Cable Price (NZ) Ltd v Taimona Haulage Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WHANGAREI REGISTRY

CIV-2015-488-131 [2016] NZHC 828

UNDER the Companies Act 1993, Section 241

IN THE MATTER OF

an application for the liquidation of
TAIMONA HAULAGE LIMITED

BETWEEN

CABLE PRICE (NZ) LIMITED Plaintiff

AND

TAIMONA HAULAGE LIMITED Defendant

Hearing: 28 April 2016

Appearances:

H King and A Easterbrook for Plaintiff
A Holgate for Defendant

Judgment:

28 April 2016

ORAL JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE R M BELL

Solicitors:

S B Law (Amy Hutton), Christchurch, for Plaintiff
Webb Ross McNab Kilpatrick (A Easterbrook/H King), Whangarei, for Plaintiff (on instructions)

The Conveyancing Shop Lawyers Ltd, Epsom, Auckland, for Defendant

Counsel:

Andrew Holgate, Barrister, Whangarei, for Defendant

CABLE PRICE (NZ) LIMITED v TAIMONA HAULAGE LIMITED [2016] NZHC 828 [28 April 2016]

[1]      Cable Price (NZ) Ltd applies under s 241 of the Companies Act 1993 for an order that Taimona Haulage Ltd be put into liquidation.  Cable Price says that it is a creditor of Taimona for $14,607.68 being the balance owed for repairs carried out and parts supplied in March 2015.   Cable Price served a statutory demand on the registered office of Taimona on 27 August 2015.  Taimona did not comply with the notice within 15 working days of service.   Cable Price began this proceeding in September 2015.   It relies on the presumption of insolvency under s 287(a) of the Companies Act.

[2]      In a creditor’s application for liquidation relying on inability to pay debts, there are three main questions:

(a)      Is the plaintiff a creditor?

(b)      Is the defendant insolvent?  and

(c)      How should the court’s residual discretion be exercised?

[3]      In this case, Taimona defends by contesting the standing of Cable Price as a creditor.  It contends that the debt on which Cable Price relies is subject to a genuine and substantial dispute.   That is a recognised  ground for resisting a liquidation application.   The Court of Appeal repeated this in Yan v Mainzeal Property and Construction Ltd :1

[61]      It has long been established that, as a general rule, an order to put a company into liquidation will not be made where the application is founded upon a debt that is genuinely disputed.  To apply to wind up a company in such circumstances is regarded as an abuse of the court’s process:  Bateman Television Ltd (in liq) v Coleridge Finance Co Ltd.  In such cases, the court has an inherent jurisdiction to prevent such an abuse of process.   But the court also has power to consider disputed debts in the context of an opposed application for liquidation or upon applications for orders restraining advertising and staying proceedings.  The relevant principles were recently

1      Yan v Mainzeal Property and Construction Ltd (in receivership and in liquidation) [2014] NZCA

190 at [61] (footnotes omitted).

summarised  by  Associate  Judge  Faire  (now  Faire  J)  in  South  Waikato

Precision Engineering Ltd v Ahu Developments Ltd in these terms:

(a)       A winding up order will not be made where there is a genuine and substantial dispute as to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cable Price (NZ) Ltd v Taimona Haulage Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 828
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cable Price (NZ) Ltd applied to the High Court of New Zealand under section 241 of the Companies Act 1993 for an order to liquidate Taimona Haulage Ltd. Cable Price claimed that Taimona owed it $14,607.68 for truck repairs and parts supplied in March 2015. Taimona argued that the debt was subject to a genuine dispute, which would bar Cable Price from pursuing the liquidation application. The court had to decide whether Taimona had raised a genuine dispute sufficient to prevent Cable Price from proceeding with the liquidation application.

The court found that Taimona had indeed raised a genuine dispute over the debt. Taimona alleged that Cable Price breached its repair agreement by failing to properly identify and fix problems with the truck engine. The court found that Taimona's evidence presented an arguable basis for disputing the debt. Although Cable Price attempted to counter with its own evidence, the court found that evidence to be inadmissible hearsay. As a result, the court could not determine the merits of the dispute and concluded that the dispute was genuine and substantial. The court held that it would be inappropriate to resolve the dispute in the liquidation application and that the matter was better dealt with in a civil court.

Accordingly, the court dismissed Cable Price's liquidation application. The court also awarded Taimona $9,430 in costs, finding that Cable Price could not complain about the costs having elected to proceed with the application despite being aware of Taimona's defence.