Carter v Canterbury Design and Development Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2022-409-411

[2023] NZHC 1750

IN THE MATTER of specific performance of agreements to issue shares

BETWEEN

SIMON LAIDLAW CARTER

First Plaintiff

CHRISTOPHER JOHN SWANN
Second Plaintiff

AND

CANTERBURY DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT LIMITED

First Defendant

AARON JOHN HOOPER and CARL JAMES FORDYCE

Second Defendants

Counsel:

M G Kirkland for Plaintiffs

No appearance for First Defendant
G D Jones for A J Hooper (Second Defendant)
K M Prendergast for C J Fordyce (Second Defendant)

Judgment:

6 July 2023


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE LESTER

(Costs)


CARTER v CANTERBURY DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT LIMITED [2023] NZHC 1750 [6 July 2023]

[1]    The plaintiffs, as the successful parties in two interlocutory applications on this proceeding, seek costs. The plaintiffs sought summary judgment against the defendants alleging Mr Carter, on behalf of Mr Swann, was entitled to receive one- third of the shares in the first defendant. Perhaps more accurately it was not in issue that Mr Carter was entitled to the shares, the issue was whether a $150,000 payment to the first defendant was a precondition of the shares being transferred to him. The defendants responded by filing an objection to the Court’s jurisdiction, relying on an arbitration clause in the shareholders agreement between the parties. The plaintiffs applied to have the protest set aside and were successful.1 That left the plaintiffs’ application for summary judgment. I assume taking on board the observations made in the judgment concerning the objection to the Court’s jurisdiction, the defendants filed an admission of claim in respect of a number of aspects of the plaintiffs’ claim.

That resulted in a judgment upon the admissions dated 25 May 2023.2

[2]    In their admission the defendants accepted liability for costs on a 2B basis. Accordingly, judgment was entered as to liability in respect of costs. The plaintiffs signalled an intention to seek increased costs and this judgment deals with the application for increased costs.

[3]I am satisfied this is not a case for increased costs.

Contractual right to increased costs

[4]    The plaintiffs rely on provisions in their shareholders agreement and another agreement between the parties, known as the business agreement, to say they are entitled to indemnity costs.

[5]    Exactly where the obligation on the defendants to transfer one-third of the shares in the first defendant to Mr Cater on behalf of Mr Swann is to be found is unclear. That is not to say that the agreements do not contemplate Messrs Carter, Hooper and Fordyce being equal shares in the first defendant, it is just that pinpointing where that obligation is created is not straightforward. For example, the shareholders


1      Carter v Canterbury Design and Development Ltd [2023] NZHC 529.

2      Carter v Canterbury Design and Development Ltd [2023] NZHC 1249.

agreement, in its background, records that upon the parties entering into the sale and purchase agreement (the business agreement) the shareholding of the company would be equal. The shareholders agreement…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carter v Canterbury Design and Development Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 1750
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Christchurch Registry, Carter and Swann, the plaintiffs, sought specific performance of agreements related to the issuance of shares in Canterbury Design and Development Limited, against the company and two of its directors, Hooper and Fordyce, the defendants. The crux of the dispute was whether a $150,000 payment was a precondition for the transfer of one-third of the shares in the first defendant to the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs argued that they were entitled to the shares outright, while the defendants contended that the payment was necessary before any transfer could occur. The defendants also challenged the Court's jurisdiction, citing an arbitration clause in the shareholders agreement, but this objection was dismissed.

The legal issues before the court included whether the plaintiffs were entitled to rely on indemnity costs clauses in the agreements and if the defendants' actions warranted increased costs. The court found that the indemnity costs provisions could not be relied on because the source of the obligation to transfer shares was unclear. Additionally, the court ruled that the defendants had not acted vexatiously, frivolously, improperly, or unnecessarily, and thus, the plaintiffs were not entitled to increased costs. The court acknowledged the reasonable actions of the defendants in light of the previous judgments and the admissions made.

The outcome of the proceedings was that the plaintiffs were awarded costs on a 2B basis, amounting to $20,414.41, plus disbursements. This decision was based on the court's determination that the defendants' actions did not warrant an increase in costs beyond the standard rate. The court's ruling underscored the importance of clear contractual obligations and the necessity for defendants to act reasonably within the legal framework.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established