IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND ROTORUA REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA
TE ROTORUA-NUI-A-KAHUMATAMOMOE ROHE
CRI-2021-463-000055
CRI-2021-463-000058 [2022] NZHC 862
BETWEEN DANNY JOHN CANCIAN
First Appellant
THE ENGINEER LIMITED
Second AppellantBRUCE JOHN CAMERON
Third AppellantAND
TAURANGA CITY COUNCIL
Defendant
Hearing: On the papers Appearances:
W T Nabney for First Appellant
R J M Marchant / N A Speir for Respondent
Judgment:
29 April 2022
JUDGMENT OF LANG
[on appeal against sentence]
This judgment was delivered by me on 29 April 2022 at 3 pm.
Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date……………
Counsel/Solicitors:
W T Nabney, Tauranga G Allan, Wellington
M Beech, Tauranga
R Marchant, Auckland
N Speir, Rice Speir, Auckland
CANCIAN v TAURANGA CITY COUNCIL [2022] NZHC 862 [29 April 2022]
[1] In a judgment delivered on 28 March 2022 I dismissed Mr Cancian’s appeal against conviction on two charges laid under s 40 of the Building Act 2004 (the Act).1 These alleged that Mr Cancian had carried out building work otherwise than in accordance with building consents. The building consents in question had been issued in relation to dwellings to be constructed on two properties in a subdivision undertaken by Mr Cancian and his company, Bella Vista Homes Ltd. The charges on which I dismissed Mr Cancian’s appeal related to dwellings being constructed at 297 Lakes Boulevard and 5 Aneta Way.
[2] This judgment determines Mr Cancian’s appeal against sentence on those charges.
The charges
297 Lakes Boulevard
[3] The trial Judge had found Mr Cancian guilty on the charge relating to 297 Lakes Boulevard on two separate bases. Each had been pleaded as a particular allegedly giving rise to liability under s 40. First, the trial Judge held that Mr Cancian was the project manager responsible for supervising all building work carried out at this site. I found the Judge was entitled to find Mr Cancian guilty under this particular.2
[4] The Judge also determined that Mr Cancian was guilty because he had lodged a record of work with the Tauranga City Council. This confirmed he had supervised restricted building work carried out in relation to the foundations of the site in his capacity as a licensed building practitioner (LBP). I concluded that the filing of a record of work did not constitute building work for the purposes of a charge laid under s 40.3 I therefore determined that this particular could not lead to a finding of guilt.
1 Cancian v Tauranga City Council [2022] NZHC 556.
2 At [25].
3 At [34].
5 Aneta Way
[5] The Judge found Mr Cancian guilty on all the particulars relied upon by the Council in relation to 5 Aneta Way. These alleged breaches of the building consent in relation to the construction and alignment of boxed corners and failure to coat sawn timber with primer where it was exposed to the elements. The particulars also included the use of an incorrect type of nail on boxed corners.
[6] I dismissed the appeal against conviction in relation to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Cancian v Tauranga City Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] NZHC 862
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court agreed with the trial Judge that the decision in Wilson v Fowler remains the leading authority for offences under s 40 of the Act. The court identified several relevant factors for fixing the appropriate sentence for offending of this type. These include the degree of culpability including the duration and nature of the offending, the degree of harm or potential harm the offending has caused to personal safety and property, the defendant’s attitude toward the offending, the need for deterrence and the scale, permanency and purpose of the building work in question. The defendant’s financial circumstances will also be relevant.
In relation to the charge relating to 297 Lakes Boulevard, the court found that the breach of the building consent was inherently serious because the dimensions of the footings posed a threat to the integrity of the wall. However, Mr Cancian was not responsible for installing the footings. The court found that the fine imposed by the Judge was not outside the available range given the basis on which the Judge was sentencing Mr Cancian. However, the court considered the fine should be reduced to reflect the fact that Mr Cancian had been acquitted of offending involving a second particular. Any reduction must necessarily be modest because of the nature and potential consequences of the breach on which he was convicted. The court therefore reduced the fine imposed on this charge by 20 per cent.
In relation to the charge relating to 5 Aneta Way, the court found that the number, nature and scope of the identified defects did not mean that a fine equating to ten per cent of the available maximum could be said to be manifestly excessive.
The appeal against sentence on the charge relating to 297 Lakes Boulevard was allowed. The fine of $20,000 imposed on that charge was quashed and replaced by a fine of $16,000. The appeal against sentence on the charge relating to 5 Aneta Way was dismissed.