Carter v Capital and Coast District Health Board

Link copied
Case Copied 3 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI MANA NUI O AOTEAROA

 SC 119/2023
 [2024] NZSC 102
BETWEEN

JOHN HOWARD CARTER
Applicant

AND

CAPITAL AND COAST DISTRICT HEALTH BOARD
First Respondent

AND

HUTT VALLEY DISTRICT HEALTH BOARD
Second Respondent

AND

ATTORNEY‑GENERAL
Third Respondent

Court:

Glazebrook, Ellen France and Williams JJ

Counsel:

Applicant in person
I H V Reuvecamp for First and Second Respondents
S M Kinsler and C E Sinclair for Third Respondent

Judgment:

16 August 2024

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The application for recusal is dismissed.

B        The application for recall is dismissed.

C        There is no order as to costs.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

  1. Mr Carter applies for the recall of our decision of 29 July 2024, dismissing his application for leave to appeal.[1]

Recusal

  1. Mr Carter submits that the current panel should not decide this application.

  2. There are no proper grounds put forward for the current panel members to recuse themselves.

Background

  1. Mr Carter’s application for leave to appeal related to proceedings filed in the High Court.  The High Court had held that Mr Carter’s statement of claim disclosed no reasonably arguable cause of action.[2]

  2. That decision was upheld by the Court of Appeal.[3]

  3. In dismissing his application for leave to appeal, this Court held that nothing raised by Mr Carter threw doubt on the reasoning of the Courts below.[4]

Grounds of application

[4]Leave decision, above n 1, at [10].

  1. Mr Carter submits that there is a very serious reason the judgment should be recalled in that the Court did not take into account recommendations of the Royal Commission of Inquiry into Abuse in State Care.[5]  Mr Carter gives a number of matters he says are examples of this Court ignoring the Royal Commission’s recommendations. 

Our assessment

[5]Royal Commission of Inquiry into Historical Abuse in State Care and in the Care of Faith‑based Institutions Whanaketia: Through Pain and Trauma, from Darkness to Light (Wellington, 24 July 2024).

  1. A decision of this Court, whether concerned with leave to appeal or a substantive appeal, is, and must be, final.[6]  A judgment will only be recalled in exceptional circumstances, being those identified in Horowhenua County v Nash (No 2), as applied by this Court in Saxmere Company Ltd v Wool Board Disestablishment Company Ltd (No 2).[7]

  2. Mr…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carter v Capital and Coast District Health Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZSC 102
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Supreme Court of New Zealand dealt with an application from Mr. Carter, who sought both recusal of the current panel and recall of the Court's decision dismissing his application for leave to appeal. The Court had previously dismissed Mr. Carter's application for leave to appeal his case, which pertained to claims against the Capital and Coast District Health Board and the Hutt Valley District Health Board. The High Court and Court of Appeal had both found that Mr. Carter's statement of claim did not disclose a reasonably arguable cause of action. Mr. Carter argued that the Court's dismissal of his application for leave to appeal should be recalled, as the Court had allegedly failed to consider the recommendations of the Royal Commission of Inquiry into Abuse in State Care.

The legal issues before the Court were whether the panel should recuse themselves and whether the judgment dismissing Mr. Carter's application for leave to appeal should be recalled. The Court considered Mr. Carter's submission that the panel should not decide the application because there were serious reasons to doubt the judgment. However, the Court found that there were no proper grounds for recusal, as Mr. Carter did not provide any reasons that would warrant the panel stepping aside. Regarding the recall, the Court noted that a decision of the Supreme Court is final, and a judgment will only be recalled in exceptional circumstances, as identified in Horowhenua County v Nash (No 2). The Court held that Mr. Carter's application did not raise any exceptional circumstances that would justify recall, as none of the examples he gave related to the Royal Commission's recommendations. The Court concluded that the Royal Commission's recommendations were irrelevant to whether Mr. Carter's statement of claim disclosed a reasonably arguable cause of action.

The Court dismissed Mr. Carter's application for recusal and his application for recall. The Court held that Mr. Carter had not provided any grounds for the panel to recuse themselves, and that his application for recall did not meet the exceptional circumstances required for recall. As the respondents were not required to file submissions, there was no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established