C v Police HC Napier CRI 2010-441-29

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

This case has been anonymized

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CRI 2010-441-29

BETWEEN  C

Appellant

ANDNEW ZEALAND POLICE Respondent

Hearing:         18 August 2010

Counsel:         A Malik for Appellant

F E Cleary for Respondent

Judgment:      18 August 2010

ORAL JUDGMENT OF MILLER J

[1]      Mr C   appeals against refusal of bail.  He is charged with burglary, to which he has pleaded guilty meaning that s 13 of the Bail Act applies.

[2]      The charge relates  to  a  residential  burglary in  which  was  stolen  a large television, an iPod and jewellery and makeup.  These items were said to be worth about $15,000.

[3]      He  has  five  previous  convictions;    none  involve  dishonesty.    The  only relevant conviction is one for failure to answer police bail in 2001.

[4]      His contention before the District Court, as here, was that a non-custodial sentence is possible.  The Judge acknowledged that, but observed that the relevant consideration under the Bail Act is whether it is “unlikely” that a custodial sentence

will be imposed.  A first offender in a case of burglary may well be imprisoned.  He

C V NEW ZEALAND POLICE HC NAP CRI 2010-441-29  18 August 2010

suggested that the offence was premeditated and involved theft to order, with professional overtones and the loss was substantial.

[5]      On appeal, counsel first contends that a different Judge had previously dealt with the question of bail pending sentence.  The appellant was given bail when he pleaded guilty on 28 July, but lost it on 11 August when the conviction was entered. The Judge had no jurisdiction to revisit the previous grant of bail.  He erroneously concluded that it was only on the entry of the conviction that s 13 applied.

[6]      Counsel cited no authority for this jurisdictional proposition.  In my opinion it is untenable.  It is true that s 13 applies when the guilty plea is entered, but nothing in the record suggests that s 13 was considered when bail was first granted on 28

July.  Further, nothing in the Bail Act precludes the Court from revisiting the grant or refusal of bail at any time before sentence is passed.  Circumstances may change; in this case, for example, he pleaded on 28 July and a sentencing date was not fixed. He was refused bail when the date was fixed on 11 August.

[7]      Turning  to  the  merits,  counsel  submitted  that  the  Judge  was  wrong  to conclude that a starting point of imprisonment was likely.   The Judge failed to consider not only whether imprisonment was a real possibility but also how likely it is that imprisonment will be imposed.[1]     For a first time burglar imprisonment is possible but frequently it is not imposed, especially where as in this case none of the aggravating features outlined in Senior was present.[2]     Accordingly, a term of imprisonment was not a substantial possibility in this case, particularly since he had pleaded guilty at an early stage and had no previous relevant convictions.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read C v Police HC Napier CRI 2010-441-29 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NZHC 1439
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of C v Police, the appellant, C, sought to appeal the refusal of bail by the District Court. The appellant, who has a history of five prior convictions, including one for failing to answer police bail, pleaded guilty to burglary, a charge that involves the theft of valuable items from a residential property. The court was tasked with determining whether it was unlikely that a custodial sentence would be imposed on the appellant, a matter governed by section 13 of the Bail Act. The District Court had concluded that a custodial sentence was likely due to the premeditated nature of the crime and the substantial value of the stolen items.

The legal issues before the High Court were twofold: whether the District Court had jurisdiction to revisit the bail decision after the appellant pleaded guilty, and whether the District Court was correct in finding that it was likely the appellant would be sentenced to imprisonment. The appellant argued that a different judge had previously granted bail and that the District Court could not reconsider this decision. However, the court found that the Bail Act does not preclude the reconsideration of bail decisions and that the appellant's jurisdictional argument was without merit. On the merits, the court considered the nature of the offence, the appellant's plea of guilty, and his lack of prior convictions involving dishonesty. The court also noted the appellant's stable personal circumstances, including his family ties and employment prospects.

The High Court concluded that, considering the appellant's guilty plea, absence of relevant prior convictions, and stable personal circumstances, it was unlikely that he would be sentenced to imprisonment. The court found that home detention was the more likely sentence and that there were no other reasons to deny bail pending sentencing. Accordingly, the appeal was allowed, and the appellant was granted bail pending sentencing on the 14th of September 2010, with specific bail conditions including residence at a specified address, a curfew, prohibition from associating with the co-accused, and restriction from visiting a particular location.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established