Carolan v NZ Real Estate Credit Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2014-404-000483 [2016] NZHC 1239

BETWEEN

MICHAEL JOSEPH CHRISTIAN

CAROLAN Plaintiff

AND

NZ REAL ESTATE CREDIT LIMITED First Defendant /

First Counterclaim Plaintiff

GEORGE KERR Second Defendant

Defendants continued over

Hearing: 25 May 2016

Counsel:

D M Salmon and E D Nilsson for the Plaintiff
C M Hanafin for the Defendants

Judgment:

9 June 2016

JUDGMENT OF EDWARDS J

This judgment was delivered by Justice Edwards on 9 June 2016 at 4.30 pm, pursuant to

r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar
Date:

Counsel:     J K Goodall, Auckland

Solicitors:    Lee Salmon Long, Auckland

Lowndes Jordan, Auckland

CAROLAN v NZ REAL ESTATE CREDIT LTD and ORS [2016] NZHC 1239 [9 June 2016]

EQUITY PARTNERS CAPITAL MARKETS LIMITED

Third Defendant /
Second Counterclaim Plaintiff

EQUITY PARTNERS LIMITED Fourth Defendant /

Third Counterclaim Plaintiff

EQUITY PARTNERS ASSET MANAGEMENT LIMITED Fifth Defendant /

Fourth Counterclaim Plaintiff

CLAYMORE FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED

Sixth Defendant /
Fifth Counterclaim Plaintiff

Introduction

[1]      The defendants seek further discovery from the plaintiff.   The documents sought fall within eight separate categories identified in an amended application dated 18 May 2016 (defendants’ application).

[2]      The defendants claim that the documents are relevant to the terms on which advances were made to the plaintiff, and the level of remuneration he received when employed by some of the defendant companies.

[3]      The plaintiff opposes the defendants’ application on the grounds that it is out of time, the documents sought are either irrelevant to the dispute or are in the control of the defendants, and he has already provided discovery of all documents relevant to the dispute.   He submits that an order for further discovery at this late stage is likely to prejudice the six day trial due to commence on 27 June 2016.

[4]      The plaintiff also seeks an award of costs on his application for discovery from the defendants (plaintiff’s application).  That application was not argued in full due to the defendants providing further documents in response to the application two days prior to the hearing.

Claim and counterclaim

[5]      The  plaintiff  commenced  this  proceeding  in  March  2015,  and  filed  an amended statement of claim on 8 May 2015.   The parties are agreed that the key issues arise out of the defendants’ defence and counterclaim filed on 25 May 2015.

[6]      Those key issues concern the terms upon which advances totalling $1.165m were made by the third and fifth defendants (EPCM and EPAM respectively) to the plaintiff in 2007 and 2008. The advances were made to assist the plaintiff ’s purchase of a residential property in Remuera (Property).

[7]      The plaintiff was employed by EPCM in 2007, and then EPAM in 2008. EPCM and EPAM are part of the Equity Partners Group.  Prior to joining EPCM in

2007, the plaintiff was employed by Macquarie Bank.

[8]      The defendants say the advances made to the plaintiff were a loan made on terms requiring repayment within three years, and accruing interest at eight…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carolan v NZ Real Estate Credit Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 1239
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Carolan v NZ Real Estate Credit Limited involved the defendants seeking further discovery from the plaintiff, Michael Joseph Christian Carolan, regarding documents relevant to advances made to him and his remuneration from the defendant companies. The defendants argued that the documents were relevant to the terms of the advances and the level of remuneration received by Carolan. The plaintiff opposed the application, arguing it was out of time, the documents were irrelevant or already in the defendants' control, and it would prejudice the trial date. Additionally, the plaintiff sought an award of costs on his application for discovery from the defendants.

The court considered the principles relevant to orders for particular discovery under r 8.19 of the High Court Rules, which allow a judge to order a party to file an affidavit and make documents available for inspection if there are grounds for believing that a party has not discovered documents that should have been discovered. The court also considered the rules governing discoverability and the proportionality assessment in Schedule 9 Part 1 of the High Court Rules.

The court declined to order discovery of the documents sought by the defendants, finding that there were no grounds for believing that the documents were relevant to the issues in dispute or that they were in the plaintiff's control. The court also declined to make a costs order on the plaintiff's application for further discovery at that stage but granted leave to file further memoranda as to costs once all issues associated with the application had been finally resolved.

In conclusion, the court granted leave for the defendants to bring their application out of time, declined the defendants' application for further discovery, and awarded the plaintiff costs on a 2B basis in respect of that application. The plaintiff's application for costs on his discovery application was left open pending resolution of all issues associated with the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established