Buller Coal Limited v Brightwater Engineers Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NELSON REGISTRY

CIV-2014-442-000054 [2015] NZHC 248

BETWEEN

BULLER COAL LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

BRIGHTWATER ENGINEERS LIMITED Defendant

Hearing: 23 February 2015 (Determined on the papers)

Counsel:

R J Gordon and D Mackenzie for Plaintiff
D G Hurd and S Stokes for Defendant

Judgment:

23 February 2015

COSTS JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE MATTHEWS

[1]      Buller Coal Limited (Buller) failed in its application to the Court for entry of summary judgment  against  Brightwater Engineers  Limited  (Brightwater).   Costs were reserved.  I have received a memorandum from Brightwater, seeking costs.  I have received a memorandum in opposition from Buller, saying costs should be reserved.   I have received a further memorandum from each counsel.   I have considered all this material.

[2]      When an application for summary judgment by a plaintiff is unsuccessful the general rule is that costs will be reserved, for a decision to be made once the final outcome of the proceeding has been established at trial.1   As noted in Air Nelson Ltd

v Airways Corporation of New Zealand Ltd,2  costs may be awarded in exceptional

cases.  Examples given by the Court are where the rules do not allow the summary judgment procedure to be invoked by a plaintiff or where a plaintiff proceeds in the

1      NZI Bank Ltd v Philpott [1990] 2 NZLR 403.

2      Air Nelson Ltd v Airways Corporation of New Zealand Ltd (1992) 6 PRNZ 1.

BULLER COAL LTD v BRIGHTWATER ENGINEERS LTD [2015] NZHC 248 [23 February 2015]

certain knowledge that there is a bona fide question of fact or law which can be determined only after a trial.

[3]      Both counsel referred the Court to other cases where, by one iteration or another, these principles have variously been applied.   I have considered all the submissions made by counsel, and reflected on them in the context of the judgment dismissing the application for summary judgment.

[4]      The first issue raised by Brightwater was the interpretation of cl 5.3(e) (the second).   This is dealt with at paragraphs [25] to [49] of the judgment.   It was necessary for Buller to establish that the contract was terminated prior to the completion of the services required by it, and some criticism can legitimately be levelled  at  Buller  for  not  focusing  its  evidence  on  precisely  what  the  services required by the contract were, and precisely which of those services remained uncompleted at the date it terminated the contract.  However, as can be seen by the review of the evidence, I ultimately reached a conclusion, and in my opinion it cannot be said that on this point Buller proceeded in the certain knowledge that this position could only be established after a trial.   Certainly its evidence could have been considerably more focused and frankly directed with precision at the point it needed to establish under this clause of the contract, but that does not bring it within an exception to the rule.

[5]      The second point Buller needed to establish was whether the contract for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Buller Coal Limited v Brightwater Engineers Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 248
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Buller Coal Limited sought summary judgment against Brightwater Engineers Limited, alleging breach of contract and seeking associated damages. The dispute centred on the interpretation and application of certain contractual clauses in a consultancy services agreement. The Court was tasked with deciding whether Buller could establish a right to summary judgment on the basis that Brightwater had failed to complete required services and that the contract was terminated for reasons other than Buller's convenience.

The key legal issues revolved around the interpretation of specific clauses within the contract and whether Buller could demonstrate that the contract was terminated prior to the completion of services, and that the termination was not for Buller's convenience. The Court had to assess whether Buller's evidence was sufficiently focused and precise to establish these points, and whether Buller's application for summary judgment was an abuse of process given the evident obstacles to its success.

The Court found that Buller's application for summary judgment was an abuse of process due to the clear obstacles identified in its own evidence. The Court concluded that Buller's reasons for termination were closely tied to its own operational challenges, rather than any failure by Brightwater. This finding fell within the exceptional circumstances that could justify awarding costs against the plaintiff in a summary judgment context. The Court awarded costs to Brightwater on a 2C basis, for the steps taken on the summary judgment application only, excluding the statement of defence.

The final orders of the Court awarded costs to Brightwater for seven days, with disbursements to be fixed by the Registrar, excluding those for a second counsel. All other costs were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established