Butler v North Shore Police

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA657/2015
[2016] NZCA 150

BETWEEN

JESSE WAIARIKI TAMANAVA BUTLER
Applicant

AND

NORTH SHORE POLICE
Respondent

Hearing:

18 April 2016

Court:

Harrison, Wild and Kós JJ

Counsel:

Applicant in Person
K Laurenson for Respondent

Judgment:

22 April 2016 at 10 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The application for an extension of time to appeal is declined.

B        There is no order as to costs.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Harrison J)

  1. The applicant, Jesse Butler, applies for leave to appeal out of time[1] against the High Court’s dismissal of his claim against the police for torture and misfeasance in a public office.[2] 

Background

[1]Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005, r 29A.

  1. Mr Butler originally brought his proceeding against Massey University Albany and the North Shore Police.  He does not appeal against the High Court’s dismissal of his claim against the University because the proceeding was never served.

  2. Mr Butler’s claim against the police was based on events which occurred on 17 February 2014.  Callum Blair, a security officer employed by Massey University, attempted to serve a trespass notice on Mr Butler.  An altercation followed.  When two police officers arrived Mr Blair was holding Mr Butler who was shouting abuse at Mr Blair. 

  3. The police officers arrested Mr Butler on a charge of assault.  With the benefit of hearing evidence from the relevant witnesses, Asher J found that when the police arrived Mr Butler was very angry and abusive.[3]  The arresting sergeant described Mr Butler’s continuous abuse as the worst he had experienced in 10 years of police service.  While the officers advised Mr Butler of their reason for his arrest, Mr Butler’s abuse was such that the officer was unable to advise him of his rights.  In due course Mr Butler was formally charged with assault, released on bail and later appeared in court.  He was convicted of assault after a trial in the District Court. 

    [3]At [10].

  4. Asher J found that the police did not exercise any unreasonable force against Mr Butler; and that the officers processed and released him as soon as possible.[4]  Also, the Judge found, the officers treated Mr Butler with humanity and respect.  There could be no suggestion that their actions mounted to torture or cruel treatment.  He also dismissed Mr Butler’s claim of misfeasance in a public office on its merits.  He found that, even though a police officer might generously be called a public officer, there was no evidence to support any of the other three elements of the tort.[5] 

Decision

[4]At [18].

[5]At [23]–[24].

  1. The principles governing determination of an application for leave to appeal out of time are well settled.[6]  The interests of justice are the overriding consideration.  Within that inquiry, relevant factors include the length of the delay and its reasons; the parties’ conduct; the extent of any prejudice caused by the delay; the respective merits of the appeal; and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Butler v North Shore Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZCA 150
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Jesse Butler sought leave to appeal out of time against the High Court's dismissal of his claim against the North Shore Police for torture and misfeasance in a public office. The case was originally brought against Massey University Albany and the North Shore Police, but the University was dismissed due to non-service of the proceedings. Butler's claim against the Police was based on events that occurred on 17 February 2014 when he was arrested for assault following an altercation with a security officer. The Court of Appeal had to decide whether the application for an extension of time to appeal should be granted, considering factors such as the length of the delay, the reasons for the delay, the parties' conduct, the extent of any prejudice caused by the delay, the respective merits of the appeal, and whether any issues of public importance arise.

The Court of Appeal found that the delay was caused by an honest mistake about the correct court, and no material prejudice resulted. The decisive factor was the merits of the appeal. The Court considered the proposed grounds of Butler's appeal, which included claims that the Judge did not take into account Butler's brief of evidence, the Judge's conclusions were unsupported by the evidence, and the Judge treated the police generously. However, the Court found that none of these grounds were arguable. The Court's own evaluation of the evidence against the relevant legal principles confirmed the High Court's assessment that Butler's claim failed "by a very wide margin."

The Court of Appeal declined the application for an extension of time to appeal and made no order as to costs. The Court found that there was no arguable basis for a contrary view, and the proposed grounds of appeal were not sufficient to grant leave to appeal out of time.

Background

Background to the litigation

Jesse Butler, the applicant, sought leave to appeal out of time against the High Court's dismissal of his claim against the North Shore Police for torture and misfeasance in a public office. The events leading to the claim occurred on 17 February 2014 when a security officer, Callum Blair, employed by Massey University attempted to serve a trespass notice on Mr Butler. An altercation ensued, leading to Mr Butler being arrested by police on a charge of assault after he was observed shouting abuse at Mr Blair. Mr Butler was subsequently released on bail and appeared in court where he was convicted of assault. The High Court dismissed Mr Butler's claim against the police, finding that the police did not exercise unreasonable force, treated Mr Butler with humanity and respect, and there was no evidence to support the claim of misfeasance in a public office.

Mr Butler originally brought proceedings against Massey University Albany and the North Shore Police. However, the proceeding was never served on the University, and Mr Butler does not appeal against the High Court's dismissal of his claim against the University. The High Court dismissed Mr Butler's claim against the North Shore Police. Mr Butler then applied for leave to appeal out of time against the High Court's decision. The Court of Appeal heard the application on 18 April 2016 and delivered its judgment on 22 April 2016.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Court should grant leave to appeal out of time against the High Court's dismissal of the applicant's claim against the North Shore Police.
2. Whether the applicant's proposed grounds of appeal are arguable.

Held
1. The Court declined the applicant's application for leave to appeal out of time against the High Court's dismissal of the applicant's claim against the North Shore Police.
2. The Court found that the applicant's proposed grounds of appeal were not arguable.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered the application for leave to appeal out of time against the High Court’s dismissal of Jesse Butler’s claim against the North Shore Police. The Court first outlined the principles governing such an application, emphasizing the interests of justice as the primary consideration. It noted that relevant factors included the length of the delay, reasons for the delay, the parties' conduct, the extent of any prejudice caused by the delay, the respective merits of the appeal, and whether any issues of public importance arise. Mr Butler’s notice of appeal was filed 19 days outside the prescribed time, but the police accepted that no material prejudice resulted from the delay, and the Court accepted that the delay was caused by an honest mistake about the correct court. The decisive factor was the merits of the appeal.

The Court scrutinized Mr Butler's proposed grounds of appeal, which included allegations that the High Court Judge did not consider Mr Butler's brief of evidence, that the Judge's conclusions were unsupported by the evidence, and various other claims. The Court found that Mr Butler's grounds were not arguable because the High Court Judge, who had the advantage of seeing and hearing the witnesses, found that Mr Butler's claim failed "by a very wide margin." The Court of Appeal's own evaluation of the evidence against the relevant legal principles confirmed this assessment, and there was no arguable basis for a contrary view. Thus, the application for leave to appeal out of time was declined, and there was no order as to costs.