Bupa Care Services NZ Limited v Gillibrand

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WHANGAREI REGISTRY

CIV 2011-488-557 [2013] NZHC 3067

IN THE MATTER OF       the Administration Act 1969

BETWEEN  BUPA CARE SERVICES NZ LIMITED Applicant

ANDCHRISTIAN JOHN GILLIBRAND Respondent

Hearing:                   15 November 2013 (by audio-visual link)

Counsel:                  A N Isac and R M Vokes for Bupa Care Services NZ Ltd

A P Holgate and G P Swanepoel for Mr Gillibrand

Judgment:                20 November 2013

JUDGMENT OF HEATH J

This judgment was delivered by me on 20 November 2013 at 11.00am pursuant to

Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

SwanLaw, Whangarei Gibson Sheat, Wellington Counsel:

A Holgate, Whangarei

BUPA CARE SERVICES NZ LIMITED v GILLIBRAND [2013] NZHC 3067 [20 November 2013]

The applications

[1]      On 16 August 2013, I made an order removing Mr Christian Gillibrand as executor of the estate of his late father, Mr Gordon Gillibrand (Mr Gillibrand snr). Mr Stuart Henderson, a senior lawyer in Whangarei, was appointed in his place.1

Costs were reserved.

[2]      Both Bupa and Mr Gillibrand seek costs.   Bupa’s claim is for increased or indemnity costs,2   primarily on  the  grounds  that  baseless  allegations  were  made against it that, while not relevant to its application, raised serious reputational questions to which it had to respond.  Mr Gillibrand’s claim rests on an offer that he made on 15 March 2013 to retire as executor and to be replaced by Public Trust; an offer that Bupa did not accept.

The substantive litigation

[3]      Bupa  operates  the  Kauri  Coast  Rest-Home  and  Hospital  in  Dargaville. Mr Gillibrand snr was resident in that facility from May 2003.

[4]      Mr Gillibrand snr died on 12 April 2011, in Bupa’s care.  Probate of his estate was granted in favour of his son, on 14 July 2011. At the time of Mr Gillibrand snr’s death Bupa was owed $51,759.   It is accepted that that sum has been calculated correctly, in accordance with the contractual arrangements in place.

[5]      As  I  held  in  my  substantive  judgment,  Mr  Gillibrand  was,  throughout, conflicted in his role as executor.  As a matter of law, he owed a duty to pay all “just debts” of his late father and to ascertain whether they were payable by conducting an independent  and  impartial  assessment  of  the  claim.3    It  was  difficult,  if  not impossible, for Mr Gillibrand to perform his function in that manner.  First, he had formed a clear view that his father’s death had been “caused” by Bupa’s (alleged)

inadequate care of him.  Second, it was in his personal interests to resist the claim

because the only asset of the estate was a debt that he owed, in his capacity as a

1      Bupa Care Services NZ Ltd v Gillibrand [2013] 3 NZLR 701 (HC) at para [26](a) and (b).

2      High Court Rules, r 14.6(3) and (4).

3      Bupa Care Services NZ Ltd v Gillibrand [2013] 3 NZLR 701 (HC) at paras [10]–[13] and [17]–

[22].

trustee of the Chris and Mary Gillibrand Family Trust.  If Bupa were…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bupa Care Services NZ Limited v Gillibrand and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 3067
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bupa Care Services NZ Limited sought the removal of Christian John Gillibrand as executor of the estate of his late father, Mr Gordon Gillibrand, due to a conflict of interest. The case involved a debt of approximately $47,000 that Bupa alleged was owed by the estate, which Bupa claimed could be met by calling up a debt of approximately $355,000 owed by the trustees of the Chris and Mary Gillibrand Trust to the estate. The primary legal issue was whether Mr. Gillibrand could be removed as executor due to his conflict of interest and inability to act impartially. The court found that Mr. Gillibrand's personal beliefs and financial interests made it impossible for him to act impartially, leading to the decision to remove him as executor.

The court's reasoning focused on the conflict of interest and the inability of Mr. Gillibrand to act impartially in assessing the debt claimed by Bupa. The court emphasized the necessity for an executor to pay all "just debts" of the deceased and to conduct an independent and impartial assessment of the claims. Mr. Gillibrand's personal views and financial interests made it difficult, if not impossible, for him to perform his function appropriately. The court concluded that an independent and impartial mind was required to assess the validity of the debt, and Mr. Gillibrand's position did not allow for that.

The court awarded Bupa costs on a 2B basis up to 23 May 2013 and indemnity costs thereafter, due to Mr. Gillibrand's unsubstantiated and inflammatory allegations against Bupa. The court found that the allegations were baseless and contributed unnecessarily to the time and expense of the proceeding. The precise amount of costs was to be fixed by the Registrar, with any queries referred back to the court for decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.