Camelot Hotel Ltd v Square Holdings Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2013-409-001352 [2016] NZHC 82

BETWEEN

CAMELOT HOTEL LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

SQUARE HOLDINGS LIMITED First Defendant

AND

THE MINISTER FOR CANTERBURY EARTHQUAKE RECOVERY

Second Defendant

Hearing: 28 January 2016

Appearances:

S J Caradus for First Defendant (Applicant) L M Taylor for Plaintiff (Respondent)

S E Rowe for Second Defendant excused

Judgment:

4 February 2016

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE OSBORNE UPON SECURITY FOR COSTS

Introduction

[1]      This  judgment  is  upon  a  defendant’s  application  for  security  for  costs

pursuant to r 5.45 High Court Rules.

[2]      In  particular,  the  first  defendant  applies  for  an  order  for  security  to  be provided by the plaintiff.

[3]      The  plaintiff  accepts  that  the  threshold  for  the  granting  of  an  order  for security for costs (under r 5.45(1)(b)) has been established.

CAMELOT HOTEL LIMITED v SQUARE HOLDINGS LIMITED [2016] NZHC 82 [4 February 2016]

The issues

[4]      The Court is required to give judgment having regard to its conclusions on two issues, namely:

(a)       what would represent an appropriate amount of security; and

(b)      what form of security would be satisfactory.

The litigation background and context

[5]      The plaintiff sues the first defendant for breaches of a 2007 lease by which the first defendant leased to the plaintiff a Cathedral Square building.  The plaintiff operated a hotel and restaurant business from the property.   The property was damaged during the Canterbury earthquake sequence and has not been occupied since February 2011.   In November 2014, the Crown exercised its powers of compulsory acquisition of the property under the Canterbury Earthquake Recovery Act 2011.

[6]      In summary, the plaintiff’s claims against the first defendant rely on the

following propositions:

(a)       as at the date of the Crown’s  acquisition,  the lease had  not been terminated;

(b)if the first defendant had acted with all reasonable speed, the building could have been repaired before the date of acquisition;

(c)       the first defendant failed to undertake repairs which it was required, by the lease, to effect;

(d)the  plaintiff  was  unable  to  re-enter  its  building  and  conduct  its business, thereby suffering damage; and

(e)       (alternatively), there was a failure by the first defendant to maintain a full   replacement   and   reinstatement   insurance   for   the   building,

constituting a breach of the lease, as a result of which the plaintiff has suffered damage.

[7]      The plaintiff has not adduced evidence to contradict that provided by the first defendant in order to establish the threshold test for security for costs.  That evidence includes the following:

(a)       the plaintiff has not traded since February 2011;

(b)      the plaintiff does not appear to own any land or chattels;

(c)       the plaintiff disposed of its chattels and furniture in May 2012;

(d)the  plaintiff  has,  at  least  in  part,  relied  on  funding  from  its shareholder; and

(e)      the  solicitors  who  previously  acted  for  the  plaintiff  commenced winding up proceedings against the plaintiff in March 2015 (subsequently settled).

[8]      In these circumstances, the plaintiff accepted that some measure of security for costs should be offered.

Informal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Camelot Hotel Ltd v Square Holdings Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 82
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Camelot Hotel Limited sued Square Holdings Limited for breaches of a 2007 lease by which Square leased to Camelot a Cathedral Square building. Camelot operated a hotel and restaurant business from the property. The property was damaged during the Canterbury earthquake sequence and has not been occupied since February 2011. In November 2014, the Crown exercised its powers of compulsory acquisition of the property under the Canterbury Earthquake Recovery Act 2011. Camelot sued Square for failing to undertake repairs to the building, which Camelot claimed it was required to effect by the lease, and for a failure to maintain a full replacement and reinstatement insurance for the building. Square applied for an order for security to be provided by Camelot. The court was required to decide what would represent an appropriate amount of security and what form of security would be satisfactory. The court found that Square had pursued security promptly once it became aware of specific circumstances indicating that Camelot might be insolvent. There was no needless delay and certainly none designed or having the effect of prejudicing Camelot. In relation to sums of such significance it was unsatisfactory for the Court to be left with no estimate of fees made by the experts themselves. A range of $50,000 to $100,000 appeared realistic. However, for the purposes of security for costs assessment, and in the absence of actual evidence of fees estimated by the experts themselves, the court would adopt a base figure of $50,000. The court found that the form of security which it considered would be satisfactory was a payment into a solicitor's trust account as requested by Square. The court found it was just to order that Camelot provide by way of security a sum of $120,000 representing approximately 75 per cent of the incurred and anticipated costs and disbursements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.