Cable Bay Wine Limited v Auckland Council

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CRI 2024-404-000742

[2025] NZHC 1576

UNDER the Resource Management Act 1991 (RMA)

IN THE MATTER OF

a prosecution under s 338 of the RMA

BETWEEN

CABLE BAY WINE LIMITED

Appellant

AND

AUCKLAND COUNCIL

Respondent

Hearing: 19 May 2025

Appearances:

K de Silva for the Appellant S F Quinn for the Respondent

Judgment:

13 June 2025


JUDGMENT OF TAHANA J

[Appeal against sentence]


This judgment was delivered by me on 13 June 2025 4.00 pm

…………………………

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors/Counsel:

K de Silva, Barrister, Auckland DLA Piper, Auckland

CABLE BAY WINE LIMITED v AUCKLAND COUNCIL [2025] NZHC 1576 [13 June 2025]

Introduction

[1]    Cable Bay Wine Ltd (Cable Bay) appeals its sentence (a $50,000 fine and costs) for exceeding the maximum noise limits specified in its resource consent in contravention of a district rule.1 The Auckland Council (the Council) opposes the appeal.

[2]    Cable Bay is a winery on Waiheke Island with a restaurant and function centre. In the afternoon of 23 June 2018, a group of ten patrons were socialising outside. Noise measurements were taken from a nearby property that exceeded the maximum noise limits.

[3]    Cable Bay was charged with contravening s 9(3) of the Resource Management Act 1991 (the RMA)2 by using the property in a manner that contravenes a district rule. Cable Bay was found guilty3 and subsequently sentenced.4

[4]    Cable Bay argues that the sentencing Judge erred in: applying cases involving the discharge of odour and not taking into account cases involving noise emissions; placing too much weight on previous unverified complaints; and failing to reduce the sentence because of correspondence from the Council.

[5]    The Council argues that the fine was not manifestly excessive, and the Judge did not err in relying on odour cases in the absence of comparable noise emission cases. The Council argues that previous noise complaints in relation to Cable Bay are relevant to the seriousness of its offending and there is no basis to reduce the sentence because of the Council’s correspondence.

[6]    The key issue is therefore whether the Judge erred in relying on odour cases such that the end sentence is manifestly excessive.


1      Under s 9(3)(a) of the Resource Management Act no person may use land in a manner that contravenes a district rule unless the use is expressly allowed by a resource consent.

2      Resource Management Act 1991, ss 338(1) and 339(1)(b). Maximum penalty of a fine not exceeding $600,000.

3      Auckland Council v Cable Bay Wine Ltd [2024] NZDC 21713 [Conviction decision].

4      Auckland Council v Cable Bay Wine Ltd [2024] NZDC 28930 [Sentencing decision].

Background

[7]    Since 2006, Cable Bay has held a resource consent allowing it to operate a restaurant and function centre at its vineyard, subject to conditions. Relevantly, condition 25 specified noise limits as follows:

At all times any activity on the site shall comply with the following noise levels:

The noise level arising…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cable Bay Wine Limited v Auckland Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NZHC 1576
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cable Bay Wine Limited (Cable Bay) appealed the sentence of a $50,000 fine and costs imposed by the District Court for exceeding the maximum noise limits specified in its resource consent. The Auckland Council (the Council) opposed the appeal. Cable Bay argued that the sentencing Judge erred in applying cases involving odour emissions rather than noise emissions, placing too much weight on previous unverified complaints, and failing to reduce the sentence because of correspondence from the Council. The Council argued that the fine was not manifestly excessive, and the Judge did not err in relying on odour cases in the absence of comparable noise emission cases. The Council argued that previous noise complaints in relation to Cable Bay were relevant to the seriousness of its offending and there was no basis to reduce the sentence because of the Council’s correspondence.

The key issue was whether the Judge erred in relying on odour cases such that the end sentence is manifestly excessive. This Court found that while it was open to the Judge to consider the treatment of previous complaints in the odour cases, in doing so it was necessary to consider the weight to be given to that knowledge. The history of complaints in relation to Cable Bay was combined with excessive noise directions and an application for an enforcement order. The Council had provided correspondence indicating that it would continue to measure noise at the boundary of the site until the Environment Court had determined the issue of whether 85 Church Bay Road was part of the site. Cable Bay knew there was a risk of exceeding noise limits if outdoor activities were allowed but nevertheless allowed those activities to occur. That indicates a degree of recklessness. However, by applying the odour cases without regard to the noise cases (and in particular Chronophonium Ltd) the Judge gave too much weight to the history of complaints and arrived at a starting point that was manifestly excessive. The offending was less serious than in Te Mata Mushroom and Bartosh and slightly more serious than in Chronophonium Ltd because the environmental damage was less than those cases and the number of incidents and duration was also less. Cable Bay’s culpability was greater than in Chronophonium Ltd because of the extent of the history of noise complaints which indicates a greater degree of knowledge of the risks and a longer period over which Cable Bay could have put in place processes to mitigate the risk of offending. An appropriate starting point is a fine of $30,000.

The appeal was allowed. The sentence of a fine of $50,000 was substituted for a fine of $30,000. The sentence in relation to costs otherwise stands. The parties are encouraged to agree costs of the appeal.