| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND | CA19/02 |
| BETWEEN | ROWAN JOHN BRUCE AND OTHERS |
| Appellants |
| AND | BRIAN JOHN WHAKARUA EDWARDS AND ANOTHER |
| First Respondents |
| AND | MAORI LAND COURT OF NEW ZEALAND |
| Second Respondent |
| AND | HORITAMAKITERANGI MANUIRIRANGI AND RAMON HANATANA TITO |
| Third Respondents |
| Hearing: | 17 and 18 September 2002 |
| Coram: | Keith J Blanchard J Glazebrook J |
| Appearances: | R C Laurenson for Appellants R T Wilson for First Respondents G J J Stanish for Second Respondent (leave to withdraw) J M Dawson and K L Broughton for Third Respondents |
| Judgment: | 18 November 2002 |
| JUDGMENT OF THE COURT DELIVERED BY BLANCHARD J |
Introduction
This is a case of some complexity about the consequences of the making by the Maori Land Court of an order changing the status of some farmland in South Taranaki from Maori freehold land to General land. In its simplest terms, what happened is this. The Maori owners, Mr and Mrs Edwards, the first respondents, agreed to sell their farm to non-Maori purchasers, Mr and Mrs Bruce, subject to the making by the Maori Land Court of an order changing the land’s status to General land. The Maori Land Court was not told by the Edwards’ solicitor of the intention to sell the land. The Court did not require notice of the application for change of status to be served on the members of the preferred classes of alienees (the PCA), being the hapu to which the Edwards belong. So long as the land remained Maori freehold land the PCA had by virtue of s147(2) of the Te Ture Whenua Maori Act 1993 (the Act) a right of first refusal if it was to be alienated.
The change of status order was registered against the title to the land under the Land Transfer Act 1952. As a result, the land ceased to be Maori freehold land. The right of first refusal no longer applied. Mr and Mrs Bruce paid a substantial deposit to the Edwards, confirmed the sale of their own farm, purchased extra livestock and made ready to move on to the land. They nominated two family trusts as purchasers. The appellants are the trustees of those trusts. On the settlement date, but before settlement could occur, the Bruces discovered that some members of the PCA had caveated the title and were applying to the Maori Land Court for a rehearing of the change of status application seeking annulment of the change.
Settlement did not occur for that reason. But the Edwards and the Bruces came to an interim arrangement under which the Bruces took possession of the farm as lessees from the Edwards and provided the Edwards with funds, secured by second mortgage of the farm, with which the Edwards could meet commitments to buy other properties which they had made in reliance on the sale.
The Maori Land Court decided that there should be a rehearing, but the appellant trustee purchasers sought in the High Court a judicial review of that decision. The appellants counterclaimed seeking…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Bruce v Edwards and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] NZCA 294
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court held that section 125 of the Land Transfer Act 1952 applied to change of status orders, authorising the registration of such orders and any consequential amendments to the land title registration. The court found that the PCA, as members of the PCA, had a right to be notified of the application for a change of status order, to appear thereon and to raise matters of importance that might influence the Court’s discretion under section 136 of the Maori Land Act 1993. However, the court rejected the argument that the PCA had a right to first refusal similar to or through section 147(2) of the Maori Land Act 1993. The court held that the registration of a status order brought that order within the indefeasibility provision of section 62 of the Land Transfer Act 1952, protecting the registered proprietor against claims that the land enjoyed another status or that the status of the land was wrongfully obtained. The order was only susceptible to attack by statutory authority, such as fraud or annulment.
The court's decision was that the PCA had a right to be notified of the application for a change of status order and to raise matters of relevance, but they did not have a right to first refusal. The court also held that section 125 of the Land Transfer Act 1952 applied to change of status orders and that the registration of such orders brought them within the indefeasibility provision of section 62 of the same Act. The court found that the change of status order had been made in circumstances that were misleading and that the PCA's failure to mention the contract to sell the land in the context of the discussion with Judge Marumaru was misleading. The court concluded that the PCA were entitled to be notified of applications for change of status orders, to appear thereon and to raise matters of importance to them that might influence the Court’s discretion under section 136 of the Maori Land Act 1993.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Judge then considered whether s125 applied to change of status orders. It reads:125Alterations in registration of title – If any order that is annulled or revoked or varied, or if any other order or any instrument affected by the annulment or variation, has been registered by the District Land Registrar in respect of the title to any land, the later order shall be transmitted to that Registrar for registration, and all necessary consequential amendments in the registration of any title shall be made by the Registrar accordingly. The Judge was satisfied that s125 did apply to and authorise, in appropriate circumstances, amendment to the registration of status orders. He supported this view by referring to s140 which provides for registration of status orders under the Land Transfer Act by a process provided for in Part VI of the Act. Section 125 was within Part VI. Status orders are subject to the registration regime. Part of that regime is the power to alter registration of orders in respect of the title to any land. This conclusion by the Judge has not been challenged on appeal. In dealing with the argument of Mr Manuirirangi and Mr Tito that, as members of the PCA, they had a right to be notified of the application for a change of status order, Ronald Young J rejected the view that there had in effect been a sale of Maori freehold land and thus an “alienation” triggering rights of first refusal. The Judge was of the opinion that the land was being sold as General land. There was only to be a sale if the land became General land. But he proceeded to review the circumstances in which the change of status order had been made, including the submissions which had been made by Mr Bulfin to Judge Marumaru. He found that counsel’s failure to mention the contract to sell the land in the context of the discussion with Judge Marumaru was misleading. He was in no doubt that the fact of a conditional sale was relevant to the residual discretion of the Maori Land Court in s136. That discretion could be exercised properly only after all the facts were known. The Maori Land Court needed to know all transactions affecting the land and would wish to know about the views of the PCA. Ronald Young J’s assessment of the Act led him to the conclusion that the PCA were entitled to be notified of applications for change of status orders, to appear thereon and to raise matters of importance to them that might influence the Court’s discretion under s136. But they were not entitled to first refusal rights similar to or through s147(2). He said that an order changing the status of the land would, while the land remained General land, remove the rights of the PCA to exercise in the future their s147(2) rights of first refusal. Those rights existed only while the land was Maori freehold land. The change of status therefore significantly affected the rights of the PCA. They should be served with such proceedings and provided with the opportunity of raising matters of relevance. Their views as to the change of status order were relevant factors for the Maori Land Court to take into account. The Judge also expressed the view that the registration of a status order brings that order within the indefeasibility provision of s62 of the Land Transfer Act. The status of land is part of the estate or interest in the land, the Judge said. Registration of the status order would protect the registered proprietor against claims that the land enjoyed another status or that the status of the land was wrongfully obtained, “outside of the statutory exceptions allowing disputation.” Once registered, the order was susceptible to attack only by statutory authority, here the Land Transfer Act (e.g. fraud, wrongfulness) and the Act (e.g. annulment).