C & S Kelly Properties Limited v Earthquake Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2013-409-1273 [2014] NZHC 3111

BETWEEN

C & S KELLY PROPERTIES LIMITED

Plaintiffs

AND

THE EARTHQUAKE COMMISSION First Defendant

SOUTHERN RESPONSE EARTHQUAKE SERVICES LIMITED Second Defendant

HearingDates:

3 December 2014

(By way of telephone conference)

Appearances:

G Shand and A Ferguson for Plaintiff
B Scott and N Bruce-Smith for First Defendant
R Johnstone and A Shaw for Second Defendant

Judgment:

5 December 2014

JUDGMENT OF MANDER J

[1]      The plaintiff, C & S Kelly Properties Limited makes application for leave to serve a reply witness statement in the name of James Michael Bundy.  It also seeks tailored discovery of documents relating to a number of witnesses to be called by the two defendants. These applications are opposed by the defendants.

[2]      This proceeding, which involves a disputed claim in respect of an earthquake damaged house owned by the plaintiff, is part heard.   The first five days of trial, commencing 29 September, were occupied with the parties’ openings, a site visit and the hearing of some of the plaintiff’s witnesses.  The trial is set to recommence on 8

December 2014  for  a  further seven  days.   The plaintiff  is  yet  to  complete the

presentation of its case.

C & S KELLY PROPERTIES LIMITED v EARTHQUAKE COMMISSION AND ANOR [2014] NZHC 3111 [5

December 2014]

[3]      The close of pleadings date of 25 July 2014 has obviously well passed, and the plaintiff requires leave to make these applications.1   In order to obtain leave it is necessary to “surmount the formidable hurdles” of showing that to do so would be in the interests of justice and will not significantly prejudice other parties or cause significant delay.2

Reply witness statement of James Bundy

[4]      Mr Bundy, a chartered surveyor, served a witness statement on behalf of the plaintiff in August 2014.  The proposed reply witness statement concerns an issue which, in the plaintiff ’s  submission, has been the subject of some focus in the hearing to date, namely whether weatherboards on the exterior of the house and aluminium windows are sloping.   The plaintiff submits that Mr Bundy’s reply evidence will challenge the correctness of the propositions that have been put to witnesses, asserting that the weatherboards are level.

[5]       The plaintiff submitted that leave should be granted because it is in the interests of justice that the Court hear Mr Bundy’s evidence and that the defendants will suffer no prejudice as a result of allowing this evidence to be admitted at this late stage.  In seeking the Court’s leave to serve the reply evidence of Mr Bundy, the plaintiff emphasised that the Court should have available to it the “best evidence” relating to this emerging issue.   It also noted that indulgences had already been extended to both the second defendant and itself to serve witness statements during the first week of the trial.

[6]      In  opposition,  the  first  defendant,  the  Earthquake  Commission  (EQC) submitted that the additional reply witness statement concerns matters which have already been dealt…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read C & S Kelly Properties Limited v Earthquake Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 3111
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, C & S Kelly Properties Limited, made an application for leave to serve a reply witness statement in the name of James Michael Bundy and for tailored discovery of documents relating to witnesses to be called by the defendants. The application was opposed by the defendants, the Earthquake Commission and Southern Response Earthquake Services Limited. The plaintiff required leave to make these applications as the close of pleadings date of 25 July 2014 had passed. To obtain leave, it was necessary to show that doing so would be in the interests of justice and would not significantly prejudice the other parties or cause significant delay. The plaintiff sought leave for Mr Bundy's reply witness statement as it was in the interests of justice that the Court hear his evidence, and the defendants would suffer no prejudice as a result of allowing this evidence to be admitted at this late stage. However, the defendants opposed the application, stating that the additional evidence concerns matters that have already been dealt with by the plaintiff's expert surveyor and there is no reason the proposed evidence could not have been provided along with the plaintiff's original reply evidence.

The plaintiff applied for tailored discovery of documents relevant to the credibility and impartiality of four witnesses to be called by the defendants. The plaintiff submitted that the documents were relevant to assessing the admissibility and weight of the witnesses' evidence and that the defendants seek to qualify the witnesses as experts. The plaintiff relied upon a recent decision of the Court, Domenico Trustee Ltd v Tower Insurance Ltd, and submitted that as a result of this decision, the documents now sought are discoverable. The defendants opposed the application for tailored discovery of the identified categories of documents, stating that there was no proper basis for the application. They submitted that the tailored discovery sought is not relevant to issues in the proceeding and that no evidential foundation has been laid for the application.

The Court granted leave for the witness statement of Mr Bundy to be served in the absence of any specific prejudice to the defendants apart from the inconvenience of having to prepare for and meet this late evidence. The admission of the evidence was subject to the defendants being given time and access to the site for the purpose of undertaking their own measurements and further examination of the house. The Court declined the application for tailored discovery, stating that no proper foundation had been laid for the application. The plaintiff had not provided a proper foundation to support the suggestion that any of the witnesses had a financial interest in the outcome of the proceeding. The Court was not satisfied that it was in the interests of justice that the application for tailored discovery be granted.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established