Cargill International SA v Solid Energy New Zealand Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2015-404-2355 [2016] NZHC 1817

BETWEEN

CARGILL INTERNATIONAL S.A.

Applicant

AND

SOLID ENERGY NEW ZEALAND LIMITED (SUBJECT TO DEED OF COMPANY ARRANGEMENT)

First Respondent

SPRING CREEK MINING COMPANY (SUBJECT TO DEED OF COMPANY ARRANGEMENT)

Second Respondent

Hearing: 9, 10, 11, 12, 13 May 2016

Counsel

D J Chisholm QC and J P Nolen for applicant

T C Weston QC, A E Ferguson and K E Morrison for first and second respondents

R B Stewart QC, L A OʼGorman and A L Harlowe for third
respondents
D R Kalderimis and K Yesberg for fourth respondents

Judgment:

5 August 2016

JUDGMENT OF KATZ J

This judgment was delivered by me on 5 August 2016 at 4:30pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:      Lowndes, Auckland Wilson Harle, Auckland Buddle Findlay, Auckland Chapman Tripp, Wellington

Counsel:        D J Chisholm QC, Auckland

T C Weston QC, Auckland

R B Stewart QC, Auckland

CARGILL INTERNATIONAL S.A. v SOLID ENERGY NEW ZEALAND LIMITED & ANOR [2016] NZHC 1817 [5 August 2016]

BRENDON JAMES GIBSON, and

GRANT ROBERT GRAHAM Third Respondents

ANZ BANK NEW ZEALAND LIMITED, BANK OF NEW ZEALAND, COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRALIA, WESTPAC NEW ZEALAND LIMITED, and DEUTSCHE BANK AG

Fourth Respondents

Table of Contents

Introduction ............................................................................................................... [1] Background to the DOCA......................................................................................... [6] Part 15A of the Companies Act 1993 ..................................................................... [13]

Cargill’s section 239ACX challenges - Does the DOCA contravene

Part 15A?..................................................................................................................[27]

Section 239 ACX - The legal principles……………………………….………...[27] Does the role of the Participants Committee contravene Part 15A?.................... [29] Does the DOCA contravene Part 15A by unlawfully restricting creditors’

statutory entitlement to vary the DOCA?.............................................................. [53]

Do the clauses in the DOCA compromising Solid Energy’s or creditors’

claims against third parties (or releasing the liability of third parties)

contravene Part 15A?  .......................................................................................... [60]

Do the “non-challenge” clauses in the DOCA contravene Part 15A?..................[84]

Does the “no set off” clause contravene Part 15A?..............................................[89]

Cargill’s s 239ADD challenges – Is a provision in the DOCA oppressive,

unfairly prejudicial to, or unfairly discriminatory against Cargill? .................. [92]

Section 239ADD – The legal principles……………………………………….....[92]

Has Cargill been prejudiced due to a lack of independence on the part

of the deed administrators?....................................................................................[99]

Was Cargill unfairly classified as a Participant Creditor rather than as

a Trade Creditor?.................................................................................................[110]

Does the DOCA treat the Lenders preferentially, in a way that unfairly

prejudices Cargill?...............................................................................................[122]

Has Cargill been unfairly prejudiced by the limitation of liability clauses

in the DOCA?.......................................................................................................[127]

Cargill’s solvent liquidation complaint………………………………………… [133] Summary and conclusion ...................................................................................... [137] Result ...................................................................................................................... [140]

Introduction

[1]      Solid Energy New Zealand Limited (“SENZ”) is the largest coal mining company in New Zealand.   It was formed in 1987 as a state owned enterprise.  The second respondent, Spring Creek Mining Company, is a subsidiary of SENZ.  I will refer to SENZ and Spring Creek Mining Company, collectively, as “Solid Energy”.

[2]      On  13 August  2015  the  Solid  Energy  Group  was  placed  into…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cargill International SA v Solid Energy New Zealand Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 1817
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cargill International SA challenged the validity of a deed of company arrangement (DOCA) entered into by Solid Energy New Zealand Limited, its subsidiaries, and various creditors. Cargill, a participant creditor, argued that the DOCA contravened Part 15A of the Companies Act 1993, which governs corporate rescue and reconstruction. Specifically, Cargill contended that the DOCA was invalid due to the role and composition of the Participants Committee, restrictions on creditors’ ability to vary the DOCA, clauses limiting liability for directors and administrators, and provisions prohibiting creditors from challenging certain clauses. Cargill also claimed that the DOCA was oppressive, unfairly prejudicial, or unfairly discriminatory under s 239ADD of the Act. The court considered Cargill's arguments in detail, examining whether the DOCA complied with Part 15A and whether it unfairly prejudiced Cargill. The court concluded that the DOCA did not contravene Part 15A and that Cargill had not been unfairly prejudiced. The court rejected Cargill's claims regarding the Participants Committee, the limitation of liability clauses, and the "no challenge" clauses. The court also found that Cargill's classification as a participant creditor and the preferential treatment of lenders under the DOCA did not unfairly prejudice Cargill. The court dismissed Cargill's application, noting that if costs could not be agreed between the parties, leave was reserved to file memoranda not exceeding 10 pages in length.