Carswell v Carswell

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND PALMERSTON NORTH REGISTRY

CIV 2013-454-031 [2013] NZHC 3562

UNDER the Family Protection Act 1955

IN THE MATTER OF

the estate of Hazel Franci Shand

BETWEEN

ANNABEL HAZEL CARSWELL Plaintiff

AND

WILLIAM HENRY CARSWELL and ALISON CLEMENCY FULLERTON- SMITH

Defendants

Hearing: 3 December 2013

Appearances:

D Sheppard for the Plaintiff
T Cleary for William Carswell
No appearance for Alison Fullerton-Smith

Judgment:

20 December 2013

JUDGMENT OF MALLON J

Introduction

[1]      Annabel Carswell claims against the estate of her late mother, Hazel Franci

Shand, under s 4 of the Family Protection Act 1955 (FPA).  Hazel had three children

– William, Alison and Annabel.  Under Hazel’s will William receives a much larger share of her estate than Annabel or Alison. Annabel says that the will failed to make provision for the fact that she is very ill, and has a dependant adult son.  Annabel seeks an order that the estate pay her a sum sufficient for her proper maintenance and support, interest and costs.  William opposes Annabel’s claim.  Alison has taken no

part in the proceeding and abides the Court’s decision.

CARSWELL v CARSWELL [2013] NZHC 3562 [20 December 2013]

Background facts

The estate

[2]      Hazel died, aged 96, on 21 December 2011.  Hazel’s first husband (William Carswell) died in 1971.   He was Annabel, Alison and William’s father.   Hazel’s second husband died in 1983.  There were no children from her second marriage. Hazel did not have another partner after her second husband’s death.  Hazel’s last will is dated 30 August 2005.  The executors are her son, William, and her daughter, Alison.   At the time of Hazel’s death, the value of her estate amounted to approximately $1.2m.  Its current value is in the order of $1,325,000.  Under her will William receives property worth approximately $980,000 (that is, approximately

74 per cent of the estate), whereas Alison and Annabel each receive property worth approximately $173,000 (that is, approximately 13 per cent of the estate).1

[3]      The  difference  in  what  Hazel’s  children  receive  arises  mainly  because William receives a property near Himatangi known as “the Swamp” and used as a shooting lodge (valued at $550,000).   He also receives a pine forest that William planted and tended on the Swamp (value of $177,000) and forgiveness of debts owed to Hazel by companies associated with William (value $78,605).  Apart from those items, Hazel distributed her estate equally between her children.   Each receives

$50,000 (Alison and Annabel in cash, William by way of forgiveness of all debts he owed personally to Hazel which amounts to $50,000).  They also each receive a one third share of the residue, less funeral and administration expenses (approximately

$432,000 of investments, of which a one third share is $123,140).  All of Hazel’s personal and domestic chattels are to be divided by Alison amongst the siblings in accordance with Hazel’s known wishes (value unclear).

Annabel’s circumstances

[4]      Annabel is 59 years old.  She divorced in 1995.  She has four children to her former husband who are now aged…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carswell v Carswell and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 3562
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Annabel Carswell claims against the estate of her late mother, Hazel Franci Shand, under s 4 of the Family Protection Act 1955 (FPA). Hazel had three children – William, Alison and Annabel. William and Alison have opposed Annabel’s claim. Hazel’s will gave William a significantly larger share of her estate than Annabel or Alison. Annabel argues that the will failed to make provision for the fact that she is very ill, and has a dependent adult son. She seeks an order that the estate pay her a sum sufficient for her proper maintenance and support, interest and costs. The first question in this kind of claim is whether there is adequate provision from Hazel’s estate for Annabel’s proper maintenance and support. The Court considers whether there has been a breach of moral duty as judged by the standard of a wise and just testator as at the time of her death. If there has been a breach of moral duty then the Court considers what is required. Although the Court may order “any provision the Court thinks fit”, an award to repair the breach of moral duty must be the minimum necessary because it is not for the Court to rewrite the will. The application is granted. Further provision from Hazel’s estate is to be made to Annabel in the sum of $85,000. That provision is to be made by increasing her share of the residuary and correspondingly decreasing William’s share by that amount.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established