Brownlow v Ministry of Social Development

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CRI-2013-485-74 [2013] NZHC 3538

STEPHANIE SANDRA BROWNLOW

v

MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT

Hearing: 12 November 2013

Counsel:

C Ross for Appellant
M J Ferrier for Crown

Judgment:

20 December 2013

JUDGMENT OF WILLIAMS J

[1]      The  appellant  appeals  against  a  sentence  of  22  months’  imprisonment imposed by Judge Hobbs in the District Court.1   The essence of the appeal is that the Judge erred in reaching the conclusion that imprisonment was the least restrictive outcome in the circumstances.

Facts

[2]      The appellant was convicted of 20 charges comprising:

(a)       using  a  document  for  pecuniary  advantage  against  now  repealed s 229A of the Crimes Act 1961 (x4);

(b)      using a document against s 228(b) of the Crimes Act 1961 (x14);

1      Ministry of Social Development v Brownlow DC Wellington CRI-2013-032-111, 11 September

2013.

BROWNLOW v MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT [2013] NZHC 3538 [20 December 2013]

(c)       obtaining a pecuniary advantage by deception against s 240 of the

Crimes Act 1961 (x1); and

(d)using an altered document to defraud against now repealed s 266B of the Crimes Act 1961 (x1).

[3]      A description of the appellant’s offending is as follows.

[4]      On 29 March 2000, the appellant applied for a sickness benefit in her married name.  She was given a sickness benefit at the single rate when she was living in a de facto relationship.  She was aware of, and failed to comply with, her obligations to tell the Ministry of Social Development about that relationship or any change in her circumstances since the grant of the benefit.  From 2001 to October 2012, the appellant used a further 17 forms or documents to claim benefits she was not entitled to.   In addition to claiming a sickness benefit, the appellant also claimed an accommodation supplement, special benefit, disability allowance and New Zealand superannuation.

[5]      On 17 January 2005, the appellant began employment under a different name. She did not tell the Ministry of Social Development of her employment.  As a result, she was not entitled to receive the benefit from 2005 to July 2009.  On 29 March

2000, the appellant altered an insurance policy schedule in support of her accommodation supplement.  The total sum overpaid to the appellant over the period of 12 years was $181,571.59.

[6]      The appellant is 69 years of age.  She suffers from a number of health issues including asthma, chronic obstructive respiratory disease, high blood pressure, heart irregularities, elevated cholesterol, anxiety and depression.

District Court decision

[7]      Judge Hobbs set a starting point of three years’ imprisonment, taking into account the significant amount of money involved, the repetitive nature of the offending over a 12 year period and the high degree of dishonesty on the part of the

appellant.2      The  Judge  reduced  the  sentence  by  six  months  for  the  appellant’s personal circumstances, taking into account her personal health problems, feelings of remorse, efforts to repay the sum overpaid and her lack of previous convictions for dishonesty.3  The Judge gave the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brownlow v Ministry of Social Development and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 3538
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal against a sentence of 22 months' imprisonment imposed by Judge Hobbs in the District Court was heard by Williams J in the High Court of New Zealand. The appellant argued that the Judge erred in concluding that imprisonment was the least restrictive outcome in the circumstances. The appellant had been convicted on 20 charges of using documents for pecuniary advantage, using a document against the Crimes Act, obtaining a pecuniary advantage by deception, and using an altered document to defraud. The offending had occurred over a 12-year period, resulting in a total sum overpaid of $181,571.59. The Judge had set a starting point of three years' imprisonment, reduced by six months for the appellant's personal circumstances and a further 25 per cent for her guilty plea. The Judge had concluded that home detention would not be an appropriate sentence, particularly as it would not be a sentence of sufficient deterrent value.

The legal issue before the court was the correct approach to appeal against the refusal to grant home detention. The appellant argued that the Judge erred by giving insufficient weight to the appellant's age and health and excessive weight to deterrence and denunciation. The respondent submitted that the Court of Appeal in James v R misstated the test by referring to "insufficient or excessive" weight and that the orthodox approach to the review of a discretion as set out in May v May should be followed. The court found that this was not a case where the learned sentencing Judge applied weightings to the admittedly relevant factors he considered in a manner that could be described as "plainly wrong." The appeal was dismissed accordingly.

The final orders of the court were that the appeal against the sentence of 22 months' imprisonment imposed by Judge Hobbs in the District Court be dismissed. The court found that the Judge was right to conclude that denunciation was important in cases such as these where the State relies to a significant extent on the honesty of the beneficiary. The court also found that the Judge was right to express some degree of scepticism in respect of the appellant's health given the fact that she was working 32 hours per week at the time and to conclude the medical condition could be effectively managed in prison.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established