IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND HAMILTON REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA KIRIKIRIROA ROHE
CIV-2020-419-000087
[2021] NZHC 1222
BETWEEN C & R CONSTRUCTION LIMITED
Plaintiff
AND
TAHAROA IRONSANDS LIMITED
First Defendant
WAYNE SIDNEY COFFEY
Second DefendantTIMOTHY DOUGLAS ROSS and CHRISTOPHER SIMON ROSS
First Third PartiesMARSHALL MAINE
Second Third Party
Hearing: 13 May 2021 Appearances:
C P Browne and K P Woodward for Plaintiff R J Gordon for Defendants
Judgment:
28 May 2021
JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE P J ANDREW
This judgment was delivered by Associate Judge Andrew dated 28 May 2021 at 12 noon
pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules Registrar / Deputy Registrar
Date…………………………..
C & R CONSTRUCTION LTD v TAHAROA IRONSANDS LTD & ORS [2021] NZHC 1222 [28 May 2021]
Introduction
[1] C & R Construction Ltd (C & R) owns earthmoving and other related machinery which it hires to Taharoa Ironsands Ltd (Taharoa). Taharoa uses the machinery for carrying out its iron sand mining operations south of Kawhia.
[2] In the substantive proceedings, C & R seeks rectification of a written commercial contract entitled “Variation and renewal of the agreement for the hire of goods (Mobile Mining Equipment); Dry Hire)” (the Variation) entered into in 2018. At issue is whether the Variation should be rectified to enable C & R to charge “minimum hours” to Taharoa as expressly provided for in the original agreement for the hire of goods in 2015.
[3] In an interlocutory judgment dated 21 October 2020,1 Associate Judge Smith made tailored discovery orders. They included the requirement to provide documents in “category 10”. The sealed orders of 21 October 2020 record category 10 as follows:
Category 10: Taharoa’s fourth counterclaim
–Documents in a party’s control relating to the “back-up arrangements for the hire of earthmoving equipment” and “holding costs” pleaded in paragraphs 86 – 88 of the ASoDCC, including correspondence regarding the arrangements, relevant board minutes and resolutions, order forms, delivery, receipts and payments.
[4] In its third amended statement of defence and counterclaim dated 14 December 2020, Taharoa abandoned its fourth counterclaim. It did not provide discovery in accordance with category 10.
[5] In the present proceeding, there are two interrelated interlocutory applications that require determination:
(a)Application by Taharoa for an order under r 8.17 of the High Court Rules 2016 varying the tailored discovery order of Associate Judge Smith so as to remove category 10;
1 C & R Construction Ltd v Taharoa Ironsands Ltd & Ors [2020] NZHC 2765.
(b)Application by C & R for discovery and inspection orders (rr 8.10 and 8.18) requiring Taharoa to provide discovery of documents falling within category 10.
[6] The critical issue for determination is whether, despite the abandonment of Taharoa’s fourth counterclaim, documents in category 10 remain relevant to the claim for rectification and, if so, does an issue of proportionality arise?
Factual background
[7] The factual background is comprehensively set out by Associate Judge Smith in his judgment of 21 October…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read C & R Construction Limited v Taharoa Ironsands Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] NZHC 1222
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues in this case revolve around the relevance of documents specified in category 10 of the tailored discovery order and whether an issue of proportionality arises despite Taharoa's abandonment of its fourth counterclaim. The court must decide if the documents in category 10, which relate to Taharoa's back-up arrangements for the hire of earthmoving equipment and holding costs, remain relevant to the rectification claim. Additionally, the court must assess if there is a disproportionate burden in requiring Taharoa to provide these documents, given the abandonment of the counterclaim.
The court found that documents in category 10, now reframed to pertain to Taharoa's arrangements for alternative equipment, are indeed relevant to C & R's rectification claim. The court held that post-contract conduct, including Taharoa's consideration of alternative earthmoving equipment, could provide insight into the parties' mutual intention at the time of the contract. This is crucial to C & R's argument that Taharoa did not intend to remove the minimum hours provisions. The court also concluded that the proportionality concerns raised by Taharoa could be mitigated by limiting the scope of the required documents to correspondence, relevant board minutes, and resolutions. As a result, the court varied the tailored discovery order to require Taharoa to provide the amended category 10 documents within 15 working days.
The final orders include the removal of category 10 from the original tailored discovery order and its replacement with a new category focusing on Taharoa's arrangements for alternative equipment. C & R's application for discovery and inspection orders under rules 8.10 and 8.18 is dismissed as the issue is addressed by the variation order. Additionally, the court ruled that no order as to costs should be made, as both parties achieved partial success in the proceedings.