Burden v Debonaire Furniture Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV 2014-485-11179 [2015] NZHC 263

BETWEEN IAN JAMES BURDEN First Plaintiff

AND

PLANTATION GROWN TIMBERS (INTERNATIONAL) LIMITED Second Plaintiff

AND

PLANTATION GROWN TIMBERS (VIETNAM) LIMITED

Third Plaintiff

AND

DEBONAIRE FURNITURE LIMITED First Defendant

AND

BURDEN FURNITURE (INTERNATIONAL) LIMITED Second Defendant

AND

BURDEN FURNITURE CO LIMITED Third Defendant

AND

LINDSAY JOHN BURDEN Fourth Defendant

AND

JEREMY DAVID SMITH Fifth Defendant

AND

ROBERT WAYNE SMITH Sixth Defendant

Hearing: 20 February 2015

Counsel:

G Hazel for Plaintiffs
G F Arthur for First, Fifth and Sixth Defendants
No appearance for the Second, Third and Fourth Defendants

Judgment:

24 February 2015

JUDGMENT OF BROWN J

BURDEN v PLANTATION GROWN TIMBERS (INTL) LTD [2015] NZHC 263 [24 February 2015]

[1]      In this proceeding the plaintiffs allege that furniture imported by the first defendant  into  New Zealand  infringes  copyright  owned  by  the  plaintiffs  and constitutes a breach of the Fair Trading Act 1986.

[2]      The  statement  of  claim  alleges  that  the  first  plaintiff  is  resident  in Queensland, Australia.  The second plaintiff is a British Virgin Islands company and the third plaintiff is a Vietnamese company.

[3]      The first defendant seeks an order for security for costs against the plaintiffs in reliance on both r 5.45(1)(a) (plaintiffs resident/incorporated out of New Zealand) and r 5.45(1)(b) (that there is reason to believe that the plaintiffs will be unable to pay costs if the defendant is successful).  Reliance is also placed on r 1.6 and the Court’s inherent jurisdiction.

Applicable principles

[4]      The decision whether or not to order security is discretionary.  It is a matter for the Judge if he or she thinks fit in all the circumstances.  The discretion is not to be fettered by constructing “principles” from the facts of previous cases: A S McLachlan Ltd v MEL Network Ltd.1

[5]      The Court of Appeal there stated:

[14]      While  collections  of  authorities  such  as  that  in  the  judgment  of Master Williams in Nikau Holdings Ltd v BNZ (1992) 5 PRNZ 430, can be of assistance, they cannot substitute for a careful assessment of the circumstances of the particular case.  It is not a matter of going through a checklist of so-called principles.  That creates a risk that a factor accorded weight in a particular case will be given disproportionate weight, or even treated as a requirement for the making or refusing of an order, in quite different circumstances.

[15]      The rule itself contemplates an order for security where the plaintiff will be unable to meet an adverse award of costs.  That must be taken as contemplating also that an order for substantial security may, in effect, prevent the plaintiff from pursuing the claim.  An order having that effect should be made only after careful consideration and in a case in which the claim has little chance of success.   Access to the Courts  for a  genuine plaintiff is not lightly to be denied.

1      A S McLachlan Ltd v MEL Network Ltd (2002) 16 PRNZ 747 at [13].

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Burden v Debonaire Furniture Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 263
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Burden v Debonaire Furniture Limited, the plaintiffs, including Ian James Burden and Plantation Grown Timbers (International) Limited, alleged that furniture imported by the defendant, Debonaire Furniture Limited, infringed copyright and constituted a breach of the Fair Trading Act 1986. The first defendant sought an order for security for costs against the plaintiffs under the relevant rules of court, arguing that the plaintiffs were resident or incorporated outside of New Zealand and that there was reason to believe they would be unable to pay costs if the defendant was successful. The plaintiffs argued that the costs should be staggered and that the defendants had proposed an unrealistically high classification for the complexity of the proceeding.

The court considered the principles applicable to an order for security for costs, including the discretionary nature of the decision and the need to protect both parties. The court noted the lack of information about the assets of the second and third plaintiffs and the financial position of the first plaintiff, but recognised the enforceability of judgments in Australia compared to other jurisdictions. The court also considered the fact that the costs awarded against the plaintiffs in Irish proceedings had not been paid.

The court concluded that the first defendant's position should be protected by an order for security for costs, but that it was not necessary or appropriate that the full amount be paid at the outset. Instead, the court ordered staggered payments at different stages of the proceeding, with the first payment to be made by 9 March 2015, the second payment seven days following the next case management conference, and the third payment 30 working days prior to the commencement date of the trial. In the event that a payment was not made at the appointed time, the proceeding would be stayed and the defendants could apply for an order striking out the proceeding.

The court also amended the timetable for the proceeding, noting the significant slippage in the filing of the second amended statement of claim. The defendants argued that the timetable should be amended on the condition that the detained furniture products be released to the defendants for sale. However, the court did not consider it appropriate to impose such a condition on the making of an amended timetable, and instead allowed the amendment of the timetable in the terms requested by the plaintiffs. In the event that the timetable was not observed by the plaintiffs, the defendants could make application to the Court for an order striking out the proceeding.

The first defendant, having been successful on its application, was entitled to costs on a 2B basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established