 2010, Mr Carter’s son Christopher committed suicide at his home while subject to an inpatient order under s 30 of the Act. Since that point, Mr Carter has raised a number of concerns about the care Christopher received, including with the Health and Disability Commissioner and the District Inspector.

[5]    Mr Carter has now brought this proceeding challenging the accuracy of the “Your Rights” document, particularly in relation to the rights around compulsory medication. According to Mr Orpin-Dowell, his position is that patients may refuse treatment in a wider range of circumstances than those described in the document.

[6]    Mr Carter first filed his statement of claim in this Court in September 2020. The respondents’ statements of defence were filed in November 2020. Since then, Mr Carter has filed a number of amended statements of claim, until Associate Judge

Johnston, by way of a minute dated 14 April 2021, made an order directing that     Mr Carter’s most recent statement of claim (the “Sixth Amended Statement of Claim”) was not…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carter v Hutt Valley District Health Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NZHC 2857
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the High Court was brought by Mr John Carter against the Hutt Valley District Health Board, the Capital and Coast District Health Board, and the Attorney General, on the basis that the "Your Rights" statement issued by the Ministry of Health does not accurately reflect the provisions of the Mental Health (Compulsory Assessment and Treatment) Act 1992. The main issue before the Court was whether the statement is a clear and accurate result of a proper construction of Part 5 of the Act.

The Court declined Mr Carter’s application to file a seventh amended statement of claim, finding that any further amendment would add nothing of consequence and would only hinder the resolution of the proceeding by requiring the respondents to respond. The Court further declined Mr Carter’s application to transfer the proceeding to the Supreme Court, stating that it did not have jurisdiction to transfer proceedings to the Supreme Court, and that there was no merit to the suggestion that the High Court was unable to determine the application. The Court also dismissed Mr Carter’s application to adjourn the proceeding pending the investigation of alleged criminal conduct, finding that there was no evidence that the police were actively investigating any of the allegations.

The Court concluded that Mr Carter’s three interlocutory applications were dismissed, and directed that if there is to be any application for costs, the respondents are to file memoranda no more than three pages in length within five working days and the applicant is to file a reply within five working days of receipt of the respondents’ memorandum. The matter will be decided on the papers.