Camelot Court Motel Ltd v Anderson

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND HAMILTON REGISTRY

CIV-2011-419-21 [2012] NZHC 153

BETWEEN  CAMELOT COURT MOTEL LIMITED Plaintiff

ANDWARREN BRUCE ANDERSON AND MARGARET ELLEN ANDERSON Defendants

Hearing:         8 February 2012

Appearances: E J Hudson for Plaintiff

P D Allan for Defendants

Judgment:      15 February 2012 at 4:00 PM

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE R M BELL

This judgment was delivered by me on

15 February 2012 at 4:00pm

pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

……………………………………………..

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

Niemand Peebles Hoult (K L Hoult), P O Box 1028 Hamilton 3240, for Plaintiff

Email:   admin@nplaw.co.nz

Kellaways, P O Box 19 379 Hamilton 3244, for Defendants

Email:   peter@kellaways.co.nz

Copy for:

E J Hudson, P O Box 19252, Hamilton 3244

Email:   elliotthudson@xtra.co.nz

Peter D Allan, 26 Thackeray Street, Hamilton 3204

Email:   Thackeray@clear.net.nz

CAMELOT COURT MOTEL LIMITED V WARREN BRUCE ANDERSON AND MARGARET ELLEN ANDERSON HC HAM CIV-2011-419-21 15 February 2012

Introduction

[1]      Mr and Mrs Anderson are the lessees of the Camelot Court Motel in Ulster Street, Hamilton.  The plaintiff is their landlord.  Part of the motel premises are, in turn, leased from Tainui Corporation Ltd under a perpetually renewable lease (the head lease).  Under the motel lease, the Andersons not only pay rent to the plaintiff, but they also separately pay the plaintiff the ground rent under the head lease.   Until May 2007, the ground rent was $14,060 plus GST per annum.    That had been the ground rent since 31 May 1986.  In December 2006 the rent under the motel lease came up for review.  On 28 February 2007, the plaintiff gave Mr and Mrs Anderson notice under the lease that the new rent for the motel would be set at $364,580.36 per annum  excluding  GST.    That  was  an  increase  over  the  current  annual  rent  of

$285,000 excluding GST. The motel lease rent review provisions allowed the defendants  to  give notice objecting to  the proposed  new rent,  but  Mr and  Mrs Anderson did not do so. The head lease fell for renewal in May 2007. A new ground rental was negotiated with Tainui Corporation Ltd.   The new ground rental was

$108,000 plus GST per annum, payable from 1 June 2007.   The Andersons acknowledge that the new ground rent of $108,000 plus GST per annum is a reasonable ground rental.  However, since 1 June 2007 they have continued to pay the  plaintiff  for  ground  rent  at  the  old  rate  of  $14,060  plus  GST  per  annum (a monthly rate  of $1318.12  including  GST).   Their  objection  is  that  when  the amounts they pay for ground rent are taken into account, along with the increased motel rent of $364,580.36 excluding GST and other charges, the total they pay for the premises is more than a fair market rental.  The matter for decision is whether their objection gives them grounds in law not to pay the new ground rent.

[2]      The plaintiff has sued them for the shortfall in the ground rent payments.  It also claims interest, damages and its legal costs in negotiating…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Camelot Court Motel Ltd v Anderson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 153
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Camelot Court Motel Limited (the plaintiff) is the landlord of the defendants, Mr and Mrs Anderson (the defendants). The plaintiff claims that the defendants have failed to pay the full amount of ground rent due under a head lease that the defendants sublease from Tainui Corporation Ltd. The plaintiff seeks payment of the shortfall in the ground rent since 1 June 2007, interest, damages and legal costs. The defendants have raised a number of defences, including that the motel lease expired on 30 May 2007 and has not been renewed, that the rent review in December 2006 failed to take into account the likely increase in ground rent, and that they are entitled to relief under the Contractual Mistakes Act or for unconscionable dealing. The court found that the motel lease was automatically extended after 30 May 2007, so the defendants were not holding over after the expiry of the lease. The court also found that the defendants’ argument that the ground rent should have been taken into account in fixing the new rent in December 2006 was not a defence in law, but a matter of fact. The court rejected the defendants’ claim under the Contractual Mistakes Act because there was no agreement fixing the new rent at the time of the rent review. The court also rejected the claim for unconscionable dealing because there was no evidence that the defendants were under any significant disability or disadvantage. The court found in favour of the plaintiff and ordered the defendants to pay the shortfall in the ground rent since 1 June 2007, as well as costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established